CLEVELAND — Dozens of people gathered outside of the City Club of Cleveland to protest a sold-out Q&A session on “Faith, Policy and Influence.”
What You Need To Know
- The City Club of Cleveland prides itself on being one of the oldest free speech organization in the country
- It’s now under fire for inviting Aaron Baer, the president of the Center for Christian Virtue
- The nonprofit organization is one of the most influential advocacy groups in Ohio, and it’s been labeled a hate group twice by the Southern Poverty Law Center for its rhetoric on the LGBTQ+ community
- The Center for Christian Virtue also backed House Bill 68, which bans gender-affirming care for transgender youth and was a large proponent for legislation that bans diversity, equity and inclusion in higher education
More than 100 LGBTQ+ leaders called on the City Club to cancel or modify the forum in the weeks leading up to the event in a public letter to the organization’s board of director and its CEO Dan Moulthrop. In a written response, the City Club acknowledged the forum’s “controversial topic” but said it is continuing its role “to provide a space where speakers can be questioned directly.”
Elizabeth Katavich is the lead advocacy coordinator at the LGBT Center of Greater Cleveland. She said, she’s concerned Baer’s comments could be detrimental to gender diverse and marginalized communities.
“We see it time and time again. There are countless statistics from the Trevor Project and many other organizations showing what a devastating effect it can have for major organizations like this to be given a platform,” Katavich said.
The City Club of Cleveland said it is “focused on achieving diversity in ideology” of speakers and topics and will continue to be a place to “hear from candidates, lawmakers and policy leaders,” including ones the public may not agree with.
Amanda Cole, Executive Director of Plexus LGBT & Ally Chamber of Commerce, said not enough action was taken by the City Club to mitigate the potential impact of Baer’s conversation.
“I’m concerned that there was a lack of care in the framing of how this forum was put together. They absolutely have an impact on legislation and democracy, the shape of democracy in Ohio,” Cole said.
While some audience members joined the LGBT Center in wearing lavender as a non-disruptive sign of support, others met across the street at Play House Square for “a public celebration of queer faith.”
“By wearing lavender, by having strong visibility and a strong presence, and collective unity … we’re trying to build an effort both inside and outside, all across the board to show that we’re still here,” Katavich said.
Baer spoke to forum attendees about a variety of issues, including a recent spike in suicides among transgender and non binary youth, which he said, are not directly linked to a growing number of anti-LGBTQ+ policies despite key findings from several advocacy groups, health experts and researchers.
He also accused pediatric clinics of causing irreparable harm to children seeking gender-affirming care.’
“Children are being sterilized for life, and so they’re being harmed irreparably is not loving them,” Baer said. “… No child was ever born in the wrong. Not telling a child you were born to the wrong body is, is a heinous act.”
According to the National Association of Social Workers, hormone replacement therapy (HRT) temporarily pauses puberty and is reversible; and while the treatment is safe for most teens and adults, the medication is typically prescribed to people age 18 and older.
Trans Ohio, the state’s first statewide transgender equity group, wrote in a statement to Spectrum News that regardless of Friday’s discussion, “Trans and gender diverse people have existed in every culture around the world throughout recorded history,” and that the community will always “be a part of society and a part of Ohio.
And while many have denounced the City Club’s actions, others have expressed their support, including Republican U.S. Sen. Bernie Moreno who cited the group’s right to free speech on social media.
In the end, Cole said she hopes the community’s presence sends a message of positivity and resilience.
“So my hope would be that if you’re frustrated, if you’re upset today, that you continue to let the City Club know, the board of directors know,” Cole said. “But also put that energy towards supporting the LGBTQ organizations that really, really need it so that we can support LGBTQ people to live full lives.”
Here are some more photos from Friday: