Home prices keep going up, defying mortgage rates at 23-year highs and a housing market that hasn’t been this unaffordable since the 1980s. Everything looks steady on the surface but prolonged national U.S. home price declines could be around the corner for the first time in more than a decade, according to one housing expert.
Continue reading this article with a Barron’s subscription.
The average house price in the U.K. fell 1.9%, or 7,012 pounds ($8,938) in the month to August 12–the biggest fall in asking prices in a month since 2018–according to new data from Rightmove released on Monday.
The average price of property coming to the market fell on month to GBP364,895, outpacing the usual summer slowdown of a drop of 0.9% for the month, the online property portal said. On an annual basis, house prices fell 0.1%, swinging from growth of 0.5% in July.
This bigger-than-average dip indicates some sellers are taking the initiative to price competitively, and tempt buyers that might be more preoccupied with holidays, inflation and the highest interest rates since 2008, Rightmove said.
“While a 1.9% drop in just one month seems dramatic, it’s in part an expected seasonal drop as sellers coming to market realise that they have to compromise on price due to the traditionally quieter summer holiday period,” Rightmove property-science director Tim Bannister said.
First-time buyer asking prices slipped 0.9% on month to GBP223,614, and were down 0.2% on year. Second-stepper prices fell 0.8% on month to GBP338,137, while top-of-the-ladder homes fell furthest, slipping 3.4% to GBP664,756.
Agreed sales were 15% behind levels seen in the more normal, prepandemic year of 2019, worse than the month before which was 12% below 2019’s figure. First-time buyer demand, however, is holding up better and is down just 10% compared with 2019, partly due to record rents and scarce rental properties.
“The lower level of agreed sales compared to this time in 2019 indicates the affordability challenges that many buyers currently face. However, with sales holding up more strongly in the typical first-time buyer sector, the prospect [of] owning your own home remains an appealing option for those that can afford it, with the alternative being an extremely frenzied rental market, where rents are at record levels,” Bannister said.
The portal measured 123,692 prices across the U.K. over the period of July 9 to Aug. 12.
The housing market may feel out of whack to home buyers coping with fast-rising home prices and 7% mortgage rates. But like it or not, the housing market is in the pink of health.
Several economic indicators that measure housing activity — from home prices to sentiment surveys — show that home builders and sellers (the few that are out there) are finding strong demand from home buyers.
News of the housing market’s relative health may be welcome to some — like real-estate agents and investors — but it’s becoming a concern for economists. The more buoyant the housing market, economists say, the more likely the U.S. Federal Reserve will unveil another interest-rate hike, which further heightens the risk of a recession.
“‘The housing market has started to recover, and this is a problem for the Fed because more demand for housing will boost home prices and rents.’”
— Torsten Slok, chief economist at Apollo
“The housing market has started to recover, and this is a problem for the Fed because more demand for housing will boost home prices and rents,” Torsten Slok, chief economist at Apollo, wrote in a note in May. And housing is a big part of how the government measures inflation, he added. This will make it more difficult to reduce inflation from 5% to the Fed’s 2% inflation target, he said.
If the Fed launches another rate hike, it would push mortgage rates, which are already in the 7% range, to go even higher.
“The housing market is in a very — if fragile — recovery,” Mike Simonsen, founder and president of real-estate analytics firm Altos Research, told MarketWatch.
“There appears to be more demand than available supply for homes, especially in the real-estate market,” he explained, which is keeping home prices high, but that doesn’t mean demand could evaporate if the current situation changes. Recall when rates doubled from pandemic-era lows in 2021 to 7% last year, which zapped home-buying momentum.
House hunters have adjusted their expectations. But if rates were to jump from 7% today to even higher levels, “I would not be at all surprised if homebuyers stopped abruptly again,” Simonsen said, stating his thesis for the fragility of the sector. Americans broadly expect rates to go over 8%, according to a March survey by the New York Federal Reserve.
MarketWatch looked at three housing-market indicators — and the picture looks rosier than ever:
Active listings are down — blame interest rates
Redfin’s deputy chief economist, Taylor Marr, said his go-to indicator was active listings.
Active listings are down this spring, compared to the previous year, according to the company’s data. At the end of June, the number of homes listed for sale on the market was down 8.1% over the prior year.
“It really captures that supply is pulling back significantly relative to demand,” Marr said.
Redfin data says that active listings of homes are down.
As a result, the housing market is seeing an excess of demand and not enough supply, which has led to a resurgence of bidding wars in some parts of the U.S.
While this metric is showing signs of the housing market returning to life and heating up amid a shortage of houses for sale, Marr said he’s not yet ready to call it a recovery. “It’s hard to declare completely the bottom of the housing market,” he said.
Still battle-scarred by the housing crash of the Great Recession, Marr said economists “might be hesitant” to say that the housing market is in recovery mode. “We still have a lot of uncertainty with the economy ahead,” he added. “If the economy really takes a turn three or four months from now for whatever reason, it could certainly bring the housing market back lower than it was even last November,” he added.
The price gap between new and existing homes
With a major shortage of resale homes, new-home sales have been taking off.
Home builders, understandably, are thrilled about the inventory shortage.
The National Association of Home Builders measures builders’ sentiment in a monthly index, and that indicator has been very cheery of late. In June, the index turned positive for the first time in nearly a year. Builders were scaling back price reductions; they were happy about current sales conditions as well as sales over the next six months, the NAHB said.
“A bottom is forming for single-family home building as builder sentiment continues to gradually rise from the beginning of the year,” said Rob Dietz, chief economist of the NAHB.
One of the major U.S. home builders, Lennar, also offered some commentary on its second-quarter earnings call last month. The company’s executive chairman, Stuart Miller, said that “the market and the economy will remain constructive for home builders as pent-up demand continues to come to market and consume affordable offerings.”
Miller also doesn’t expect the supply issue to be fixed anytime soon: “We believe that the supply constraint will continue to limit available inventory and maintain supply-demand balance,” he said on the call. “The core elements of the supply shortage will not resolve in the near term as the almost 15-year production deficit will take years to resolve.”
Home-builder confidence, as a result, is signaling high optimism about the future of the housing market, and a return to normalcy.
Builders have ramped up building new single-family and multi-family homes.
Ali Wolf, chief economist at Zonda, looks at how prices of new homes trend relative to resale homes as a key indicator of the health of the housing market. Her conclusion? Housing industry professionals involved in the construction and sale of new homes are out of a recession, given the robust demand.
In fact, demand has been so strong that new homes — generally considered to be more expensive than resales — have become more affordable in home buyers’ eyes given the competition in the existing home space.
Typically, new homes are 20% more expensive than resales, Wolf said. And today? That spread has fallen to 4%.
So what’s going on? Builders are not necessarily slashing prices. Instead, existing home prices have risen as homeowners are reluctant to sell.
That’s a good deal for buyers. New homes, Wolf said, are traditionally considered a “luxury good.” They’re brand new, and buyers can often customize them. They also require less maintenance than older homes.
Sellers are holding out on cutting prices
Simonsen, who leads Altos Research, said price cuts were his go-to indicator to gauge the health of the real-estate market. Specifically, price cuts formed a proxy for demand, he explained.
“When the houses are on the market, if there are no buyers for the current houses that are listed, people start taking price cuts,” Simonsen said.
And to be clear, price cuts jumped last year, when rates jumped, he added.
But that dynamic has since changed, as seen in the chart below. “There are currently fewer price reductions now than in 2018 or 2019,” Simonsen said.
Data from Redfin says that homeowners aren’t cutting prices on their homes when selling, possibly due to strong interest from buyers.
And for those of you holding out for home prices to crash? Keep waiting, Simonsen said.
“There’s nothing in the data that shows prices crash,” he said. Even if a recession hits at the end of the year, which results in more job layoffs, demand for home-buying falling, and an increase in foreclosures and distress, that’s still a few years from now, he added.
“There’s no signal of home prices crashing anywhere,” Simonsen added.
If you’re a retiree and you’re trying to square the circle of rising costs, longer lifespans, more expensive medical care and turbulent markets, don’t be afraid to run the numbers on your biggest investment.
That would be your home — if you own it.
U.S. house prices are now so high that it is almost impossible for seniors not to ask themselves the obvious question: “Should we cash in, invest the money, and rent?”
Right now the average U.S. house price is nearly $360,000. That’s about a third higher than just a few years ago, before the COVID-19 pandemic. The lockdowns, the panic, the stimulus checks and 2.5% mortgage rates have all passed into history. But the sky-high prices remain — for now.
After several years of double-digit percentage increases, apartment-rent growth is falling for only the second time since the 2008 financial crisis. WSJ’s Will Parker joins host J.R. Whalen to discuss.
There is a similar story for seniors. Federal data show that the average U.S. house price is now nearly 17 times the average annual Social Security benefit — an even higher ratio than it was in August 2008, just before Lehman Brothers collapsed. At that juncture, the average house price was 15 times higher.
U.S. National Home Price Index vs. average rent of primary residence in U.S. city, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Indexed: January 1987=100.
S&P/Case-Shiller
Our simple chart, above, compares average U.S. home prices with average U.S. rents, going back to 1987. (The chart simply shows the ratio, indexed to 100.) The bottom line? House prices are very high at the moment compared with rents — again, prices are about where they were in 2006-07.
And the two must run in tandem over the long term, because the economic value of owning a house is not having to pay rent to live there.
If there are times when, in general, it makes more financial sense for seniors to rent than to own, this has to be one of those.
Seniors who own their own homes may think high interest rates on new mortgages don’t affect them. They most likely either already have a mortgage at a lower, older rate or they’ve paid off their home loan. But if you want to sell, you’ll almost certainly be selling to someone who needs a mortgage.
If borrowing costs drive down real-estate prices, seniors who hold off on selling may miss out on gains they may never see again. After the last housing peak, in 2006, it took a full decade for prices to recover fully. Those who sold when the going was good had the chance to buy lifetime annuities at excellent rates or to invest in stocks and bonds that overall rose about 80% over the same period.
Incidentally, there is also an exchange-traded fund that invests in residential REITs, Armada’s Residential REIT ETF HAUS, -0.53%,
though in addition to single-family homes and apartment-complex operators, about 25% of the fund is invested in companies involved in manufactured-home parks and senior-living facilities.
For each person, the math will be different, and there are a number of questions you need to ask. Where do you want to live? How much would you get if you sold your house? How much would you pay in taxes? How much would it cost to rent the right place? Do you want to leave a property to your heirs? And what would be the costs of moving — both financial and emotional?
The conventional wisdom is that you should own your home in retirement.
“I would advise any and all retirees against renting if at all possible,” says Malcolm Ethridge, a financial planner at CIC Wealth in Rockville, Md. “You need your costs to be as fixed as possible during retirement, to match your income being fixed as well. If you choose to rent, you’re leaving it up to your landlord to determine whether and by how much your No. 1 expense will increase each year. And that makes it very tough to determine how much you are able to allocate toward everything else in your budget for the month.”
A key point here, from federal data, is that nationwide rents have risen year after year, almost without a break, at least since the early 1980s. They even rose during the global financial crisis, with just one 12-month period where they fell — and then by only 0.1%.
“My general advice for clients is that owning a home with no mortgage in retirement is the best scenario, as housing is typically the highest cost we pay monthly,” says Adam Wojtkowski, an adviser at Copper Beech Wealth Management in Mansfield, Mass. “It’s not always the case that it works out this way, but if you can enter retirement with no mortgage, it makes it a lot easier for everything to fall into place, so to speak, when it comes to retirement-income planning.”
“Renting comes with a lot of risk,” says Brian Schmehil, a planner with the Mather Group in Chicago. “If you rent, you are subject to the whims of your landlord, and a high inflationary environment could put pressure on your finances as you get older.”
But it’s not always that simple.
“With housing costs as high as they are now though, renting may be a viable solution, at least for the moment,” says Wojtkowski. “We don’t know what the housing-market trends will be going forward, but if someone is waiting for a housing-market crash before they move, they could very likely be waiting for a long time. We just don’t know.”
“Any decision comes with pros and cons,” says Schmehil. “Selling when your home values are historically high and renting allows you to capture the equity in your home, which is usually a retiree’s largest or second-largest financial asset. These extra funds allow you to spend more money on yourself in retirement without having to worry about doing a reverse mortgage or selling later in retirement, when it may be harder for you to do so.”
Renting also allows you to be more flexible about where you live, for example nearer your children or grandchildren, he adds.
And as any experienced property owner knows, renting also brings another benefit: You no longer have to do as much work around the house.
“Renting is great in that you don’t need to maintain a residence,” says Ann Covington Alsina, a financial planner running her own firm in Annapolis, Md. “If the dishwasher breaks or the roof leaks, the landlord is responsible.”
Wojtkowski agrees, noting that many people no longer want to spend time mowing the lawn or shoveling snow in retirement. “Ultimately, one of the things that I’ve seen most retirees most concerned with is eliminating the general upkeep [and] maintenance of homeownership in retirement,” he says.
Several planners — including Covington Alsina and Wojtkowski — note that one alternative to selling and renting is simply downsizing. This can free up capital, especially when home prices are high, like now, without leaving you exposed to rising rents.
Many baby boomers have been doing exactly that.
Meanwhile, I am reminded of my late friend Vincent Nobile, who — after a long and fruitful life owning homes and raising a family — found himself widowed and alone in his 80s. He rented a small cottage on a New England sound and said how glad he was that he never had to worry about maintaining the roof or the appliances, or fixing the plumbing or the heating, or any one of a thousand other irritations. Or paying property taxes — which go down even more rarely than rents.
When the regular drives to Boston got too onerous, he moved into the city and rented there. And he was glad to do it. The money he had made was all in investments — a lot less hassle both for him and his heirs.
I once asked him if he would prefer to own his own home. He shook his head and laughed.
Data on the U.S. consumer and housing market, plus several notable earnings reports, will be this week’s highlights. Barring any surprises, federal financial regulators’ Congressional testimony will be the main event on the banking front.
On Wednesday, Fed Vice Chair for Supervision Michael Barr and Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. Chairman Martin Gruenberg are scheduled to testify before the House Financial Services Committee. They’ll discuss the collapses of Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank and efforts to maintain confidence in the U.S. banking system.
The numbers: The S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller 20-city house price index fell 0.5% in October, its fourth monthly decline.
Year-over-year prices rose rose 8.6%, slowing from 10.4% in the previous month.
A broader measure of home prices, the national index, fell a seasonally adjusted 0.3% in October from September.
A separate report from the Federal Housing Finance Agency showed home prices remaining flat in October, down from a 0.1% gain the prior month.
And over the last year, the FHFA index was up 9.8%.
Key details: Miami, Tampa, and Charlotte reported the highest year-over-year gains among the 20 cities in October. All 20 cities reported lower price increases.
San Francisco and Seattle reported the lowest year-over-year gains, which have seen prices fall by more than 10% from a peak in May.
Big picture: Housing is in a slowdown, but affordability hasn’t returned. Homes are still expensive, as mortgage rates remain above 6%, and inventory of homes available for sale remains low.
What S&P said: “As the Federal Reserve continues to move interest rates higher, mortgage financing continues to be a headwind for home prices,” Craig J. Lazzara, managing director at S&P DJI, said.
“Given the continuing prospects for a challenging macroeconomic environment, prices may well continue to weaken,” he added.
Market reaction: The Dow Jones Industrial Average DJIA, -0.22%
and the S&P 500 SPX, -0.63%
were up in early trading on Tuesday. The yield on the 10-year Treasury note TMUBMUSD10Y, 3.807%
rose above 3.81%.
The Federal Reserve still has a chance to meet both of its main goals — strong economic growth and stable prices — but time is running out to achieve a soft landing.
The problem is that Fed officials are fixated on raising interest rates FF00, +0.00%
several more times, including another supersize increase at their meeting Tuesday and Wednesday. They don’t seem to notice that inflation is already retreating significantly, while growth is dangerously close to stalling out.
They have a blind spot because they are looking at the past.
Fed officials ought to reach out to another government agency that has had remarkable success in achieving soft landings: The National Aeronautics and Space Administration.
NASA’s scientists know something the Fed has forgotten: It takes a long time to send and receive messages from space, so they need to account for those delays when sending instructions to their spacecraft so they can land safely on Mars, or orbit Saturn or the moons of Jupiter.
Compounding errors
It’s the same way with the economy. The signals that the Fed receives from the economy are often delayed, sometimes by months. Unfortunately, one of the main signals the Fed is relying upon right now to decide how much to raise interest rates is delayed by a year or more.
I’m talking about inflation in the price of putting a roof over our heads. Shelter prices are now the leading contributor to increases in the consumer price index (CPI) and the personal consumption expenditure (PCE) price index. But because of the way the CPI for shelter is constructed — for very good reasons — the inflation reported today reflects conditions as they were 12 to 18 months ago.
The error is compounded because shelter prices are by far the largest component of the CPI, at more than 30%.
The Fed is disappointed that inflation hasn’t declined more since it began raising interest rates in March, but how could it when the signals about shelter prices were sent last summer and fall, long before the housing market began to cool in response to higher interest rates TMUBMUSD10Y, 4.049%
and the reductions in the Fed’s holdings of mortgage-backed securities?
According to real-time data, shelter prices are no longer rising at a near-10% annual rate as the CPI and PCE price index claim. Growth in rents and house prices has slowed since the first rate hikes in March. House prices are actually falling in most regions of the country, and private-sector measures of rents show that landlords are now dropping rents in many cities.
Just like a radio signal from Jupiter, it takes time for that message to be received by the CPI. It will be received and incorporated into the CPI eventually, but by then it may be too late for the Fed to react. The Fed might crash the spacecraft because it mistakenly believes the messages it gets are in real time.
Growth is slowing
The Fed’s blind spot puts the economy in peril. Recent data show that growth is naturally slowing from the breakneck pace following the pandemic shutdowns but also from the Fed’s relentless squeeze on financial conditions.
It’s very hard to argue that the economy is still overheating. Domestic demand has stalled out since the spring. Final sales to domestic purchasers — which covers consumer spending and business investment — has grown at a 0.3% annual pace over the past two quarters.
Real disposable incomes are growing at less than 1% annualized. Household wealth has fallen off a cliff, with the stock market SPX, -0.41%
DJIA, -0.24%
in a bear market and home equity beginning to fall. Wage growth is beginning to slow. Supply chains are improving.
And the CPI excluding shelter has gone from rising at a 14% annual pace in the spring when the tightening began, to falling at a 1% annual pace over the past three months. Rate hikes are working!
This benign picture on inflation may not persist. Inflation is still worrisome, particularly for essentials such as food, health care, new vehicles and utilities.
But the Fed should adopt a more balanced view of the economy, no matter what the signals from the past say. No one wants a hard landing.
The whipsaw action wasn’t limited to stocks, and was described by Rick Rieder, the chief investment officer for global fixed income at BlackRock, as “one of the craziest days” of his career.
The bond market’s warning
Some investors who focus on stocks might not realize that the bond market is much larger, and that its movements can cause government and central-bank policies to shift. Larry McDonald, founder of The Bear Traps Report and author of “A Colossal Failure of Common Sense,” which described the 2008 failure of Lehman Brothers, explained just how bad the action was in the U.K. bond market over the past few weeks, when 30-year government bonds issued in December traded as low as 24 cents on the dollar. He also predicted what will happen if the Federal Reserve continues on its current course of interest-rate increases.
Michael Brush argues the Federal Reserve is moving too quickly to raise interest rates and cool the U.S. economy. He expects a rapid decline in inflation and a new bull market for stocks. In a column, he shares five sentiment indicators that suggest it is time to buy stocks — especially this group of companies.
Time for a refreshing COLA if you are on Social Security
Getty Images
The Social Security Administration has announced that its cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) for 2023 will be 8.7%, the largest increase in four decades. There is more to the story, including tax implications and changes to Medicare, as Jessica Hall and Alessandra Malito explain.
Freddie Mac said interest rates on 30-year mortgage loans averaged 6.92% on Oct. 13, up from 3.05% a year earlier. Mortgage Daily said rates had hit 7.10% — the highest in 20 years — and economists are warning these levels could be a “new normal.”
A homeowner locked-in with a low interest rate on their mortgage loan will be reluctant to sell. And some would-be buyers may now be priced out of the market because of much higher loan payments. Here’s what economists expect for home prices in 2023.
This is why Florida’s insurance market is such a mess
Florida insurers are not only suffering from storm-damage payouts.
Joe Raedle/Getty Images
Hurricanes are nothing new to Floridians, but insurers in the state are losing money even though premiums have doubled over the past five years. Shahid S. Hamid, the director of the Laboratory for Insurance at Florida International University, explains why the Florida insurance market is so distorted.
Here’s a travel option you may never have heard of — home swapping
Villefranche-sur-mer on the French Riviera.
istock
Home swapping can give you an opportunity to live as a local in a faraway place while spending much less than you would as a tourist. Here’s how it works.
Want more from MarketWatch? Sign up for this and other newsletters, and get the latest news, personal finance and investing advice.
This week Freddie Mac said the average interest rate on a 30-year mortgage loan in the U.S. had climbed to 6.70% from 6.29% the week before and 6.02% two weeks ago. The average rate a year ago was 3.01%.
Would-be sellers who have low-rate mortgage loans are reluctant if it means they need to take out a new loan to fund their next home. Would-be buyers are forced out of the market, as the monthly principal and interest payment for a new 30-year loan, based on Freddie Mac’s figures, has increased 53% from a year ago.
Home-sale contracts are being canceled at a record pace in some areas.
The dollar has strengthened as the Federal Reserve has taken the lead among central banks in raising interest rates. This is reverberating across the world, making it more costly for countries to make interest payments on dollar-denominated debt and increasing the cost of any commodity traded in dollars.
The rising dollar lowers prices on imported goods for Americans and can also lower their international travel costs. But Michael Wilson, Morgan Stanley’s chief equity strategist, warns that earnings for the S&P 500 SPX, -1.51%
would decline as a direct result of the strong dollar and called the current foreign-exchange backdrop an “untenable situation” for the stock market.
This is what happens when bearish sentiment runs high
Michael Brush interviews David Baron, co-manager of the Baron Focused Growth Fund BFGFX, -0.76%,
who describes opportunities cropping up as institutional investors dump stocks. He also explains his winning long-term strategy, which has included a very long-term investment in Tesla Inc. TSLA, -1.10%.
When interest rates rise, bond prices fall. But it also means that if you have money to put to work, bond yields have become much more attractive.
Khuram Chaudhry, a European equity quantitative strategist at JPMorgan in London, makes the case for buying bonds now.
What about preferred stocks?
Getty Images/iStockphoto
Preferred stocks feature stated dividend yields and prices that move the same way bond prices do. That means prices for many issues are now heavily discounted to face value and that current yields are much higher than they were at the end of 2021. Here’s an in-depth guide on how to research preferred stocks and make your own selections.
Stanley Druckenmiller predicted a “hard landing” in 2023 for the U.S. economy while speaking at CNBC’s Delivering Alpha Investor Summit on Sept. 28.
Bloomberg
Stanley Druckenmiller predicted a U.S. recession in 2023 as a result of monetary policy tightening by the Federal Reserve. That may not be much of a stretch, considering that the U.S. economy contracted during the first half of 2022, according to revised GDP figures from the Bureau of Economic Analysis.
After the new U.K. government of Prime Minister Liz Truss announced a massive tax cut along with a new spending program to help counter rising fuel costs and new borrowing, the pound hit a new low against the dollar on Sept. 26 as investors and money managers panicked and sold-off U.K. government bonds. Steve Goldstein explains how and why the Bank of England came tot the rescue.
After Tesla CEO Elon Musk said the upcoming Cybertruck would be sufficiently waterproof to “serve briefly as a boat,” the San Francisco Bay Ferry offered this advice to patrons.
Want more from MarketWatch? Sign up for this and other newsletters, and get the latest news, personal finance and investing advice.