There is nothing like an adult romance to refresh our TBR list! It may or may not be a guilty pleasure of ours. And we love sharing our wide range of book reviews with all of you. Wicked Believer by Kait Ballenger is a spicy, dark romance transforming New York City into the Seven Deadly Sins’ playground.
Wicked Believer is the second book in the Original Sinners trilogy, picking up only days after the end of book one. As a new divine being, Charlotte must navigate her increasingly complicated relationship with Lucifer and her role in the pending war among the celestials.
This sequel delivers even more drama, secrets, and spice, of course. Here are three things we love about Kait Ballenger’s Wicked Believer!
Image Source: Amazon Publishing
Book Overview: Wicked Believer
Content warnings: heavy themes of religious trauma, religiously motivated hate speech, mentions of forced marriage, forced pregnancy, and emotional, physical, and sexual abuse, stalking, drinking, drug use, graphic violence, religious genocide, mass murder, swearing (Please read at your discretion!)
Summary:I wasn’t always immortal. And I’m not sure I’ll ever get the hang of it. Not like Lucifer, a.k.a. Pride. He and the other seven deadly sins, the high-profile billionaires who run this city, make the divine life look easy.
I came to New York a good, if damaged, Christian girl. Then Lucifer opened my eyes to the darkness. To the hunger burning inside me. To a world of pain and pleasure like nothing I’ve ever known. Now it’s all I crave. He’s all I crave.
But as I grapple with this new existence―and the events that led me to it―unseen forces push me and Lucifer apart. Paparazzi track my every move, Lucifer’s family plays their wicked games, and I hardly know who I am anymore. Or who I’m meant to be.
A celestial war is brewing, and Lucifer’s siblings are out for blood―and the dark power inside me calls me to join the fight.
The Spice
We’re not ashamed to admit that the spice in Wicked Believer is hot, hot, hot! Charlotte and Lucifer stay ready to jump each other’s bones, and we don’t blame them one bit! The tension, the BDSM scenes, and of course, the aftercare are top-tier. Charlotte even has wicked fantasies of her own, though she still grapples with the complicated feelings of shame that ensue. If you thought book one was steamy, then wait until you read the sequel!
Lucifer’s Character Development
While we loved Charlotte’s character development in the first book, Lucifer’s personal journey in Wicked Believer definitely stood out to us. He’s forced to rethink his possessiveness over Charlotte. Lucifer also struggles with an inability to confide in Charlotte, so as not to make her worried about him. But that only backfires and pushes the two of them apart. Lucifer must learn the importance of choice and truly fight for their relationship if they have any hopes of making it in the long run.
A New Love Interest
Another thing we love about Wicked Believer is the appearance of a new love interest. We won’t give away his name yet, though. He appears exclusively in Charlotte’s dreams and flashbacks in Original Sinner and the first quarter of the sequel. To sweeten the deal, he even has a long history with Lucifer. We were not expecting how obsessed we’d be over their three-way romance, but we can’t wait to see how their relationship develops in the next installment of this series.
Packed with more drama, character development, and spice, we’ve become even more invested in Kait Ballenger’s brilliant new sequel, Wicked Believer!
Wicked Believer by Kait Ballenger comes out September 9th, and you can order a copy of it here!
What did you need of Kait Ballenger’s new sequel, Wicked Believer? Are you as hooked on this series as we are? Let us know on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram!
Content Warnings: death of a parent, grief, arson, murder, violence, mental health struggles, abandonment, sexual content, manipulation
Summary: When 18-year-old River Santos loses everything after her house burns down, someone anonymously donates two million dollars to her GoFundMe. It’s like she’s won the worst sort of lottery. She’s a millionaire, but at what cost?
With every person who comes into the diner where she works, she wonders, “Was it you?” The only person she’s sure didn’t donate the money is her extremely hot—and extremely standoffish—coworker, Logan Evans. Ever since he started at the diner, he’s acted like he hates her. Which is why she’s shocked when he helps her save face in front of her ex…
Their attraction can’t be denied, but when River discovers a long-hidden family secret, she suddenly finds herself questioning everyone in her life. Her dad, who wasn’t as perfect as he seemed. Her chaotic mother, who left without so much as a goodbye at the beginning of her senior year. The anonymous donor, whose intentions may not have been altruistic after all. And most especially Logan, who has dark secrets of his own.
After the fire, River thought she had hit rock bottom. But as it turns out, there’s always more to lose…
Image Source: Courtesy of Penguin Random House 
What would you do if you lost everything, only to have a mysterious stranger drop $2 million at your feet? Sloan Harlow’s ALL WE LOST WAS EVERYTHING poses this question, then cranks the drama up to eleven. In this dark and twisty young adult thriller, 18-year-old River Santos watches her life literally go up in flames. After her house burns down and her father dies in the fire, River is left clinging to the ashes of her old life. As if that isn’t enough to rock anyone’s world, an anonymous benefactor deposits a fortune into her GoFundMe, a no-strings-attached gift that feels more like a curse. From that gripping premise, Harlow spins a tale that’s equal parts mystery, romance, and emotional coming-of-age. It’s a story about trusting no one and learning to trust yourself; all set against the unforgiving beauty of the Arizona desert.
1. A Genre-Blending Thriller That Hits Home
ALL WE LOST WAS EVERYTHING doesn’t fit neatly into a single box, and that’s a good thing. It’s a high-stakes mystery-thriller wrapped in a heartfelt YA coming-of-age story, with a generous dash of dark romance for good measure. One minute, River is a small-town teen slinging pancakes at the local diner; the next, she’s thrust into a real-life whodunit with a secret admirer’s millions hanging over her head. The novel walks a fine line between edge-of-your-seat suspense and genuine emotional depth, making it a crossover hit for fans of both E. Lockhart and Colleen Hoover. Harlow’s narrative feels like Veronica Mars grew up in the age of TikTok: witty and modern, yet unafraid to delve into raw feelings. And it all stays surprisingly grounded: River’s voice is down-to-earth and relatable, even when she’s grappling with million-dollar mysteries. By blending genres, Harlow has crafted a story that burns bright with thriller tension while still tugging at the heartstrings!
2. Heartache, Secrets, And The Weight Of Grief
At its core, this is a story about loss and the messy, painful healing that comes after. River isn’t just dealing with a tragic freak accident; she’s navigating bone-deep grief, family secrets, and the rubble of her identity. Six months ago, she had a loving father, a troubled but present mother, and a life full of music (her beloved guitar and songbook perished in the fire). Now, she’s essentially orphaned: her dad gone, and her mom missing without a trace for nearly a year. Living with her Tita Ana (aunt) and leaning on her best friend Tawny, River faces each day in survival mode, stuck between mourning and moving on.
The secrets make that dance even more complicated. When River discovers unsettling clues about her father’s past, including threatening letters hinting that his perfect facade hid something horrific, her understanding of her family begins to crumble. Was the fire that killed him truly an accident, or the final act in a long-brewing tragedy? Suddenly, River is questioning everything she thought she knew about her parents, her friends, and even herself. This book isn’t afraid to ask the hard questions: Can you ever really know the people you love? Can you forgive the unforgivable? Each new revelation brings River a mix of pain and clarity. It’s heavy stuff for a teenager to confront, but that’s exactly what makes the story so compelling. By the end, River isn’t the only one forced to rethink her past; you will be right there with her, sifting through the clues and confronting the unsettling idea that sometimes the people closest to you harbor the darkest secrets.
3. Twists, Trust Issues, And A Love Triangle Done Right
Don’t let the grief and melodrama fool you; this novel moves fast. Harlow piles on the mysteries from page one and never lets up. River’s sudden windfall sets the stage for a guessing game, and that’s just the beginning. Soon her ex-boyfriend, Noah, waltzes back into town with regret in his eyes and secrets on his lips. At the same time, her aloof co-worker Logan, previously more inclined to roll his eyes at River than talk to her, starts revealing a surprisingly soft side. The result is a tension-filled love triangle that actually serves the plot. It’s Team Logan vs. Team Noah, but not in the shallow way YA triangles sometimes play out. Each guy represents a different path and a different set of dangerous questions for River. Noah is the golden boy ex-best friend who broke her heart without explanation. Logan is the enigmatic new crush whose own family history is entangled with River’s in shocking ways. Choosing between them isn’t just about romance; it’s about uncovering the truth.
Every character in River’s life, from her loyal friend Tawny to the anonymous donor, seems to be hiding something. In ALL WE LOST WAS EVERYTHING, everyone has a secret, and no one can be fully trusted! Harlow masterfully juggles multiple mystery threads that intertwine like puzzle pieces, keeping even the savviest readers guessing. Just when you think you’ve solved one puzzle, another revelation comes out of left field, keeping you on your toes. And yes, there are twists on twists. By the final act, the connection between the fire, the missing mom, and that $2,000,000 twist of fate becomes a web of lies and loyalties that will make your jaw drop. Yet amidst the breakneck plotting, Harlow never loses sight of her characters. River, Logan, Noah, and Tawny are more than pawns in a mystery; they’re teenagers dealing with trauma, loyalty, and first love in a very intense situation. The dialogue crackles with authenticity, and moments of humor and warmth peek through the darkness, reminding you that these are young people trying to reclaim some normalcy. And for readers who crave a bit of spice with their suspense, fear not: River and Logan’s chemistry sizzles. Their flirtation starts slow and hostile, then blooms into a passionate connection with genuinely steamy scenes (prepare for some upper-YA heat).
4. Forgiveness And Hope Rising From The Ashes
Beneath the mysteries and make-outs, ALL WE LOST WAS EVERYTHING carries a surprisingly uplifting message: even after the worst happens, you can choose to find hope. River’s journey is more than just solving the whodunit and figuring out which boy deserves her heart. It’s about learning to let go of anger and to forgive others and herself. Throughout the novel, characters grapple with mistakes and betrayals that would break many of us. River learns gut-wrenching truths about her father’s past and her mother’s disappearance, the kinds of revelations that could easily breed lasting bitterness. Instead, our heroine finds an unexpected strength in her ability to understand and forgive those who hurt her. This isn’t the cheap, fairy-tale kind of forgiveness; it’s the hard-earned kind. Harlow shows that forgiveness is not about saying “it’s okay” to wrongs; it’s about refusing to let those wrongs destroy you. River can’t change what happened to her family, but she can decide not to be consumed by rage or regret. That’s a powerful takeaway for any reader, young or old!
By the final chapter, redemption and second chances take center stage. The question of “Can we forgive the unforgivable?” lingers over the story, and Harlow isn’t interested in easy answers. Instead, she offers something more honest: the idea that forgiveness is a journey, not a destination. Characters who seemed irredeemable earn sympathy, and those who betrayed trust get a chance, however slight, at redemption. Importantly, River also learns to forgive herself for the survivor’s guilt she carries, for the naive faith she placed in people who let her down, and for the mistakes she makes along the way. In a narrative filled with literal flames and figurative daggers, it’s this emotional arc that gives the novel its soul! After all the twists and heartaches, the lasting impression is one of resilience. River’s story reminds us that even when you’ve lost everything, you might just find yourself.
ALL WE LOST WAS EVERYTHING doesn’t just keep you guessing; it makes you feel every broken piece and hard-won hope along the way.
