Watch CBS News
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.

Watch CBS News
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.

Watch CBS News
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.

Merrimack, New Hampshire — Former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie will visit Israel this weekend, where he plans to meet with the family members of abducted civilians, Israeli Defense soldiers and government officials.
At a town hall on Thursday, he said, “Tomorrow night, I’m leaving to go to Israel because I want to see it for myself.”
Christie will be the first Republican presidential hopeful to visit Israel since the Oct. 7 Hamas attacks. He said, “I don’t think you can try and be president of the United States and be afraid to go and see what’s happening on the ground.” Adding, “If you really want to lead, you need to go over and show the people of Israel that one person running for president of the United States cares enough to get on an airplane.”
The trip was first reported by CNN.
Christie told reporters that late last week the Israeli foreign ministry had contacted him. “They said they appreciated the things I was saying and the stance I was taking,” he said.
Shortly after Hamas’s surprise attack on Israel in early October, Christie tweeted, “We must do whatever it takes to support the State of Israel in its time of grave danger, and we must end the scourge of Iran-backed terrorism.”
He has defended Israel, telling Fox News two days after Hamas’ assault, “The Israelis have an absolute right to defend themselves and to fair it out and eliminate those people in Hamas who perpetrated this horrible attack.”
Christie is also a proponent of providing aid to both Israel and Ukraine and has made itcentral to his campaign. In August, Christie visited Ukraine and met with President Volodymyr Zelenskyy.
Thanks for reading CBS NEWS.
Create your free account or log in
for more features.

A day after Democrats and abortion rights advocates chalked up a string of electoral victories around the country, GOP presidential candidates on Wednesday night appeared to have learned nothing from their party’s losses.
During the third Republican primary debate, moderator Kristen Welker of NBC News asked the five presidential hopefuls how they see their party’s path forward on the issue of abortion, given that they keep losing elections over their attacks on women’s reproductive rights. Most doubled down on their opposition to abortion, and then made nonsensical claims about Democrats advocating for no restrictions on abortion in any scenario.
The moderators did nothing to call them out for it, either.
“Let’s just be clear,” said Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis. “The Democrats have taken a position they will not identify the point at which there should be any protection, all the way up until birth. That is wrong and we cannot stand for that.”
“I am 100% pro-life … I would certainly, as president of the United States, have a 15-week national limit,” said Sen. Tim Scott (S.C.). “I would not allow California, Illinois or New York to have abortion up until the day of birth.”
Scott went on to say he thinks “it’s unethical and immoral to allow for abortions up until the day of birth,” which, to be clear, is not something that anybody is calling for, anywhere.
“We have the opportunity to stop that reckless behavior,” Scott vowed.
Former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie briefly laid out why he thinks abortion rights should be decided on a state-by-state basis. But then he, too, waded into the made-up claim about Democrats wanting people to be able to have abortions while delivering babies at full term.
“In my home state of New Jersey, it goes up to nine months that you can get an abortion,” Christie said. “I find that morally reprehensible. But that is what the people in my state voted for.”
Wednesday night’s debate is not the first time the GOP candidates have spread misinformation about abortion. Many of the same claims, including that people were getting abortions up until birth, were on full display during the first Republican debate in August.
And it’s still not true. While some Democrats have supported allowing abortion later in pregnancy to protect the life and health of the pregnant person, it is not true that Democrats support abortions of healthy pregnancies up until the moment of birth ― or that they are happening at all.
The reality is that abortions later in pregnancy are extremely rare. Fewer than 1% of abortions even happen at 21 weeks or later, and after 26 weeks, even fewer are carried out and they are generally for pregnant people facing emergency health situations. A fetus is usually able to survive outside the womb at around 24 weeks, which is considered the viability threshold.
Abortion has been a sticky issue for Republicans, and more so than ever in the year since the Supreme Court’s decision in Dobbs v. Jackson overturned the national right to abortion. Since then, GOP-fueled abortion bans and attempts to restrict abortion have proved deeply unpopular with voters. Democrats have been campaigning heavily on a pro-choice agenda, promising to protect reproductive rights — a stance that has been credited with propelling them to victory in crucial races.
Democrats racked up more electoral wins around the country on Tuesday night. In Ohio, voters approved a constitutional amendment ensuring access to abortion. In Virginia, Democrats took control of the state House and cemented their hold on the state Senate, delivering a huge setback to GOP Gov. Glenn Youngkin and his plans to push through a 15-week abortion ban. Meanwhile, voters in deep red Kentucky reelected a Democratic governor whose campaign centered on protecting abortion rights.

GIORGIO VIERA via Getty Images
Vivek Ramaswamy said Wednesday that he wanted to talk about abortion — as a man.
“They say men have trouble speaking on this issue,” Ramaswamy said, without saying who has actually said that. “I don’t think we need to be that way.”
He went on to talk about the accuracy of paternity tests, a story once told by Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, and then called for greater “sexual responsibility for men” because ultimately, he said, abortions aren’t about women’s rights.
“It’s not men’s rights versus women’s rights,” Ramaswamy declared. “It’s about human rights.”
Former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley, the only woman on the stage, was the only candidate who appeared to have learned something from her party’s string of electoral losses.
In a noticeable change of tune from the first GOP debate, where she demanded that President Joe Biden reveal where he would draw the line on abortions, Haley said Wednesday that abortion is a personal issue for everyone. She said even though she’s pro-life, now that Roe v Wade has been overturned, it’s time to stop attacking women and find consensus.
“Let’s make sure we encourage adoptions. Let’s make sure we make contraception accessible. Let’s make sure none of these state laws put women in jail or give her the death penalty for getting an abortion,” Haley said. “Let’s focus on how to save as many babies as we can and support as many moms as we can and stop the judgment. We don’t need to divide America over this issue anymore.”
She drew some of the loudest applause of the night.

“It’s a who’s who of who has no chance to beat Donald Trump,” Kimmel declared, referring to the five as “dopefuls” instead of hopefuls.
“But it is ridiculous to have these debates without the frontrunner,” he noted. “You know things have gone sideways when you’re watching something and you think, ‘God, I wish Donald Trump was there.’”
So Kimmel gave Trump his own debate ― one where he’s battling himself:
“That’s like Melania’s worst nightmare come true,” Kimmel said.
See more of Kimmel’s take on Trump ― including the former president’s latest legal developments in New York ― in his Wednesday night monologue:

Republican 2024 presidential contenders faced high stakes in the third primary debate, but some candidates fared better than others Wednesday night in Miami, Florida.
Candidates sparred over issues from federal spending, Ukraine and China in the showdown, which arrived roughly two months before the first votes of the election will be cast in the Iowa caucuses. Five candidates—former South Carolina Governor Nikki Haley; Florida Governor Ron DeSantis; ex-New Jersey Governor Chris Christie; South Carolina Senator Tim Scott; and entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy—verbally wrangled on the stage.
The GOP race front-runner, however, was again a no-show. Former President Donald Trump, who continues to hold a substantial lead over his Republican rivals, skipped the debate, as he did the first two. He has pointed to his poll numbers as the reason for his snubbing of the debates. Trump’s absence left the other five qualifying candidates aiming to prove they deserve the GOP nomination.
Here’s an overview of who won and who lost on the big stage.
Israel emerged as a major victor during the debate. Candidates rallied behind the nation amid its war against Hamas, which on October 7 launched thousands of missiles into Israel from the Gaza Strip. Israel has since cut off food, water and electricity to Gaza, launching its own attacks, including a ground operation.
Candidates all voiced support for Israel, saying they would tell Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu he has the right and responsibility to respond to the Hamas attack.
“The last thing we need to do is to tell Israel what to do. The only thing we should be doing is supporting them in eliminating Hamas,” Haley said.
Ukraine, however, emerged as a loser. Candidates, as in past debates, voiced disagreement over whether the United States should provide aid for Ukraine as it defends itself against the invasion from Russia. More traditional conservatives, such as Haley, have called for continued support, but more MAGA-aligned candidates have called for more limits on aid.
DeSantis said he would not send U.S. troops to Ukraine, while Scott said he disagreed with coupling aid to Israel and Ukraine, a move that Ukraine aid supporters hope would boost its chances of passing Congress.
Ramaswamy took a stronger stance against Ukraine, calling President Volodymyr Zelensky, who is Jewish, “a Nazi.”
“[Ukraine] has celebrated a Nazi in its ranks, the comedian in cargo pants, a man called Zelensky,” he said.
Moderators opened the debate by directly asking Trump’s rivals why they would make a better president than him. Candidates continued lines of attacks from previous debates—questioning why he is skipping the debate, and knocking him over the national debt.
But those attacks have not proven to be effective, as Trump withstood them following the second debate, after which his poll numbers continued to hold steady.
Ramaswamy sparked boos from the crowd over launching a personal attack against Haley. The former South Carolina governor has supported a ban on TikTok, a Chinese-owned app that has come under scrutiny for national security concerns. She criticized Ramaswamy for using the app to campaign, and he responded by saying that Haley’s daughter previously used the social media platform.
The remark elicited loud boos from the crowd, and Haley responded by calling him “scum.”
As with the other candidates, Ramaswamy was tough on border control, but moved beyond the pack by suggesting that America build a wall on the northern border with Canada as well the southern border. “We need to skate to where the puck is going,” Ramaswamy said, despite northern border encounters making up 5% of all Customs and Border Patrol encounters in September 2023.
Haley faced new attacks from DeSantis about her record on China, but largely turned his critiques back on him, raising concerns about his recent record on the matter.
Haley earned praise following the first two debates from analyst, who have said her past performances suggest she may be able to win over more moderate and independent voters. She held steady during Wednesday’s debate, drawing a contrast from other candidates on Ukraine and abortion, an issue that again proved difficult for Republicans in Tuesday night’s elections, which saw Republican defeats in Virginia’s legislative races and Kentucky’s gubernatorial race.
She also earned praise from social media users for her response to Ramaswamy’s attack on her daughter’s past use of TikTok, telling him, “Leave my daughter out of your voice.”
DeSantis and Scott entered the debate in different positions. DeSantis needed a breakout moment during the debate to prove he can go head-to-head against Trump, whose polling lead has only grown since the last debate. Scott, meanwhile needed a particularly strong performance after struggling in the polls.
Neither had any major slip-ups and remained steady, but they also lacked a major moment as they hope to boost their polling numbers.
Republican candidates were united on banning social media app TikTok due to concerns that the Chinese government could access the personal data of American users. But the conversation extended past privacy to point to TikTok’s impact on young minds. “This is China trying to further divide the United States of America,” Christie said.
The idea of a TikTok ban resonates with many Americans. In a March 2023 study by the Pew Research Center showed supporters of a ban outnumber opponents of a ban by more than 2 to 1.
Holt, Welker and Hewitt faced a separate challenge—controlling the candidates. The second debate in October received backlash from viewers after allowing candidates to frequently disrupt each other.
Tonight’s moderators, however, took a different approach. Holt told the audience to “restrain” themselves when they erupted into thunderous applause early on in the debate.
“Let’s not go down this road,” he said.
Welker, meanwhile, took attack from Ramaswamy, who argued she should not be moderating the debate over conservative personalities such as Elon Musk or Tucker Carlson. However, she declined to engage in the attack, drawing praise on social media.
“Smart move by Lester and Kristen Welker not to take the bait and give Vivek the attention he wanted from his cheap stunt,” wrote journalist Matt Lewis.
All of the candidates on stage were effusive in their support for Social Security entitlements and made clear that they didn’t want to impact any current recipients. “My mama and every other mama out there — I will protect your social security,” said Scott.
On the subject of keeping the program solvent, most evaded specific answers on whether the entitlement age should be raised.
Christie came out as a clear supporter of raising the retirement age “a few years” for Americans in their 30s and 40s, but doesn’t think new funding should come from tax increases. “We are already overtaxed in this country and we shouldn’t raise taxes,” he said.
Scott firmly said no to a raise on the retirement age. DeSantis seemed to lean away from a change to retirement age, noted that life expectancy is currently declining, so tethering entitlement dates to life expectancy doesn’t make sense.
Both Christie and Haley brought up limitations on benefits for the wealthy, with Christie specifically calling out Warren Buffett by name.
Ramaswamy was vague on solutions, but vowed to keep benefits for current seniors intact. When pushed for answers on entitlement reform for future generations, he responded “It’ll take a CEO from the next generation to do it.”
Newsweek is committed to challenging conventional wisdom and finding connections in the search for common ground.
Newsweek is committed to challenging conventional wisdom and finding connections in the search for common ground.

Republican presidential candidate Asa Hutchinson was booed at Saturday’s Florida Freedom Summit after saying there’s a “significant likelihood” that former President Donald Trump (R) will be convicted next year.
Trump faces four separate criminal indictments, with a total of 91 felony charges related to a hush money payment to a porn star, his handling of classified documents, his interference in the 2020 election, and his role in instigating the 2021 Capitol riot.
During the GOP summit, Hutchinson gave his prediction for the outcome of Trump’s Georgia, New York, Florida and Washington, D.C., trials.
“There is a significant likelihood that Donald Trump will be found guilty by a jury on a felony offense next year,” the former Arkansas governor told the crowd.
Hutchinson, a critic of the former president, has previously expressed doubts about Trump being able to take office if he wins the 2024 race for the White House. In August, he told CNN that he doesn’t expect Trump to win the GOP nomination and questioned his eligibility to run.
“I’m not even sure he’s qualified to be the next president,” Hutchinson said, referring to arguments that Trump’s actions on Jan. 6, 2021, make him ineligible to hold office.
Hutchinson was not the only person to receive a frosty reception at this week’s summit. Former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie (R), another presidential candidate who has not shied away from slamming Trump, was met with boos and heckling. Someone in the audience yelled “Trump!” — prompting Christie to chastise the crowd, which appeared to be largely filled with Trump supporters.
“What a shock, you’re for Trump. I’m going to fall over dead,” Christie said. “Now look, every one of those boos, every one of those catcalls and every one of those yells will not solve one problem we face in this country.”
He added, “Your anger against the truth is reprehensible,” later slamming the crowd members for their “pettiness” and “fear” of the truth.

President Joe Biden’s fundraising haul from July through September easily surpassed all his potential GOP rivals, according to campaign finance data made public Sunday. Former President Donald Trump continues to lead the GOP field of presidential candidates, with Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis and former U.S. Ambassador to the U.N. Nikki Haley trailing.
Here’s a rundown of what the candidates raised in the quarter, according to data from the Federal Elections Commission.
Mr. Biden’s reelection campaign, joint fundraising committees and the Democratic National Committee raised more than $71 million in the third quarter, and have a collective of $91 million cash on hand. The haul is slightly less than what the same entities raised in the second quarter, but aides cite increasing enthusiasm among smaller-dollar donors giving $200 or less. These donations constituted about 49% of the third quarter totals, compared to only about a third of donations in the second quarter.
His fundraising was 1.6 times higher than Trump’s, and close to five times DeSantis’ fundraising. Biden’s committees spent over $56 million as the incumbent candidate ramps up his reelection bid by hiring more staff and buying advertising time on broadcast and cable television and digital media platforms.
Trump’s fundraising momentum has picked up: his campaign raised $24.5 million between July and September, topping the $17.7 million he raised in the second quarter, and $14.4 million in the first quarter.
Trump ended September with over $37.5 million cash on hand, which is seven times what DeSantis has and around triple what Haley and South Carolina Sen. Tim Scott have available.
The fundraising numbers published Sunday by Trump are lower than the $45.5 million that the campaign said his joint fundraising committee raised, signaling that the fundraising mechanism, which raises money for Trump’s official campaign and Save America PAC, could be spending significantly. Official joint fundraising committee numbers are required to be filed semiannually, with the next deadline in January 2024.
Trump’s ongoing legal battles, including two federal and two state indictments, have benefited his campaign fundraising, while his legal bills mount.
According to a CBS News analysis of Sunday’s filings, the campaign raised over $2 million in the first 48 hours after Trump’s mug shot from the Fulton County, Georgia, jail was released. The campaign sold merchandise featuring the mugshot. He faces charges there and in federal court related to alleged efforts to overturn the 2020 election results.
His campaign raised over $770,000 on August 1, the day Trump was indicted in Washington, D.C., on federal charges stemming from his efforts to overturn his 2020 election loss. Trump has denied all of the charges against him in these cases.
DeSantis’ campaign reported raising $15.1 million, with the money coming through his campaign committee ($8.93 million) and his joint fundraising committee ($6.18 million).
But DeSantis spent nearly all of what was raised, with a reported $10.6 million on “operating expenditures” spent by the campaign over the third quarter. Travel and payroll ate up $3.4 million of that.
His campaign also reported $12.3 million cash on hand going into October, but only $5 million may be used in the primary because of individual limits on donations. Some donors gave the maximum for the primary and general combined, but only the funds earmarked for the primary can be spent before the general election campaign. DeSantis’ campaign says his cash on hand is not impacted by the $1 million in payments still due to vendors for direct mail services.
After DeSantis’ campaign laid off staff in July to cut spending, promising big donors a “leaner, meaner” operation, it spent just under $4 million in August, a savings of $2 million from July. In September, DeSantis spent just $1.4 million, according to a CBS News analysis of his campaign committee’s filing.
DeSantis spent over $1.5 million to private jet companies last quarter, though only one company, “Israjets,” received a payment for travel in September.
September was DeSantis’ strongest fundraising month. He picked up $5.6 million, with $2.3 million in the days around the second GOP debate.
Small dollar donations (those $200 and less) made up just 28% of DeSantis’ total contributions to his campaign, notably less than Trump who relies heavily on grassroots small-dollar donations.
Haley’s campaign has picked up fundraising momentum after two strong debates and some improved polling. She hauled in $8.2 million between July and September and acquired nearly 40,000 new donors.
She ranks fourth among her GOP competitors in cash in hand, with $11.5 million, and ranks third with money available to spend on the 2024 primary with over $9.1 million.
This is her strongest fundraising quarter, and Haley also kept operations lean, spending just $3.5 million between July and September, far less than some of her rivals, including Scott, who spent almost $7.8 million more than he raised.
Olivia Perez-Cubas, a Haley spokeswoman,said Haley “is surging and emerging as the alternative to Trump.”
Former Vice President Mike Pence is facing significant challenges in fundraising for his presidential campaign. He raised $3.3 million in the third quarter, but his cash on hand is only $1.2 million, and he’s facing a substantial debt — about $620,000. His personal $150,000 contribution to his campaign further highlights his campaign’s financial shortfall.
His FEC filing also revealed that Pence owes money to two companies based in Virginia, related to direct-mail consulting and postage expenses. His campaign has relied heavily on mail to reach enough voters to qualify for the Republican debates.
Candidates must prove they’ve secured at least 70,000 individual donations to qualify for the third Republican debate, which takes place Nov. 8, in Miami. His campaign has not yet confirmed whether he has met the requirements.
Entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy raised nearly $7.5 million from July through September, and a campaign official told CBS News that over 120,000 of his donations came from small donors – 40% of whom were first time donors to a Republican candidate.
The Ohio multimillionaire said, “That’s how we roll,” when told he had more small donors than DeSantis in the third quarter.
His campaign spent over $12 million, leaving him with about $4 million in cash on hand.
According to his filing, Ramaswamy donated more than $1 million to his campaign, compared to the $750,461 he donated during the first two quarters, total. He had previously loaned his campaign more than $15 million.
Scott raised about $5.9 million across entities and burned through about $12.4 million in the third quarter. He has the most available cash on hand besides Trump — $13.3 million — in part due to successful fundraising during his 2022 reelection campaign.
He has $927,827 in debt, according to documents filed on Sunday. His campaign says it’s fully funded through the early-voting states. “This campaign is built for the long-haul,” it said, and adds that he’s met the fundraising threshold for the third debate.
The campaign also responded to the recent decision of the super PAC backing Scott to cancel $40 million in TV ads ahead of the Iowa caucuses, noting that it has already spent $14 million in TV reservations through November.
Christie brought it an estimated $3.7 million and spent $1.5 million between July 1 and October 30. The former New Jersey governor ended the third quarter with $3.9 million cash on hand and no debt. According to his campaign, all of his available cash can be used for the primary.
Christie’s burn rate this quarter was about 40%. The campaign attributes this to it not spending money on TV ads or internal polling and keeping the team small, with about 15 people who take on various roles and work remotely or in the field.
Ahead of Sunday’s filing, Christie posted, “Our team is lean and mean, and we’re going to do what it takes to continue taking on Trump and expose his lies across the country.” He urged donors to help him reach the unique donor threshold to make the third debate.
Candidates need 70,000 individual donors to participate in the third GOP debate.
North Dakota Governor Doug Burgum reported raising $3.4 million in the third quarter and has $2.3 million cash on hand.
Former Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson raised $667, 781 and reported having $325,287 in cash on hand and has $720,172 in debt, according to his FEC filing for the quarter.
Both Hutchinson and Burgum are struggling to qualify for the third GOP presidential debate, which has the highest polling and donor thresholds so far.
There were knocks against Joe Biden. Some friendly fire against one another. There were even a few jabs at the conspicuously absent Donald Trump from someone other than Chris Christie, who is waging something of a kamikaze campaign to bring down the former president. But ultimately, the futility of the second GOP debate was best summed up by Vivek Ramaswamy: “The real divide is not between the Republicans on this stage,” he said early on in the affair Wednesday evening at the Reagan Library in Simi Valley, California. “We need to unite this party.”
If there was a point to any of this, it was for one of these candidates to finally stand out from the pack as a viable alternative to Trump, who once again skipped the debate, this time to campaign in Michigan. But the problem, as Ramaswamy unintentionally pointed out, is that these aspirants are too substantively similar to distinguish themselves from one another. Sure, there’s some slight variation in packaging, from Ron DeSantis’s awkward approximation of what a tough guy would say to the corny uplift of Tim Scott, who appears to be trying to reinvigorate his flagging campaign with some new facial hair. But open every box, and you find the same MAGA junk: fearmongering about immigrants and cities and transgender Americans; lots of talk about a decaying country; the misrepresentation not only of Biden’s policies, but of reality itself.
This content can also be viewed on the site it originates from.
The candidates did seem more willing to go after Trump—something most were reluctant to do in the first debate. But their attacks were still too tame or lame to really make an impact, whether it was DeSantis accusing Trump of being “missing in action” for skipping the debate or Christie taunting him as “Donald Duck.”
“I know you’re watching,” Christie said into the camera. “You’re afraid of being on this stage.”
Trump is surely afraid of a lot of things—namely, that one of his four indictments will result in jail time—but it’s hard to imagine he’s that nervous about seven challengers he’s currently leading by more than 40 points and who don’t even match his polling numbers collectively.
Especially when they all seem to be trying so hard to sound like him.
Indeed, the seven challengers spent the evening trying to out-extreme one another. We got Scott essentially arguing, when questioned about striking auto workers, that Americans should work more and for less money—surely a winning message. We got obfuscation about the looming government shutdown, which Christie said was the fault of “everybody”—though it is Kevin McCarthy and House Republicans who are holding government funding hostage. We got Ramaswamy, insufferable as ever, promising to “militarize” the southern border—something Nikki Haley, running as the self-styled adult in the room, more or less echoed later (“It’s how we deal with terrorists,” she said, calling for special operations to go after drug cartels). We got a humorless-as-ever Mike Pence, the former vice president and noted Christian, suggesting he would address mass shootings by passing an “expedited death penalty” law and proposing a “federal ban on transgender chemical or surgical surgery anywhere in the country.” And we got Christie bashing Biden’s education policy by quipping that the president was “sleeping with a member of the teacher’s union”—a reference, of course, to First Lady Jill Biden.
“I’m going to reverse this country’s decline,” DeSantis said at one point, recalling Trump’s “American Carnage” inaugural address.
These people are each trying, in theory, to position themselves as a more reasonable alternative to the former president. But what they’re actually doing is confirming that this remains the party of Trump, in all his absurdity. They might have their scraps with one another—“Every time I hear you, I feel a little bit dumber,” Haley told Ramaswamy, in what was perhaps the best (and most cathartic) line of the night—but at the end of the day, they’re not all that different. None of these seven actually offered up a vision of a post-Trump GOP; they offered up a vision of the current GOP, with a less charismatic extremist sitting at the top of it.
Eric Lutz
Source link

Seven candidates seeking the Republican nomination for president in 2024 will share the stage Wednesday night at the Reagan Presidential Library in California for the second primary debate.
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie, North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum, former ambassador Nikki Haley, former Vice President Mike Pence, Sen. Tim Scott of South Carolina and entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy met the Republican National Committee’s polling and fundraising threshold to qualify for the stage.
Former President Donald Trump, who remains the Republican frontrunner, is skipping the debate and instead will speak in Detroit, where Big Three union auto workers are on strike. A CBS News poll released Tuesday found Trump leads the Republican primary field comfortably in both Iowa and New Hampshire. His current margins would translate to winning half of Iowa’s delegates and the lion’s share in New Hampshire.
The eight candidates who participated in the first debate were asked if they would support Trump even if he is convicted of a crime. All but Christie and former Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson (who will not be at the second debate) raised their hands in support.
The debate will air on Fox Business Channel and Univision from 9 p.m. to 11 p.m., and can be streamed on Rumble.
The threshold for the second debate was higher than for the first. Candidates had to poll at 3% in two national polls or 3% in one national poll and 3% in one early state poll from two separate early-voting states — Iowa, New Hampshire, Nevada, South Carolina. For the first debate, the polling requirement was 1% in the same poll categories in surveys conducted on or after Aug. 1.
Candidates also needed to have a minimum of 50,000 unique donors to their principal presidential campaign committee or exploratory committee, with at least 200 unique donors per state or territory in more than 20 states and/or territories. That’s an increase of 10,000 unique donors over the 40,000 required to make it onstage for the first primary debate.
Stuart Varney and Dana Perino, of Fox News, will moderate the debate, with Univision’s Ilia Calderón.
A week before the second debate, primary opponent Nikki Haley criticized Trump for sitting out the debate. “You can’t just not be on a debate stage because you’re so high in the polls,” she said at an event in New Hampshire Thursday. “You’ve got to show not what you did in the last four years [but], what are you going to do in the next four, how are you going to fix what was broken?”
Trump has also not signed the RNC’s “loyalty pledge” to support the candidate who wins the Republican nomination.
Cristina Corujo contributed to this report.

Former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie said Donald Trump keeps hurting his own legal defense, and did so again on Sunday during his “Meet the Press” interview.
“Every time he opens his mouth, his lawyers must want to vomit,” Christie said on CNN on Monday.
One of Trump’s potential defense arguments to some of the 91 felony counts across four criminal cases is that he was relying on the advice of attorneys when he orchestrated a plot to overturn the results of the 2020 election.
But on Sunday, Trump admitted that he was calling the shots.
“It was my decision,” Trump told Kristen Welker.
“This is a guy who is just burying himself deeper and deeper, taking away any potential defense he has,” said Christie, a former Trump ally who is now running against him for the 2024 Republican presidential nomination.
While Sunday’s interview featured Trump’s usual constant barrage of lies, Christie said the admission was a “rare time” when the former president was actually telling the truth.
“I think he was the person who made these decisions. I think he is responsible for his own conduct,” Christie said. “But I tell you, if I was his defense lawyer, I’d want to jump out a window every time this guy gets in front of a microphone or in front of a screen to send something out on Truth Social.”
Christie also noted that Trump never denied the actual conduct at the heart of the criminal cases against him.
“If you don’t deny the conduct, then you’re in very, very big trouble,” Christie said. “He is in big trouble. and if we nominate him, our party will be in big trouble.”
See the full interview below:

The second Republican primary debate will be held Sept. 27 at 9 p.m. ET, at the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library, in Simi Valley, California.
Fox Business, along with Univision, will moderate the second debate, and the conservative online video platform Rumble will also stream it.
The threshold for the second debate is higher than it was for the first. Candidates must poll at 3% in two national polls or 3% in one national poll and 3% in one early state poll from two separate early-voting states — Iowa, New Hampshire, Nevada, South Carolina — recognized by the Republican National Committee. For the first debate, the polling requirement was 1% in the same poll categories.
Polls must have been conducted on or after Aug. 1, and candidates have until 48 hours before the debate to meet the polling requirement.
Candidates will also need to have a minimum of 50,000 unique donors to their principal presidential campaign committee or exploratory committee, with at least 200 unique donors per state or territory in more than 20 states and/or territories. That’s an increase of 10,000 unique donors over the 40,000 required to make it onstage for the first primary debate.
The RNC has not yet released its list of participants, but so far, it looks likely that former President Donald Trump, entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamey, former Ambassador to the U.N. and South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley, former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie, former Vice President Mike Pence, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis and South Carolina Sen. Tim Scott are likely to have qualified.
Former Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson and North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum appear not to have qualified yet.
Stuart Varney and Dana Perino, of Fox News, will moderate the debate, with Univision’s Ilia Calderón.
Trump will skip the second Republican primary debate to deliver a competing address the same night in Detroit, his campaign confirmed Monday.
The exact time and audience have not been announced yet, but according to the New York Times, which first reported Trump would skip the debate, he will be addressing a union crowd. Trump is expected to speak in the same city where United Auto Workers members are striking to demand higher wages, better schedules and better benefits.
The former president also did not attend the first debate, and instead sat for an interview with Tucker Carlson that streamed at the same time the debate aired. Here’s what he said about why he didn’t participate: “You see the polls have come out, I’m leading by 50 and 60 points. And some of them are at one and zero and two. And I’m saying, ‘Do I sit there for an hour or two hours, whatever it’s going to be and get harassed by people that shouldn’t even be running for president? Should I be doing that? And a network that isn’t particularly friendly, frankly.’”
Trump has also not signed the RNC’s “loyalty pledge” to support the candidate who wins the Republican nomination.

We’re here in New Hampshire, outside a brewery with Gov. Chris Christie because, as he told us, this is his make-or-break state. His path to the Republican nomination runs through New Hampshire, the first-in-the nation primary. “If Donald Trump wins here, he will be our nominee. And everything that happens after that is going to be on our party and on our country.” “You’re about second in the polls in New Hampshire, but President Trump is still 20 points ahead. How do you see your path now that this race has started to actually winning this?” “I see it right where we’re sitting. The path is to beat him here. I think once Donald Trump loses in one place, that entire rotted building will crumble.” “Is there any scenario that you could see where you would drop out?” “Look, Nick, if I don’t do well in New Hampshire, then I’ll leave. I mean, it’s like I’ve been through this before. I know what these races mean. And if I do very well here, then you bet I’ll continue on through the convention.” More so than any other candidate in this race, Governor Christie has been harshly critical of former President Trump. Most of the field has been trying to keep Trump out of it. Christie has made it central to his argument for why he deserves the presidency. “And we watched you stand up there and say that, you know, Donald Trump was unfit, and you were very right. We agree. And then all of a sudden, you back out of the race and we see you on the stage next to him.” “Yup.” “Sucking up to him —” “Yup.” “So I want to know why? And how do I know that you’re not going to do that again this time?” “Well first off, why was because I didn’t want Hillary Clinton to be president, and I was convinced he was going to be the nominee at that point.” “It’s retail campaigning in New Hampshire. You don’t come up here to give big policy speeches, normally. What you do is come up here to meet voters. Gotten a chance to meet a lot of voters, take a lot of photos, shake some hands. It’s amazing that this is the way we elect a president in this country. But it is. But just remember, the future of this country is going to be determined here. So America is counting on you, and I’m counting on you too.”
Kassie Bracken, Emily Rhyne and Mark Boyer
Source link

“Look, he says so many ridiculous things,” Christie told CNN’s Dana Bash on Thursday.
“I think there is absolutely no interest in either Donald Trump or Meghan Markle debating about anything. And if people really want to have the real issues that are concerning their lives, like inflation, our role around the world, our troubled education system, crime and law and order in our cities debated, we need to have serious candidates on that [debate] stage.”
“And the only thing I think that might draw an audience that even approaches that would be if you were to sit down with the Duchess of Sussex, Meghan Markle and Prince Harry. They don’t like you much. Would you do that for the ratings?” Hewitt asked Trump.
“Oh, if you want to set it up, let’s set it up. Let’s go do something. I’d love to debate her. I would love it. I disagree so much with what they’re doing,” replied Trump, who claimed the pair treated the late Queen Elizabeth II “with great disrespect.”
The former New Jersey governor shared a clip from his interview with Bash on X (formerly Twitter), writing: “Donald Trump wants to debate Meghan Markle but not his opponents? What a joke. I’m sure they’d have a great debate on Spotify. Keep me on the stage for when the coward finally shows up to debate me.”

There are rules about when and how a politician can use music. Technically Republican primary combatant Vivek Ramaswamy had actually followed them before he performed Eminem’s self-hype anthem “Lose Yourself” in a half-viral moment at the Iowa State Fair on August 12. In May, Ramaswamy’s campaign signed an agreement with the performing rights organization BMI, giving him the rights to play songs from the thousands of artists they represent. But there are also a few unwritten codes that supersede the licensing business, and something about the biotech entrepreneur turned MAGA stan’s lackluster performance must have violated them in the rapper’s eyes. Less than two weeks later, BMI asked the campaign to stop using Eminem’s music. According to the letter, which Deadline obtained, the artist reached out to his longtime licensing company and asked them to exclude his music from the agreement with the Ramaswamy campaign. (ASCAP, another rival rights organization, advises campaigns to seek permission from the artists’ management before playing a song to ensure the use doesn’t infringe on the artists’ rights to publicity or represent a false endorsement.) Ramaswamy’s campaign spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin said the campaign will comply with the request to stop using Eminem’s music. “To the American people’s chagrin, we will have to leave the rapping to the real Slim Shady.”
Eminem’s politics surely had something to do with the complaint, but I would be surprised if “don’t be cringe” wasn’t an equal part of the subtext. It’s likely a coincidence that the letter went out the same day that Ramaswamy’s profile rose significantly in the first GOP presidential debate of the 2024 election cycle, but it’s fitting. Perched in the center of the stage, Ramaswamy’s lively performance impressed the likes of Matt Gaetz and earned attacks from his fellow debaters. In any case, the Eminem letter was its own strange mark of legitimacy. In Republican politics, you’re no one until someone is beseeching you to please, for the love of god, stay away from their back catalog.
The tussles between right-wing politicians and left-leaning musical artists are nothing new. In the wake of the 1984 Reagan campaign’s appropriation of “Born in the U.S.A.,” Bruce Springsteen quipped about the president missing, well, the whole point of the song. The visibility of these technical and legal matters changed after Donald Trump’s 2016 run for president, if only because celebrity outcry against Trump was loud and the campaign had the bad habit of continuing to use music long after rights organizations tried to intervene. “Musicians who oppose Donald Trump’s use of their music” now has its own Wikipedia page and entries ranging from Adele to the White Stripes, with Elton John, Neil Young, and the Village People among the names in between. Despite intervention from the rightsholders, performances of “Macho Man” were still taking place at Mar-a-Lago as recently as May, and that’s unlikely to change. Trump is set in his ways.
Eminem’s quiet rebuke of Ramaswamy recalls the sad saga of Springsteen and his former number-one fan, Chris Christie. Ever the New Jersey man, Christie was devoted to the artist, never mind their obvious political differences. But Springsteen rebuffed his invitation to perform at a state event and publicly criticized his policy positions. It’s not just that Christie wanted the songs, he wanted an embrace from the man himself. He wanted to be cool enough for Bruce. Christie soon switched his allegiance to another son of the Garden State and struck up a friendship with Jon Bon Jovi.
If stars were once hesitant about rebuking politicians they disagreed with, the Trump era broke the seal for good. Though close observers know that Eminem circa 2023 is a fairly progressive guy, the contingent of his fan base who might remember him, approvingly, as the avatar of early 2000s homophobia got a shock when he used his 2017 BET Hip-Hop Awards performance to announce his proud membership in the Resistance. In a rap, he called Trump a “racist 94-year-old grandpa” who would “probably cause a nuclear holocaust.”
Sure, there were a few fans who expressed outrage on Twitter, complaints from the type of person who might also find themselves in Tom Morello’s mentions lamenting that Rage Against the Machine got so political. For many sectors of the culture industry, the lesson of the Trump era was that Republicans do buy sneakers too, but not that many of them, and not the ones the trendsetters want to wear.
Now that we’re in the middle of another election cycle, more Republican presidential campaigns will inevitably face headlines like this. We’re also in the middle of a ferocious backlash against the vaguely liberal urban consensus over racial equality and tolerance that coalesced in the 2010s. While its most dire consequences have been laws that criminalize abortion or gender-affirming care, it’s also been waged widely in the culture, from the war on Disney to uproar about rainbows at Target. The right is now realizing that the decades-long groundwork they laid to capture American politics did little to net them the cultural supremacy they desperately crave.
This is quite clearly a part of what motivates Ramaswamy. In a profile by The New Yorker’s Sheelah Kolhatkar which labeled him “the CEO of anti-woke,” he lamented conservatism’s image problem on Ivy League campuses. “He mentioned a white, heavyset conservative male classmate at Harvard who was considered uncool,” Kolhatkar wrote, “and argued that the social pecking order was stacked against him ‘more than some athletic Black kid who came and got a place on the basketball team.’ Ramaswamy blamed affirmative action and similar policies for forcing élite institutions to lower their standards.”
For the most part, the attempts to change the tide have the quixotic air of Ben Shapiro’s efforts to make Nashville a conservative Hollywood. But there have been a few successful campaigns to seize the means of popularity, from a depressingly effective boycott of Bud Light over a single influencer’s sponsored post to the lackluster Jason Aldean provocation that spent a few weeks on the chart this summer.
So it was darkly hilarious to hear the newly minted folk hero Oliver Anthony react with dismay after his song “Rich Men North of Richmond” was played before the Fox debate last week. Anthony’s would-be corporate media boosters had impeccable right-wing bona fides, but Anthony still has the muddled, anti-establishment centrist politics of a regular guy. “It’s aggravating seeing people in conservative news try to identify with me like I’m one of them,” he said in a YouTube video. “It was funny seeing my song at the presidential debate. Cause it’s like, I wrote that song about those people. So for them to have to sit there and listen to that, that cracks me up.”
The brand is strong—just turns out even their own hand-selected standard-bearers don’t want to be associated with it.
Listen to Vanity Fair’s DYNASTY podcast now.
Erin Vanderhoof
Source link

Watch CBS News
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.

CNN
—
Polls show Donald Trump leading Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, his nearest rival for the 2024 Republican presidential nomination, by about 40 points. You might think this would cause the former president’s GOP rivals to attack him in an attempt to eat into that support, which stands at north of 50% of the primary vote.
Yet, most of his opponents seem hesitant, if not totally unwilling, to do so.
A look at the numbers reveals why. Those who have gone after him have seen their popularity among Republican voters suffer, while those who have risen in primary polling are either mostly not mentioning Trump or are praising him.
You needn’t look further than former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie to understand what happens when a Republican candidate is highly critical of the former president. Christie is setting records for intraparty unpopularity.
His net favorability rating in the latest Quinnipiac University poll stands at minus-44 points among Republicans. An astounding 61% of Republican voters hold an unfavorable view of him.
Indeed, Christie has, if anything, become more unpopular as the presidential campaign has gone on.
From what I can tell, he appears to have the lowest net favorability rating at this point in the cycle of any Republican running for president since at least 1980.
This doesn’t mean that Christie does not have a base of support within the GOP. A New York Times/Siena College poll from July illustrates the point well.
The former New Jersey governor led the Republican field (with 22%) among likely GOP primary voters who cast ballots for Joe Biden in 2020. The problem is this group makes up less than 10% of the Republican primary electorate. Christie earned only about 1% support among the remaining 90-something percent.
Christie’s not alone in his poor favorability ratings among Republican presidential candidates seen as anti-Trump.
Former Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson – who has called on the GOP to move on from Trump – was the only presidential contender during the first GOP debate last week not to raise his hand when candidates onstage were asked if they would back the former president as the party nominee even if he were convicted in a court of law. (Christie raised his hand but later gestured with a pointed finger, saying that Trump’s conduct should not be normalized. The former president skipped the Milwaukee debate.)
Prior to the debate, most Republicans (65%) hadn’t heard enough about Hutchinson to form an opinion, according to Quinnipiac. Those with an opinion viewed him unfavorably by more than a 3-to-1 ratio (26% unfavorable to 8% favorable, a net favorability rating of minus-18 points).
Former Texas Rep. Will Hurd, another Trump critic, didn’t make the debate stage, and the vast majority of Republicans (83%) haven’t heard enough of him to form an opinion. Among those who have, Hurd has a similar net favorability ratio to Hutchinson’s – 4% viewed him favorably and 11% unfavorably. This isn’t shocking given that Hurd has signaled he wouldn’t back Trump if the former president were the nominee.
Other polling data confirms the dilemma facing Christie, Hutchinson and Hurd. Beyond the fact that Trump is consistently viewed favorably by about 80% of his party – and as “strongly favorable” by more than 50% – most Republicans simply don’t want Republicans making the case against Trump.
A CBS News/YouGov poll taken prior to the GOP debate found that 91% of likely Republican primary voters wanted candidates to make their own case for the GOP nomination onstage. Just 9% wanted them to make the case against Trump.
That 91% figure makes it clear why South Carolina Sen. Tim Scott has been hesitant to attack other Republicans. He’s been seen as a happy warrior of sorts.
As a result, Scott has gone up in the polls and is at a consistent third place in Iowa. His net favorability rating among Republicans in the latest Quinnipiac national poll was plus-41 points, with 49% holding a favorable view of him and 8% an unfavorable one.
Scott has been a rare Republican to break through besides Trump and DeSantis.
The other Republican to do so has been Vivek Ramaswamy. The Ohio businessman has been unrelenting in his praise of Trump, going so far as pledging to pardon the former president if elected to the White House should Trump be convicted of a crime in federal court.
Ramaswamy was a top target at last week’s debate. That makes sense considering he is polling in third place on average nationally.
His net favorability rating was at plus-30 points in the Quinnipiac poll. Thirty-nine percent of Republicans had a favorable view of him, eclipsed only by the 51% who couldn’t even form an opinion.
Of course, the ultimate issue when it comes to going against Trump can perhaps best be seen in the CBS News poll. The former president’s supporters were asked about the truthfulness of what they hear from others. The vast majority of them (71%) felt that what Trump tells them is true – a higher percentage than those who said the same about friends and family (63%).
Given that Trump is commanding a majority of the GOP vote, Republicans seen as too negative toward him aren’t likely to go anywhere in the primary.
This leaves Trump’s GOP rivals with a conundrum that even Harry Houdini would find difficult to solve: how to eat away at Trump’s support without being seen as trying to bring him down.

Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, the Georgia Republican who once spoke at a white nationalist conference, took issue with what she deemed to be a “racist” incident at Wednesday’s GOP primary debate.
“I was pretty disgusted at Chris Christie and his racist comment towards Vivek Ramaswamy,” Greene said during a discussion on Right Side Broadcasting Network at the event, hosted by Fox News, in Milwaukee. “He compared him with Obama. I honestly thought that was pretty racist.”
Christie, the former governor of New Jersey, called out his rival on stage after the entrepreneur basically recycled a line used by former President Barack Obama.
“Who the heck is this skinny guy with a funny last name and what the heck is he doing in the middle of this debate stage?” Ramaswamy had said.
Obama famously called himself a “a skinny kid with a funny name who believes that America has a place for him, too,” during the 2004 Democratic National Convention keynote speech when he was running for the U.S. Senate.
Christie pointed that out, saying: “I’ve had enough already tonight of a guy who sounds like ChatGPT.”
“The last person in one of these debates … who stood in the middle of the stage and said, ‘What’s a skinny guy with an odd last name doing up here?’ was Barack Obama,” Christie said. “And I’m afraid we’re dealing with the same type of amateur.”
Greene attended the debate as a surrogate for Donald Trump, who was absent.
Ramaswamy has been loudly pro-Trump on the campaign trail and repeatedly defended him at Wednesday’s event. Christie, on the other hand, was the former president’s most vocal critic on the stage.
Greene apparently wasn’t fazed about actual racism and bigotry when she spoke last year at the America First Political Action Conference in Orlando, Florida, organized by prominent white nationalist Nick Fuentes; when she told two Muslim colleagues in Congress to “go back to the Middle East”; when she falsely claimed Obama is a Muslim and “opened up our borders to an invasion by Muslims,”; and when she told supporters that undocumented immigrants are “replacing your jobs and replacing your kids in school and, coming from all over the world, they’re also replacing your culture.”