The proposed Billionaire Tax Act, imposing a one-time 5% tax on the total wealth of Californians whose net worth is $1 billion or more, needs reconsideration.
Certainly, anyone with $1 billion (or more) has more than enough to live very comfortably, but there is an approach that would be less onerous to the billionaires and more helpful to the state.
A one-time 5% tax would bring in a windfall for the state — once. And since it would be a one-off, it would likely just get spent on one-off types of things, providing no long-term benefit.
Far better would be an annual wealth tax of, say, 0.5%. That’s just pulling a number out of the air, but the point is that it would generate a steady source of income — and not come as a jolt, one-time though it might be, to those being taxed.
Once again, we hear billionaires are fleeing California because of the possibility of a one-time 5% tax, but billionaires aren’t moving to buggy, high-humidity states. They are moving their LLCs to Nevada for “more flexible tax planning.” Buying a house in Florida doesn’t mean moving your life there. It means counting days to be able to pretend you don’t reside in California.
They pay lawyers and accountants to avoid paying taxes even if paying the taxes would be cheaper. Zero tax is the goal. California taxes income, not unrealized wealth, which is why so much billionaire wealth escapes taxation. A temporary tax won’t start an exodus.
So no, California won’t lose the billionaires. They aren’t making California weather anywhere else. I don’t care whether they enact this law or not — it won’t make any difference.
It’s clear that our government schools need competition. Denying the most important demographic in our country the opportunity to participate, along with their parents, in a competitive system denies them the chance to do well. The government schools are failing our students.
More tax money, more government and more unions won’t help. Parents and students need to be able to choose the school that will serve them the best. Competition benefits the consumer. This may be a new concept to some, but it’s a very important one. Politicians and school officials can talk all they want about insufficient taxes, but money alone won’t fix the problem.
Thomas Baker San Jose
Schools must provide classroom supplies
Teachers have to request basic classroom supplies through donation sites or fundraisers instead of receiving them from the school.
This is happening at schools in Cupertino Union School District, such as Miller Middle and Warren E. Hyde Middle, where teachers post projects asking for items such as art supplies, books and classroom tools. Teachers should have the materials they need without having to rely on donations.
I believe the school district should ensure that every classroom has all the basic supplies required. If the district provided these resources, teachers could focus fully on teaching, and students at Miller and other nearby schools would benefit. This issue affects not only our schools, but schools around the world.
I am writing this letter to encourage the government to make sure classrooms are properly supported.
Adithi Nimmagadda San Jose
What is Trump’s endgame with ICE?
I closely watch the news. I mostly watch MS NOW, or whatever NBC cable calls itself today. I’d watch right-wingers like Fox or Newsmax too, but can’t get past 30 seconds without hearing Trump-inspired lies.
What is striking is that no one, even the left, is connecting all the dots to expose Donald Trump’s goal of imposing military rule by provoking insurrection. He isn’t about migrants, deportation or even protest control. He doesn’t care who his thugs shoot. He only cares if they shoot back. This is what he’s waiting for. Once he gets the Army and Marines on your nearest corner, he has them where he needs them to control access to polling places later this year.
Mark my words: the pressure will remain until someone shoots and kills a Trump ICE agent. A nationwide Insurrection Act declaration will follow before the body is even cold.
Robert Wahler San Jose
Trump is given rope that will hang us all
Clay Bennett’s cartoon, pointing out the relationship between the Epstein file redactions and the flurry of new dramas, while not “funny,” does make chilling sense.
What I don’t understand is why our constitutional guardrails haven’t kicked in. Greenland, Venezuela, Iran, Minneapolis, plus our health care and pocketbooks, have created a world of chaos.
When Joe Biden demonstrated age-related decline at the debate, the nation was quick to anger and dump him. Now we have a president who repeatedly lies, insults people worldwide, is obviously in poor physical health and also shows age-related mental decline, and he is allowed to paint it all over in gold.
On a beach in Fiji competing on “Survivor,” the reality show that, like “48 Hours,” airs on CBS, Joe Hunter’s grief over the death of his sister Joanna came out in full force.
JOE HUNTER (“Survivor” season 48): I miss you so much. I just miss you so much.
“Survivor” contestant Joe Hunter’s emotional tribute to his late sister Joanna Hunter became one of the most talked about moments of season 48.
Survivor Productions LLC
JOE HUNTER (“Survivor” season 48): I am so sorry for the things I said. … And I never got the chance to say “I love you.” So, “I love you.”
Joe is still grappling with how she died.
DISPATCHER: 911, What’s your emergency?
CHURCH MEMBER: … I think someone’s dead.
A 911 call was made on Oct. 6, 2011 at 9:25 p.m. in Vacaville, California.
CHURCH MEMBER: My pastor just came out of the house, and he’s really, really upset and he told me to call the cops. He thinks his wife’s dead …
DISPATCHER: What’s his name?
CHURCH MEMBER: His name is Mark Lewis.
DISPATCHER: Can I talk to Mark?
DISPATCHER: … Can you tell me what happened?
MARK LEWIS: I have no clue what happened …
MARK LEWIS: Oh, I don’t want to talk about it. … I don’t want to talk about what she looks like.
THE SCENE AT JOANNA’S HOUSE
It was a terrible sight. Mark Lewis’ 36-year-old wife Joanna hanging inside a bedroom closet.
MARK LEWIS (to 911): Send somebody out here quick.
DISPATCHER: Mark, they’re on the way, honey.
14 minutes later, at 9:39 p.m., according to the Solano County Sheriff’s report, a deputy was on the scene.
Captain Jackson Harris reviewed the case with “48 Hours.”
Capt. Jackson Harris: He cut her down … tried to find any signs of life. …There were not any signs of life that were there, unfortunately.
A bathrobe sash had been the noose. The deputy’s report said, “he did not observe any signs of a struggle.” There was an open suitcase and a note.
A note reading “Take care of dogs” was found in an open suitcase in the bedroom of the home Joanna Hunter shared with her husband Mark Lewis.
Solano County Sheriff’s Office
Capt. Jackson Harris: I believe the note said, take care of the dogs.
Had Joanna taken her own life? Mark Lewis, the 36-year-old pastor of The Fellowship Baptist Church, was handcuffed, placed in the back of a patrol car, and briefly questioned.
Capt. Jackson Harris: He provided a statement.
He said his wife “did not appear to be depressed,” “has no history of mental illness” and “has never attempted suicide.”
Natalie Morales | “48 Hours” correspondent: The husband is saying … my wife did this out of the blue. …
Capt. Jackson Harris: That — that was his statement that he provided … people commit suicide for a variety of reasons. Some people keep it to themselves … some people tell the world.
In the report,Lewis said he last saw his wife at 1 p.m. And the church member who called 911, said he and Mark had been outside the house playing basketball and talking about their faith starting at 3 p.m., until Mark went inside and found Joanna dead.
Joanna’s mother, Patricia Hunter, knew nothing of what was unfolding at her daughter’s house that night. She wasn’t called. A day later, a deacon from the church, went to see her.
Patricia Hunter: He said, “Joanna is dead.” … What?
At around the same time, Joe, a Sacramento, California, firefighter, was taken aside by the captain of his firehouse.
Joe Hunter: He said, “your sister’s gone.”
“The day that I got the news will always be etched in my brain,” Joe Hunter says. “I knew right then, he had taken her life. … From that moment on, my life changed forever.”
Patricia Hunter
First, the gut punch.
Joe Hunter: I dropped to my knees.
And then, almost instantly, one thought, one name: Mark Lewis.
Patricia Hunter: What did he do to her?
Joe Hunter: I knew. I knew he did it.
Patricia Hunter: And I fell to the ground screaming, crying.
Joe Hunter: Half of me died right there.
A few weeks later when Patricia and her late husband spoke to an officer, he showed her the note.
Patricia Hunter: I actually laughed. And I said, “That’s not a suicide note.” … She was leaving him. And that was her note to him, take care of the dogs. I can’t take them.
A HISTORY OF ABUSE AND RESTRAINING ORDERS
Joanna had tried to leave Lewis many times before, says Patricia. There was a history of abuse and a cycle that began not long after the couple started seeing each other in high school. At 17, Patricia says, Joanna came home with a black eye.
Patricia Hunter: And I begged her. I said, let’s go to the hospital. Let’s go to the police … and she said, “no, mom, no.”
At 20, Joanna documented Lewis “choking” her and got a restraining order against him. Even so, Joanna returned to him.
At 21, after she reported that Lewis “grabbed my neck and twisted it,” Joanna got another restraining order.
In 1996, when she was 22, Joanna was hospitalized with a sprained neck. Mark Lewis was convicted on a domestic violence charge and according to court documents, sentenced to 36 months in the Solano County Jail.
Again, she returned to the relationship.
Patricia Hunter: She told me that he had reached out to her from jail … Would she come visit him? She did. She fell right back into it.
Joanna was 25 when she married Lewis without telling anyone in her family.
Patricia Hunter: I had to tell my husband, and we just held each other and sobbed because we knew now it would be that much harder to help her and get her out.
Their worry continued over the next decade, but Joanna wouldn’t open up to them.
Natalie Morales: You said you feared for your daughter, but did you ever think he would be capable of killing her?
Patricia Hunter: Absolutely.
That is what Patricia believed. Law enforcement at the scene came to the opposite conclusion.
Capt. Jackson Harris: There is no evidence on her body that another person used force to have killed her.
No homicide investigators were called to the house, the bedroom was not treated as a crime scene, no fingerprints taken, no DNA tested and no phones collected.
After his statement, Mark Lewis was released. Lewis was not asked about his history of abuse or about his prior conviction.
That information was more than 15 years old, says Harris, and not available to the deputy in the field.
The next day, an external autopsy determined the ligature marks on Joanna’s neck were consistent with suicide.
A month later, when the toxicology report came back clean, the case was closed. And so began the tug-of-war between the family and the sheriff’s department that would go on for years to come.
Patricia Hunter: From this moment, when we couldn’t get anyone to listen to us and act on it, we are going to work to get justice for Joanna.
Natalie Morales: Do you think she was ever suicidal?
Joe Hunter: You know … I’m sure she got in many dark places, but in no way, shape, or form, was she capable of that mindset because I know my sister deep down just wanted to leave.
And in the year before she died, Joanna almost saved herself, says Joe. Almost.
Joe Hunter: My mom called me and said, “Joanna’s coming home.” I said, “Oh, really?” “Yeah, she’s done.” And I said, “she’s really, really done this time?” … And I thought, man, like we got her back. We win.
Patricia Hunter: Within two weeks, mom, I — I’m going back. And I thought she meant to get more things. … And she said, no, mom, I have to go back to stay.
Joe Hunter: My mom begged her not to go back. … on her knees, begging her. … And my mom said, OK, well, I’ll drive you.
Natalie Morales: How much do you think of that moment and that drive, taking her back?
Patricia Hunter: All the time.
Patricia Hunter: On the way over … I was sobbing and I said, honey … I’m afraid if you go back, I’ll never see you again.
Joe Hunter: And we never saw her again.
A FAMILY’S ANGUISH
Joe Hunter: Joanna … was the perfect person. … She was the life of the party, but she was also at the same time … probably the most compassionate, warm person I’ve ever known.
From the minute he was born, Joanna relished being Joe’s big sister.
Patricia Hunter: She thought Joseph was her gift. … Someone gave her this adorable little boy and he belonged to her.
“We were the perfect team,” Joe Hunter says of his big sister, Joanna.
Patricia Hunter
Joe Hunter: I always tried to be in charge, but she wouldn’t let that happen. … Anybody that called the house … they had to go through Joanna first. … “and you wanna talk to my brother? Why?” (laughs) … She protected me a lot. … we were the perfect team.
Mark Lewis, the son of a local preacher, was Joanna’s first boyfriend. At the start, Joe didn’t think he had anything to worry about.
Joe Hunter: The first, maybe six to eight months, she seemed really happy.
But after the abuse began, Joe confronted Mark more than once.
Joe Hunter: After physically going after him … him then taking it out on her. … I had to back off a little bit from my sister. … I had been screaming at her for so long, two years straight. … I hate this guy, leave this guy, please stop. … I thought I’m gonna lose her for good. … So, I’m just gonna listen. … And then I really got the deep, deep, deep, dark secrets that she wasn’t even telling my parents.
And Joanna showed him her wounds.
Joe Hunter: She finally showed me … the massive indentations from him strangling her … you could just see clearly each outline of each finger.
Mark Lewis had grown more powerful and influential at the Fellowship Baptist Church. He was on his way to becoming pastor.
After they married, Patricia says she went to Lewis with her fears.
Patricia Hunter: And I said to him … how do I know in this moment that you will never lay a hand on her again? … And I’ll never forget. He kind of sneered, half smile and he looked at me and said, when she’s a better woman and a better Christian, you won’t have to worry about that.
Joe Hunter: My sister started saying comments that he would make to her like, hey, we can help save you. Because you’re half black, we can help fix that through religion. Because of your hair and the way you look, we can fix that with religion. … And you just think, how dare you?
Pastor Lewis, to hear former church members tell it, was a commanding and a demanding presence with fiery sermons and an insistence on loyalty.
Pastor Mark Lewis
Sarah Nottingham
Jacob Cantrell: Very energetic, get up there and screaming and sweating … that was his style.
Jacob Cantrell become a deacon there.
Jacob Cantrell: I looked up to him … he was a … mentor … only to find out that I was a pawn.
In hindsight, Cantrell says, Pastor Lewis had too much control over him.
Jacob Cantrell: I couldn’t go to my mom and dad’s house … without asking Mark permission. … I was brainwashed. … he manipulated me for many years and it — it — it — it twisted my brain up.
MARK LEWIS (preaching in church): There’s no accidents with God.
Jacob Cantrell: He can talk his way out of anything including Miss Joanna’s death.
Natalie Morales: Now, you feel that way?
Jacob Cantrell: Now, I feel that way.
Daryl Snedeker: I came to the conclusion that it was probably the closest thing to a cult that I had ever experienced.
Natalie Morales: And he was the leader …
Daryl Snedeker: The leader.
Daryl Snedaker was a deputy in the Solano County Sheriff’s Office and a member of the church at the time of Joanna’s death. He wasn’t involved in the investigation back then. At the church, he says, it didn’t take long for him to lose all faith in the place and the pastor.
Natalie Morales: Was there a fear then amongst the people who attended the church, did they fear Mark Lewis?
Daryl Snedeker: I think the people that were his puppets, I think they acted out of fear a lot.
Natalie Morales: You did whatever he asked then?
Jacob Cantrell: Unfortunately. … You don’t question him.
MARK LEWIS (preaching in church): It’s important that you listen up!
MARK LEWIS (preaching in church): What would you do if you caused your pastor to quit cause you wouldn’t obey? What would you do if you caused your Sunday School teacher to quit cause you wouldn’t obey?
Joe already knew Lewis all too well and the years after Joanna’s death were filled with anguish and frustration.
Joe Hunter: No one was listening to us, no one was believing this.
There were still so many questions about what happened that night. Why didn’t Lewis cut Joanna down or try to administer CPR? And Joe found it particularly hard to believe Lewis was actually playing basketball for six straight hours.
Joe Hunter: You never went inside to use the restroom, get a glass of water … playing basketball for this obscene amount of time … is absurd to me.
But all their attempts to get the sheriff’s office to take another look at Lewis were getting no results — until Patricia got a knock on the door.
Patricia Hunter: It was … a reporter asking if we had heard about what had happened with him. I had no idea what he was talking about.
It was 2014. Joanna had been dead a little more than two years. Pastor Mark Lewis had been arrested — accused of violence against another woman.
Natalie Morales: Do you feel lucky to be alive?
Sarah Nottingham: Oh yeah.
SARAH NOTTINGHAM’S HARROWING NIGHT
On that crisp fall day in 2011 when Pastor Mark Lewis said he found his wife dead, he never called Joanna’s family. He did call Sarah Nottingham.
Sarah Nottingham: He had asked if I heard what happened, he sounded upset. He was crying.
At the time, Nottingham says, she believed in her pastor — Joanna had died by suicide. Sarah says she and Lewis became friends, then began dating about a year after Joanna’s death.
Sarah Nottingham: At first, it was somewhat exciting thinking that … I’m seeing a side of this person that no one else is seeing.
Eventually, Nottingham says another side of Mark Lewis began to emerge.
Sarah Nottingham: A lot of … extreme manipulation, a lot of gaslighting, and a lot of verbal abuse, um, some physical. … A push or a shove. … And it was just more and more.
And then, she says, she discovered that Lewis had been sending inappropriate text messages to an underage girl.
Sarah Nottingham: You know, I’m just like, I’ve had enough, like, I’m done. And he said, I’m not ready for it to be over. … I would just keep telling him, you know, this is, it’s over, we’re done.
Lewis grabbed her, she says, and tightly wrapped his arms around her.
Mark Lewis and Sarah Nottingham.
Sarah Nottingham
Sarah Nottingham: It was meant to be threatening. He squeezed me tight and told me, “You’ve created a monster.”
Nottingham and her two young children were living with her parents in Vacaville as the pastor’s threats, she says, became more frequent and frightening.
Sarah Nottingham (outside her former home): The first time … my car was vandalized, it was actually parked here (pointing at the driveway).
Sarah Nottingham: He had, either himself or had somebody, smash my windshield in on my car.
Nottingham was granted an order of protection against Lewis. But it did not stop what happened next in the early morning hours of Jan. 9, 2014.
Sarah Nottingham: It was three something in the morning. And I woke up to our um fire alarm going off … and there was um smoke filling the hallway. And I checked on my kids.
A Molotov cocktail had crashed through her parents’ bedroom window.
Sarah Nottingham: We were able to put the fire out ourselves. … I had never seen my dad run so fast out the door, trying to see if he could see anybody.
Vacaville Police pulled over a U-Haul van within minutes, arresting the driver and two passengers. The trio quickly confessed, telling police they were hired to firebomb Sarah Nottingham’s house — hiredby the pastor, Mark Lewis. He was questioned by local reporters.
MARK LEWIS (KVOR news report): I never — I never gave them any money to do anything bad.
Lewis was arrested, charged with arson, conspiracy, and stalking.
Mark Lewis was arrested and charged with arson, conspiracy, and stalking against Sarah Nottingham.
Vacaville Police Department
MARK LEWIS (KVOR news report): A lot of people are going to … throw accusations out there. But until the facts come out, why don’t we just wait and see how that goes and let the court decide.
SARAH NOTTINGHAM (KOVR news report): I’m living in a nightmare. My kids are so scared. My — my son knows that this is, this is a pastor, his previous pastor that is threatening his mommy and his family.
Natalie Morales: What do you think you and your family survived at that time?
Sarah Nottingham: Ultimately, death. … When the police came into the house, one of them said this is attempted murder and that’s exactly what it was, nothing less.
Surviving the attack, Nottingham says, helped answer a lingering question about Joanna.
Natalie Morales: How do you see her death?
Sarah Nottingham: By him. … There’s just not a doubt in my mind.
By January 2015, Lewis’ thundering sermons that echoed in the Fellowship Baptist Church were a distant memory as he sat silently in a Solano County courtroom. Lewis’ trial had begun for stalking Sarah Nottingham and hiring people to firebomb her parents’ home.
Joe Hunter: I hear about the arson charge. I hear about the stalking. … But I also feel that he needs to be convicted … for what he did to my sister.
On day three of Lewis’ arson and stalking trial, he changed his plea from not guilty to no contest — meaning he would not dispute the charges against him but also would not acknowledge guilt. Lewis was sentenced to eight years in prison.
Natalie Morales: How important was that development then in allowing you to then go back to the sheriff’s office and demand that they reopen the case?
Patricia Hunter: It was huge, because there was — it isn’t often that you read about a pastor hiring people to firebomb someone’s house. … Because of media pressure, we felt that now is the time where we can go back and say, “Look at Joanna’s case. Reopen it.”
The Solano County Sheriff’s Office did reopen the case in 2014. Remember the churchgoer who called 911 the night Joanna died? His name is Andrew Alvarado. Back then he told authorities that he had played basketball with Pastor Mark Lewis for about six hours. Detectives decided to reinterview him and recorded the call.
DETECTIVE MEHL (phone call): Was anyone else playing basketball with you?
ANDREW ALVARADO: Yeah, a couple other … teenagers.
This time, investigators learned a new detail.
ANDREW ALVARADO (phone call): I left to go drop them off. I guess I had to go eat dinner or whatever.
He had actually leftthe church grounds during those six hours to drive the teenagers home, he says, and wasn’t sure what the pastor was doing while he was gone. “48 Hours” repeatedly reached out to Alvarado but never heard back.
Natalie Morales: So there were gaps of time when he was not with Mark Lewis.
Capt. Jackson Harris: Right. … That still does not change the fact that … the lack of evidence on her body does not show a second person involved in her death.
Mark Lewis was not questioned during the reinvestigation.
Capt. Jackson Harris: He … … exercised his constitutional right to have his attorney, who did not allow him to speak to us.
The sheriff’s office had anotherforensic pathologist look at Joanna’s case. Dr. Scott Luzi agreed with the original coroner: suicide. The case was closed again. And then in 2015, the county district attorney’s office announced its own investigation, which included DNA testing on Joanna’s bathrobe sash. The results? HerDNA was found on the sash along with an unknown male — not Mark Lewis.
Natalie Morales: Was anything done to investigate that further, to … could it have been anybody else associated with Mark Lewis?
Capt. Jackson Harris: That DNA that was collected from there, my understanding is that it was entered into the DNA — I believe it’s called CODIS, the database.
CODIS is the FBI’s criminal DNA database.
Capt. Jackson Harris: It did not come up with a hit.
Captain Harris says the anonymous male DNA has never been identified.
Daryl Snedeker: They should find out whose DNA is on that damn — on that — on that robe.
Daryl Snedeker, former church member and retired Solano County deputy sheriff, says things were missed.
Daryl Snedeker: Based on what I know today, the totality of the circumstances … … I think they did fail that family. And I think if they didn’t follow up and find out whose male DNA is on that night robe, that’s a catastrophic failure right there.
And a team of experts was about to come forward for the Hunter family, offering help and hope.
Dr. Bill Smock: This is a homicide. There is no question.
QUESTIONING THE INVESTIGATION
Dr. Bill Smock is sure that Joanna Hunter was murdered and says he can prove it.
Dr. Bill Smock: Every injury will tell you a story if you take the time to analyze it.
In 2023, Smock was hired by the Solano County Sheriff’s Department to look at the case. He is a medical doctor, who, by his count, has reviewed thousands of autopsies and examined forensic evidence for police departments across the country.
Smock also has been an expert witness in high profile cases — including testifying against Derek Chauvin in the 2021 George Floyd murder trial.
Dr. Bill Smock: What I’ve spent 40 years doing is analyzing injuries, reconstructing how injuries occur.
And where the Solano County Sheriff’s Department saw a bathrobe sash, a note and a suicide, Smock saw something else: something new.
Dr. Bill Smock: There was a braided nylon marine rope three feet from Joanna. … The murder weapon was there in the room with Joanna. … When you look at the photos of the mark that was created on her neck, the only thing in that closet that could have created that was the marine rope.
Dr. Bill Smock believes a braided rope found near Joanna’s body was the murder weapon.
Solano County Sheriff’s Office
But because he was required to sign a non-disclosure agreement, no one outside the sheriff’s office saw Smock’s report.
Dr. Bill Smock: I could not talk to the family … I could only talk to the lieutenant at Solano County regarding my findings.
Here was everything the Hunters had been looking for … but they did not even know the rope existed. Or how Smock made his determination. Smock was eventually released from the NDA and was able to show “48 Hours” using mannequins and red paint.
Smock says Joanna’s neck had two different ligature marks — one is from the sash and one is from the marine rope.
Using a mannequin and red paint, Dr. Bill Smock demonstrates the pattern of ligature marks found on Joanna Hunter’s neck during her autopsy.
CBS News
Dr. Bill Smock: We’re gonna apply the rope … and see what type of imprint it creates. … You’ll notice along the edge that there’s a distinct fabric imprint, which is the type of fabric imprint we saw on Joanna’s neck.
Bill Smock: She was dead —
Natalie Morales: When the bathrobe —
Bill Smock: — when the bathrobe sash was applied to her neck.
Bill Smock: Joanna’s scene was staged. She was killed with a rope, and then to make it look like a suicide, she was hung up by the bathrobe sash after she was already dead.
“I know in my heart that Mark killed my sister,” Joe Hunter tells “48 Hours.” And then he staged it to look like … she hung herself.
Patricia Hunter
Casey Gwynn: Domestic violence homicides are the number one staged murders in America.
Casey Gwinn was sure Joanna’s case was what he calls a hidden homicide. He and Gael Strack are the co-founders of Alliance for HOPE International, an advocacy group for survivors of domestic violence and their families.
Casey Gwynn: If you kill a total stranger … Nobody knows who you are … but if you kill your wife or you kill your girlfriend, everybody is gonna be looking at you as a suspect. … You have to make it look like something else.
When they took up the Hunters’ cause, they believed that Joanna’s history of neck injuries told them they were looking at a strangulation.
Casey Gwynn: The fact is that if you strangle a woman one time in an intimate relationship, she’s 750 percent more likely to be killed by you.
Smock, who works for Alliance for HOPE, confirmed their suspicion.
But when the sheriff’s office agreed to hire Smock, it also commissioned another review. This one by Dr. Brian Peterson, a pathologist and former president of the National Association of Medical Examiners. He disputed Smock’s findings.
“I see neither injuries nor toxicology findings that would support the physical involvement of another person,” the report said.
And after hiring Smock —
Capt. Jackson Harris: Especially in hindsight, I completely disagree with qualifications.
— the sheriff’s office took issue with the fact that Smock is not a forensic pathologist.
Harris also took issue with Smock’s methods.
Capt. Jackson Harris: This is not someone who has their body weight hanging … This is simply draped over a mannequin. That is not how she was killed.
Smock sent “48 Hours” his contract with the sheriff’s office, which requested his “opinion as to the cause and manner of her death.” He also told us the sheriff’s position was “disingenuous” … because “I didn’t agree with what they wanted me to say.”
Natalie Morales: So, Bill Smock’s report, are you completely discounting everything that he reports in it?
Capt. Jackson Harris: I’m — I’m disputing his conclusion that it was a homicide.
And so, what Dr. Smock called the murder weapon was never examined.
Natalie Morales: But where is the rope?
Capt. Jackson Harris: I don’t have the rope. I don’t know. … We also don’t have —
Natalie Morales: It wasn’t tested.
Capt. Jackson Harris: — every electrical cord that was there. We didn’t go through the garage to look for absolutely everything. …
Natalie Morales: What was missed? What about the history of domestic abuse, was that missed?
Capt. Jackson Harris: I don’t think it was missed.
Because three different forensic pathologists — and three separate reviews starting with the original corners report in 2011, the 2014 reinvestigation, and Dr. Peterson in 2024 – all found suicide, Harris maintains that even if they had initially taken the domestic violence into account, nothing would have changed.
Capt. Jackson Harris: And other than creating a hypothetical situation that Mark murdered her, there is no evidence to support that. …
Capt. Jackson Harris: The prior incidents of domestic violence, those were — I’m — I’m — those were not considered at the time of the death. You’re right. But that doesn’t mean that they were the cause of death.
Natalie Morales: Knowing all that you know now though, you said … You would’ve called Mark Lewis’s past into question and you would’ve investigated it differently.
Capt. Jackson Harris: If I — if I could rewind knowing what I know now about Mark Lewis, yes, this would be a totally different investigation.
But there is no rewinding, says Harris.
Natalie Morales: So is this still an open case now?
Capt. Jackson Harris: No, it’s closed.
Strack and Gwinn’s experience with Joanna’s case led them to create a checklist of 10 factors to be considered by law enforcement. They had begun drafting a new law — a law that included the red flags that could signal a homicide. Among them:
Gael Strack: The first one is someone dies prematurely. Well, Joanna was 36 years old. The second one, the scene looked like a suicide or an accident. … Prior history of domestic violence. … prior history of strangulation. … The partner is the last person to see the victim alive.
Casey Gwinn: We’ve never had a case with all 10 that wasn’t a homicide. Joanna Hunter had all 10 factors.
Mark Lewis has not been charged with any crime relating to the death of Joanna. After serving five years for the firebombing of Sarah Nottingham’s house, he was released on parole.
He currently lives in Arizona, works for a plumbing and drain cleaning company, and has married again. “48 Hours” tried to reach Lewis repeatedly and received no response.
So, after suiting up with hidden cameras we decided to go in person.
ADVOCATING FOR CHANGE: JOANNA’S LEGACY
Casey Gwinn: It is our earnest intention that one day, pastor Mark Lewis will be charged with first-degree murder in the death of Joanna Hunter.
With hidden cameras rolling, therewas Mark Lewis.
NATALIE MORALES (hidden camera): Mark Lewis? Hi, I’m Natalie Morales with “48 Hours.” We’ve been trying to reach you.
MARK LEWIS: Oh no, it’s all good.
“48 Hours” correspondent Natalie Morales approaches Mark Lewis to hear his side of the story.
CBS News
NATALIE MORALES: We’ve sent you a couple of letters and correspondence. … Would you be willing to speak to us on camera, sir?
MARK LEWIS: No.
NATALIE MORALES: Did you have anything to do with your late wife Joanna Hunter’s death, Mark Lewis?
MARK LEWIS: (turns his back and walks inside home)
NATALIE MORALES: Mark, please … We want your side of the story, Mark …
NATALIE MORALES: People would really like to hear your side of the story. … We’ve tried to reach you many ways.
With Lewis inside the house, we approached his father-in-law in the garage.
NATALIE MORALES: Hello sir … I’m just wondering if you have any concerns about your daughter’s own safety given his past history with domestic violence? His late wife was found hanging to death.
FATHER-IN-LAW: I — I know the whole story.
NATALIE MORALES: Yes.
FATHER-IN-LAW: I know the whole story. …
NATALIE MORALES: Did you know his late wife, Joanna Hunter?
FATHER-IN-LAW: Yes, I did.
NATALIE MORALES: Did you go to the church?
FATHER-IN-LAW: Yeah, I did.
NATALIE MORALES: You did.
FATHER-IN-LAW: OK, look —
NATALIE MORALES: I know, I know this is a difficult situation.
FATHER-IN-LAW: Well, actually, you know, I think this is really unnecessary. I really have nothing more to say.
NATALIE MORALES: I appreciate that, but I hope you understand there are a lot of questions still that the Hunter family would like to have answers to. And so I’m here simply doing my job giving your son-in-law a chance to answer some questions.
FATHER-IN-LAW: I can feel for them. But there’s really no more to say about it. It’s over. It’s done.
Mark Lewis was moving on with his new family, while his previous one was aching for answers.
Joe Hunter: For years, I was just trying to get to the next hour … to the next minute, because the pain was unbearable at times.
The Hunters, so accustomed to grief, were thrilled when Senate Bill 989 – Joanna’s Law – became California State law on Jan. 1, 2025, passing unanimously.
Senate Bill 989 – Joanna’s Law – became California State law on Jan. 1, 2025. The law contains a checklist that helps law enforcement look for red flags when responding to reported suicides, drug overdoses or fatal accidents to check for a history of domestic violence.
Patricia Hunter
Patricia Hunter: Joanna’s Law … gave us a sense of, we’ve done something wonderful for Joanna.
Joanna’s Law requires investigators responding to reported suicides, drug overdoses or fatal accidents to check for a history of domestic violence.
Patricia Hunter: If there is a documented history of domestic violence, to assume that this is a suspicious death.
Joe Hunter: And that they … treat that scene like a homicide.
Casey Gwinn and Gael Strack, who helped write Joanna’s Law, are using her case to spotlight the connection between suspicious deaths and domestic violence.
At a conference in Denver, they’re guiding law enforcement officers on how to identify those 10 red flags that could reveal hidden homicides.
CASEY GWINN (to attendees in a packed conference room): How many of you believe that this case should have a complete independent homicide investigation? Raise your hand. (Every hand goes up.)
“48 Hours” has learned the California Department of Justice has agreed to review the Solano County D.A.’s decision notto bring criminal charges related to Joanna’s death. The Hunters hope that will move the case forward.
Kayte Hunter: I look at it this way. Nothing can be kept in the dark forever.
Joe’s wife, Kayte, is a sideline reporter for the Sacramento Kings, and a former player in the WNBA. She experienced domestic violence herself in a teenage relationship.
Natalie Morales: have you talked to your daughter about domestic abuse?
Kayte Hunter: In the most basic form. She’s 6 right now. But we talk to her about … how you treat others and how you should be treated. And that will evolve over time.
Kayte Hunter: But it’s also conversations that we have with Jojo, with our son, because it is our responsibility to also teach him what is acceptable behavior and treatment of women. Period.
JOE HUNTER (in “Survivor” talking to Joanna): I’m sorry that I couldn’t protect you from that monster.
Joe’s tribute to Joanna on “Survivor” season 48 moved millions. This spring, he’ll compete again in a landmark season 50 to celebrate the game, which will also keep attention on his sister’s case.
Kayte Hunter: In advocating for his sister, he’s advocating for other victims, other women. … And our daughter’s gonna be so proud of it, our son.
Patricia Hunter: And she gives us so much love. Every day, I feel it.
For as long as she’s able, Patricia will tell Joanna’s story – often at the Sacramento Family Justice Center – a resource for survivors of domestic violence.
“I’m here to be her voice,” Patricia Hunter told a group gathered at the Justice Family Center. “Joanna was light. She was joy.”
CBS News
Joe Hunter: So when we talk about her, I just try to light the room up with her.
They hope Joanna’s Law — and Joanna’s light — will help save lives and shine the way forward for survivors of domestic violence.
Joe Hunter: She fought from the beginning to her last breath. So no matter how hard it gets, never give up. That’s her legacy.
RESOURCES:
“48 HOURS” POST MORTEM PODCAST
Correspondents Anne-Marie Green and Natalie Morales discuss “Survivor” contestant Joe Hunter’s mission to raise awareness about his sister, Joanna, who was found dead in her California home in 2011. Joe and his family believe that Joanna’s husband, Mark Lewis, killed her and staged it to look like a suicide. But the Solano County Sheriff’s office says Joanna was not murdered. Mark Lewis has never been charged with any crime relating to her death.
Produced by Mary Murphy and Mead Stone. Michelle Fanucci is the development producer. Emily Wichick Hourihane is the field producer. Greg Fisher is the development producer. Doreen Schechter, Atticus Brady, Mead Stone are the editors. Patti Aronofsky is the senior producer. Nancy Kramer is the executive story editor. Jusy Tygard is the executive producer.
LOS ANGELES — TikTok agreed to settle a landmark social media addiction lawsuit just before the trial kicked off, the plaintiff’s attorneys confirmed.
What You Need To Know
TikTok has agreed to settle in a landmark social media addiction lawsuit just before the trial kicked off, the plaintiff’s attorneys confirmed
The social video platform was one of three companies facing claims that their platforms deliberately addict and harm children, along with Meta’s Instagram and Google’s YouTube
Snapchat’s parent company Snap Inc., settled the case last week for an undisclosed sum
Additional details of the settlement with TikTok were not disclosed
The social video platform was one of three companies — along with Meta’s Instagram and Google’s YouTube — facing claims that their platforms deliberately addict and harm children. A fourth company named in the lawsuit, Snapchat parent company Snap Inc., settled the case last week for an undisclosed sum.
Details of the settlement with TikTok were not disclosed, and the company did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
At the core of the case is a 19-year-old identified only by the initials “KGM,” whose case could determine how thousands of other, similar lawsuits against social media companies will play out. She and two other plaintiffs have been selected for bellwether trials — essentially test cases for both sides to see how their arguments play out before a jury and what damages, if any, may be awarded, said Clay Calvert, a nonresident senior fellow of technology policy studies at the American Enterprise Institute.
A lawyer for the plaintiff said in a statement Tuesday that TikTok remains a defendant in the other personal injury cases, and that the trial will proceed as scheduled against Meta and YouTube.
Jury selection starts this week in the Los Angeles County Superior Court. It’s the first time the companies will argue their case before a jury, and the outcome could have profound effects on their businesses and how they will handle children using their platforms. The selection process is expected to take at least a few days, with 75 potential jurors questioned each day through at least Thursday. A fourth company named in the lawsuit, Snapchat parent company Snap Inc., settled the case last week for an undisclosed sum.
KGM claims that her use of social media from an early age addicted her to the technology and exacerbated depression and suicidal thoughts. Importantly, the lawsuit claims that this was done through deliberate design choices made by companies that sought to make their platforms more addictive to children to boost profits. This argument, if successful, could sidestep the companies’ First Amendment shield and Section 230, which protects tech companies from liability for material posted on their platforms.
“Borrowing heavily from the behavioral and neurobiological techniques used by slot machines and exploited by the cigarette industry, Defendants deliberately embedded in their products an array of design features aimed at maximizing youth engagement to drive advertising revenue,” the lawsuit says.
Executives, including Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg, are expected to testify at the trial, which will last six to eight weeks. Experts have drawn similarities to the Big Tobacco trials that led to a 1998 settlement requiring cigarette companies to pay billions in health care costs and restrict marketing targeting minors.
“Plaintiffs are not merely the collateral damage of Defendants’ products,” the lawsuit says. “They are the direct victims of the intentional product design choices made by each Defendant. They are the intended targets of the harmful features that pushed them into self-destructive feedback loops.”
The tech companies dispute the claims that their products deliberately harm children, citing a bevy of safeguards they have added over the years and arguing that they are not liable for content posted on their sites by third parties.
“Recently, a number of lawsuits have attempted to place the blame for teen mental health struggles squarely on social media companies,” Meta said in a recent blog post. “But this oversimplifies a serious issue. Clinicians and researchers find that mental health is a deeply complex and multifaceted issue, and trends regarding teens’ well-being aren’t clear-cut or universal. Narrowing the challenges faced by teens to a single factor ignores the scientific research and the many stressors impacting young people today, like academic pressure, school safety, socio-economic challenges and substance abuse.”
A Meta spokesperson said in a statement Monday the company strongly disagrees with the allegations outlined in the lawsuit and that it’s “confident the evidence will show our longstanding commitment to supporting young people.”
José Castañeda, a Google Spokesperson, said Monday that the allegations against YouTube are “simply not true.” In a statement, he said “Providing young people with a safer, healthier experience has always been core to our work.”
TikTok did not immediately respond to a request for comment Monday.
The case will be the first in a slew of cases beginning this year that seek to hold social media companies responsible for harming children’s mental well-being. A federal bellwether trial beginning in June in Oakland, California, will be the first to represent school districts that have sued social media platforms over harms to children.
In addition, more than 40 state attorneys general have filed lawsuits against Meta, claiming it is harming young people and contributing to the youth mental health crisis by deliberately designing features on Instagram and Facebook that addict children to its platforms. The majority of cases filed their lawsuits in federal court, but some sued in their respective states.
TikTok also faces similar lawsuits in more than a dozen states.
It was a relatively quiet start to 2026, with winter storms bringing heavy snow to the typical snow belts. The hardest-hit states included Michigan and New York, where lake-effect snows have added up, with some areas seeing well over 100 inches.
What You Need To Know
Snow was reported from New Mexico and Texas to Maine
Freezing rain and sleet brought icy conditions to Mid-South and South
Five tornadoes touched down in Alabama and Florida on Sunday
However, the Mid-South, Mid-Atlantic, and even the Northeast hadn’t seen as active a start. In fact, these regions began the year with temperatures above average, some even having top ten warmest starts to January. But all of that changed on Jan. 23.
At one point, a large storm stretched over two-thousand miles, with millions of people under a weather alert.
Southern snow and ice totals
Two storm systems merged as arctic air surged south across much of the U.S. By Jan. 23, snow began falling in New Mexico. The highest snowfall accumulated near Bonita Lake, NM., where 31 inches of snow fell.
As the storm emerged east of New Mexico into Texas, it picked up moisture from the Gulf. Snow, sleet and freezing rain fell across the South. Dallas and Fort Worth, TX., picked up 1 to 2 inches with bitter cold that followed.
Northern Arkansas and Oklahoma saw higher totals, ranging from 6 to 8 inches, with a mix of sleet and freezing rain in parts of Arkansas.
Mid-South snow and ice
By Saturday, Jan. 24, snow and ice moved through the Mid-South, with the heaviest snow occurring Saturday night into Sunday across Kansas, Missouri, Kentucky and Illinois.
With cold air in place in Missouri, snowfall totals range from 5 inches around Kansas City to over a foot of snow south of St. Louis. Kentucky saw snow at the onset before switching to a mix of snow and sleet, which limited the totals.
As the storm moved through Illinois, Indiana and Ohio Saturday into Sunday, it was mainly a snow event. Totals ranged from 6 to 9 inches across the region.
The Northeast and New England snow
With cold air in place in the north, it was an all-snow event in this region. The storm dumped over a foot of snow onto New York City, with the Boston area picking up nearly two feet of snow Sunday through Monday evening.
York, Maine, in the southern part of the state, accumulated 20 inches of snow.
Mid-Atlantic snow and ice
Snow fell in parts of the Mid-Atlantic before changing to sleet. Washington D.C. saw nearly 7 inches of snow before it mixed with and changed to sleet.
Central North Carolina picked up a few flakes before it mixed with and changed over to sleet. While not as icy as freezing, sleet still caused treacherous road conditions.
Southeast snow and ice totals
The colder air was in place in the northern parts of Alabama, Georgia and Upstate South Carolina. Some snow fell at the onset of the storm before mixing with and changing to sleet and freezing rain. Ice Storm Warnings were posted on Sundy and Monday across the region.
Severe side of the storm
The National Weather Service confirmed that five tornadoes touched down on Sunday. Four of them in Alabama and one in Florida. The highest rated tornado was an EF2 with winds estimated of 115 mph in Geneva County, Ala.
Airport delays
With all of the intense weather of the pass few days, airport delays and cancelations are prevalent. Here’s the latest below.
Cold air remains locked in place for the eastern two-thirds of the country.
Our team of meteorologists dives deep into the science of weather and breaks down timely weather data and information. To view more weather and climate stories, check out our weather blogs section.
Registered nurse Silvia Lu was working the day shift at UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital in Oakland when she read about the shooting death of ICU nurse Alex Pretti, who was protesting the ICE immigration crackdown on the streets of Minneapolis.
On a day shift in the emergency department Saturday, where Lu often cares for children recovering from heart surgeries and car crashes, she struggled to hold back her emotions.
“I held my tears back the whole day,” she said.
She carried that pent-up grief outside the hospital Monday evening, where she joined about 200 others, mostly nurses, in a candlelight vigil to remember the 37-year-old Minnesota nurse whose death has become the latest flashpoint in the Trump administration’s immigration enforcement surge.
Just weeks earlier, videos circulating online showed an ICE officer shooting and killing Renee Good, another Minnesota protester and mother of three, as she attempted to drive away during a separate enforcement operation, according to media reports.
“I just felt I needed to do something. I needed to stand up for this and to just make myself present to the horrendous things that are going on in this country,” said Mary Dhont, a nurse in the hospital’s outpatient infusion clinic who joined the vigil organized by the California Nurses Association. “This is just the latest in a string. But it was horrible. The fact that he was a nurse just brought it closer to home.”
Registered nurse Hannah Pelletier, center, friend Tim McNamara, left, and others attend a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Healthcare professionals and others are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
The nurses’ vigil came after a weekend of scattered protests in San Francisco, San Jose and Oakland over Pretti’s death.
So far, the Bay Area has been spared the kind of sweeping federal operation underway in Minneapolis. There, videos and news reports have shown ICE agents pulling people from their vehicles and detaining children during enforcement actions. Separate bystander videos captured the shootings of both Pretti and Good.
In October, after President Donald Trump sent 4,000 National Guard troops to Los Angeles, he threatened to deploy them to San Francisco as well to clean up the city’s “mess.” But the president backed off after appeals from San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie and tech executives, including Marc Benioff, the Salesforce CEO whose family name is attached to the Oakland children’s hospital.
On Monday, in a petition circulating online, a group of tech workers urged Silicon Valley executives to flex their political muscle again and “cancel all company contracts with ICE.”
“This cannot continue, and we know the tech industry can make a difference,” they wrote. “Today, we’re calling on our CEOs to pick up the phone again.”
Nurses said they were especially worried about the families of their young patients.
Registered nurse Michelle Trautman, center, and others attend a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Protesters are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
“We take care of a lot of families, immigrant families, patients that may not have the ability to afford care otherwise,” said nurse Michelle Trautman. “And I’m concerned that they’re going to try and take advantage of that vulnerability to grab some of our patients and send them away when they obviously need care.”
In the hours after Pretti’s death, Trump administration officials said the shooting was justified, arguing that because Pretti carried a legally registered handgun in his waistband, he posed a threat to officers and intended a “massacre.” Trump adviser Stephen Miller called Pretti an “assassin.”
Those characterizations outraged his family and Democratic politicians, who pointed to bystander videos showing Pretti helping a woman who had been pushed by an ICE agent and holding only his camera.
He was pinned to the ground by multiple ICE agents, the videos show, and his gun had already been pulled from his waistband by an agent when he was shot several times.
The Bay Area’s Democratic congressional delegation has responded by voting against a Department of Homeland Security appropriations bill that would provide additional funding for ICE.
Healthcare professionals and community members attend a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Healthcare professionals and others are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
“I cannot and will not continue to fund lawlessness or federal agencies that terrorize families in their own neighborhoods and criminalize people for seeking opportunity and refuge,” U.S. Rep. Lateefah Simon, D-Oakland, said in a statement. “What we’re witnessing is cruel, immoral, and completely at odds with the promise of the American dream.”
U.S. Rep. Sam Liccardo, San Jose’s former mayor, also voted against further funding.
“ICE has abandoned its mission of removing violent criminals in favor of detaining children, shooting Americans, and terrorizing our communities,” he said in a statement.
At the busy intersection of 52nd Street and Martin Luther King Jr. Way on Monday evening, streams of cars honked and waved as they passed nurses and other supporters holding signs reading “Melt ICE” and “Justice for Alex Pretti.”
Aaron Cortez, of Oakland, attends a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Healthcare professionals and others are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
Aaron Cortez, 28, of Alameda, said fear drove him to attend the vigil.
His family has lived in California for generations, with relatives who served in the U.S. military, but he still worries about a potential ICE raid.
“They just see me by the color of my skin, and that worries me,” said Cortez, who cares for ailing relatives at home. “And so I decided to come out because I had to, I needed to show that we’re all here together, that no matter what happens, we will all protect each other.”
Former San Francisco city attorney Nancy Tavernit, right, attends a protest at UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Healthcare professionals and others are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)
Healthcare professionals and community members attend a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Protesters are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
Nurse practitioner Sarah Malin-Roodman attends a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Healthcare professionals and others are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
Healthcare workers and community members protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Protesters are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
Retired nurse Gina Shepherd attends a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Healthcare professionals and others are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
Registered nurse Hannah Pelletier, center, and others attend a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Healthcare professionals and others are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
Community members Mary Larson and Simone Schmidt, from left, attend a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Protesters are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
Healthcare professionals and community members attend a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Protesters are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
Healthcare workers Wendy Bloom, Holly Alley and Sherry Alcock, from left, attend a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Protesters are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
Registered nurse Michelle Trautman, and friend Hannah Pelletier, from right, attend a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Protesters are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
Nurse practitioner and midwife Kate McGlashan, right, and others protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Protesters are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
Healthcare workers and community members take part in a protest outside of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Protesters are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)l
1 of 12
Former San Francisco city attorney Nancy Tavernit, right, attends a protest at UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland in Oakland, Calif., on Monday, Jan. 26, 2026. Healthcare professionals and others are demanding justice and the abolishment of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) in the wake of the killing of Veteran’s Administration nurse Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. (Jane Tyska/Bay Area News Group)
For more than a decade, the California State Auditor has issued warnings to lawmakers about government waste, fraud, cost overruns, and broken oversight systems across state government. Again and again, audits called for changes in state law meant to fix those problems.
In many cases, those fixes did not happen.
CBS News California Investigates recently exposed how lawmakers ignored years of warnings from the California State Auditor about hidden traffic violation fees.
That raised a broader question: What other audit warnings have lawmakers been ignoring, and at what cost?
An exclusive CBS News California analysis of state audit recommendations dating back to 2015 found lawmakers failed to enact three out of every four recommendations that required legislative action.
These are audits the Legislature asked for. Audits Californians paid for. Audits with recommendations that remain unresolved, while California continues to lose money to potential waste and fraud.
California’s Unfinished Business
CBS News California analyzed state audit recommendations dating back to 2015 and found the following.
California lawmakers failed to act on three out of every four state audit recommendations
There are more than 300 outstanding recommendations to the legislature
The outstanding recommendations impacted more than 100 different issues and agencies
Two out of three state auditsincluderecommendations on which the auditor notes that lawmakers have taken “no action” at all.
CBS News California Investigates is now building a publicly searchable “Audit Accountability Tracker” to help viewers and voters track what lawmakers have not done and what that inaction costs Californians.
The database is not yet public, but the early findings reveal a series of patterns the Auditor has documented for years: the same problems, the same risks, the same inaction.
Billions lost to fraud and broken oversight
The analysis reveals that some of California’s most costly cases of fraud or untracked spending were the subjects of numerous prior audits. According to the auditor, state losses may have been mitigated if lawmakers had acted on earlier recommendations.
“There would still be issues, but not as serious as we are now,” former California State Auditor Elaine Howle told CBS News California in 2021 while discussing two audits related to pandemic unemployment fraud.
Prior audits warned lawmakers that the state’s Employment Development Department (EDD) left Californians vulnerable to fraud, but by the time lawmakers acted, it was too late.
It’s estimated that California lost more than $20 billion to pandemic unemployment fraud when EDD issued billions in fraudulent payments to criminals while out-of-work Californians struggled to get an EDD rep on the phone, let alone get paid.
Homelessness spending offers another example of state audit warnings that lawmakers ignored. The Auditor repeatedly warned lawmakers that California lacks a statewide plan, outcome tracking and accountability for homelessness program spending.
Outstanding audit recommendations also involve risks to public safety and public health that may have been mitigated if lawmakers acted sooner.
For instance, the auditor found that water districts were failing to tell people that their drinking water was unsafe. It’s an issue CBS News California has been covering for years.
Lawmakers even failed to act on polices that, according to the auditor, put child abuse victims at risk.
In all, CBS News California identified more than 300 outstanding audit recommendations.
New lawmakers, old warnings
CBS News California Investigates shared some of our findings with Assemblymember John Harabedian, the new chair of the Joint Legislative Audit Committee (JLAC). The JLAC committee decides which issues the auditor investigates.
“When I hear that there are many audits and recommendations that haven’t been addressed, I think that’s a wake-up call, Harabedian said.”
Harabedian is part of a large new class of lawmakers, many of whom were not in office when the recommendations were written.
“I think that being new to the Legislature and now being the chair of the Joint Legislative Audit Committee, I am keenly focused on oversight,” he said. “I do think investigative journalism, what you’re doing, is important. It keeps everyone accountable and highlights issues that might not be on my radar or (my colleagues’) radar.”
What comes next
CBS News California Investigates is building an Audit Accountability Tracker, a public database designed to show in one place:
What the State Auditor told lawmakers to fix
Which recommendations required changes in state law
Which ones remain unresolved
Why they matter to Californians
We are also waiting for additional financial records from the California State Auditor’s office to quantify the potential cost of inaction and potential future savings if lawmakers act.
The tracker will serve voters and viewers as well as the more than 30 new lawmakers who were not in office when many of these audits were issued.
The warnings are written, solutions identified.
The question is, will the new class of lawmakers finish what their predecessors started?
DEAR JOAN: Recently I noticed mushrooms growing at the base of one of the juniper trees in the backyard. It was interesting, so I took a picture.
A couple of days ago, I noticed that the mushrooms were gone, and there were scratch marks in the damp earth at the base where the mushrooms had been.
I am curious as to what animal could have eaten the mushrooms, and if that animal is in any danger from poisoning. I see raccoons, possums, squirrels, and birds on my backyard camera.
Who is the most likely culprit, or victim?
— Nancy McKiernan, Sunnyvale
DEAR NANCY: The winter rains can turn our Bay Area yards into fairylands with mushrooms popping up all over. While it is never a good idea to eat one without knowing exactly what type it is, animals don’t have the benefit of being able to call on a mycologist to determine the identity.
Instead, they rely on taste, outcome and experience. If a wild animal eats a mushroom that later makes it ill, it will avoid those mushrooms in the future, provided they survive. They’ll likely also stay away from anything that has a same or similar taste. That provides them with some protection against eating the poisonous ones.
In the Bay Area, there are two mushrooms that are unsafe for any creature, and those are the death cap (Amanita phalloides) and the western destroying angel (Amanita ocreata). Both are commonly found near and around oak trees.
As for what animal would eat the golden hued mushrooms you observed, the list is long. Mushrooms are a treat for wildlife as they have a high water content, are a good source of protein, and a good source of vitamins and phosphorus.
Rats, squirrels, deer, box turtles, wild turkeys, and wild boars, just to name a few that might be visiting your yard, all love mushrooms. The scratches you observed lead me to think of turkeys, but there’s no way to know for certain.
DEAR JOAN: I’m already thinking about spring and what I’ll be planting in my vegetable garden. Last year, much of the garden was eaten by rats, birds and squirrels. I’m wondering if one of those plastic owls would scare them away?
— Alice B., Clayton
DEAR ALICE: Decoys do work, however briefly, against the birds but it’s unlikely the rats and squirrels will even raise an eyebrow.
Stationary owl statues and other decoys might keep the birds away for a day or two, but then the birds figure out there’s no threat, and before you know it, they’re perching on the fake owl’s head and having a good laugh.
You want something that will move unpredictably. Objects that are pushed and pulled by the wind, and which add unexpected flashes of light have a better and longer track record of success. You can hang reflective ribbons or old CDs throughout the garden.
For the rats and squirrels, the only thing stopping them are physical barriers. Surrounding your garden with a hardware cloth fence and a shock wire on top will do wonders.
The Animal Life column runs on Mondays. Contact Joan Morris at AskJoanMorris@gmail.com.
A car being pursued by California Highway Patrol officers early Sunday, Jan. 25 flew off the 105 Freeway and crashed to the ground below near Los Angeles International Airport, the CHP said.
The driver’s face was bloody, and he appeared dazed after El Segundo firefighters cut him out of a Chevrolet Camaro, as seen in a video by freelance news organization OnScene.TV. The man was arrested and hospitalized.
California Highway Patrol officers arrest a man who they say led them on a pursuit early Jan. 25, 2026, before crashing off the 105 Freeway near Los Angeles International Airport. (Photo by OnScene.TV)
The pursuit began when officers attempted to pull over the car for speeding on the westbound 10 Freeway at Vincent Avenue, CHP spokeswoman Megan Curtiss said. The driver failed to stop, and the crash happened around 2:07 a.m. near N. Nash Street and Imperial Highway, she said.
A California Highway Patrol officer looks down on a crash scene after a car being pursued flew off the 105 Freeway near Los Angeles International Airport early on Jan. 25, 2026. (Photo by OnScene.TV)
The OnScene.TV footage showed a red sedan that was apparently involved in a collision at the end of the pursuit. The video also showed a gun that the CHP had seized, as well as a saw and a computer device. No details about those items were available on Sunday.
A little over 24 hours after a federal immigration agent shot and killed Alex Pretti amid protests a few miles away from Target Center, causing the postponement of Saturday’s game between the visiting Warriors and the Wolves, the longtime Golden State coach gave his first public statements on the situation.
“I love the city of Minneapolis, and people here are wonderful. And it’s very sad, what’s happening, and I feel for the city,” Kerr said. “There’s a pall that has been cast over the city. You can feel it, and a lot of people are suffering. Obviously, loss of life is the No. 1 concern. Those families will never get their family members back. And you know, when all the unrest settles down, whenever that is, those family members won’t be returning home, and that’s devastating.”
Kerr said Warriors general manager Mike Dunleavy alerted him Saturday morning that the league was considering postponing the game.
He also received calls from both Wolves coach Chris Finch and veteran forward Joe Ingles, who let Kerr know that the Wolves players were “feeling really uneasy” about the situation.
“I told Chris and Joe, ‘We trust you guys. We trust the league, whatever makes the most sense,’” Kerr said. “So ultimately, obviously, the game was postponed. I totally agree with the decision. Everything should be about safety and concern for not only the players and the fans, but everybody here in Minneapolis with what’s going on.”
BCA officers stand near the scene of a fatal shooting that took place yesterday, in Minneapolis, Sunday, Jan. 25, 2026. (AP Photo/Adam Gray)
Ultimately, the NBA postponed the game just under three hours before tipoff. Kerr’s teams have previously gone through sudden postponements.
The Warriors coach was just a rookie on the Phoenix Suns when his team had its game cancelled in Miami during the riots of 1989. Over three decades later, the Warriors’ games against the Jazz and Mavericks were postponed after the sudden death of Golden State assistant coach Dejan Milojević.
The Warriors arrived in Minneapolis on Friday afternoon and watched as tens of thousands of people marched down the streets to protest the protracted presence of federal immigration officers in the city.
Though protests did not break out near the arena on Saturday, they were in full force a few hours before tipoff on Sunday afternoon. Hundreds held signs expressing displeasure at Immigration and Customs Enforcement being in the city, and chants rang through the crowded streets.
Minneapolis Police Chief Brian O’Hara told reporters on Saturday that a 37-year-old man was killed on Saturday morning but did not identify him, citing limited information about what led up to the shooting. The man was identified by his parents as Alex Pretti, an intensive care unit nurse.
Minnesota Timberwolves guard Mike Conley (10) and Minnesota Timberwolves guard Anthony Edwards (5) celebrate after Conley scores during the first half of Game 5 of an NBA basketball second-round playoff series against the Golden State Warriors, Wednesday, May 14, 2025, in Minneapolis. (AP Photo/Abbie Parr)
The protests continued inside the arena.
During a moment of silence held in honor of Pretti, several fans could be heard yelling “(expletive) ICE,” although no physical signs or written messages in opposition to immigration personnel were seen in the lower bowl.
During a break in the action with about five minutes left in the first half, chants of “ICE out” were heard while De’Anthony Melton was shooting free throws. In the third quarter, several members of the Target Center’s dunk crew entertainment team were seen wearing “ICE OUT” shirts.
When the game was being played, neither team was very sharp. The Timberwolves, understandably, appeared to lack focus during the first half, turning the ball over 16 times in the first 24 minutes.
The Warriors led 47-46 at halftime as both sides seemed to just go through the motions, and Golden State pulled away in the third quarter after outscoring the home team 38-17. The Warriors (26-21) snapped a two-game skid, which was the same number of games the team had played without Jimmy Butler, who was lost for the season on Monday with a torn ACL.
Steph Curry scored 26 points, passing John Havlicek and tying with another Celtic great, Paul Pierce (26,397), for 19th on the all-time scoring list.
Teammate Moses Moody scored 19, while Brandin Podziemski put in 12 points. Anthony Edwards poured in 30 points for the Timberwolves, while former Warrior Donte DiVincenzo scored 22.
The teams will play again here on Monday at 6:30 PT.
Kerr decried the death of Good when it occurred several weeks ago, blasting the federal government during an impassioned monologue.
But on Sunday, Kerr struck a message of unity, asking his fellow Americans to respect one another.
“It’s hard to decipher what’s real and what’s not, what’s true and what’s not true,” Kerr said. “People arguing over the exact same video and saying, ‘This happened. No, that happened.’ It is a confusing time to be alive and to be an American, and so what I would appeal to everyone is to remember what our constitution stands for, what our values are, and what that means to how we treat each other and our fellow citizens.”
Information from The Associated Press was used in this report.
Voting is the most elemental of democratic exercises, a virtuous act residing right up there alongside motherhood and apple pie. But Trump has treated it as a cudgel, something dark and sinister, fueling a partisan divide that has increasingly undermined faith in the accuracy and integrity of our elections.
One result is a batch of new laws making it harder to vote.
Since the 2020 presidential election — the most secure in American history, per the Trump administration’s own watchdogs — at least 30 states have enacted more than 100 restrictive laws, according to New York University’s Brennan Center and the Democracy Policy Lab at UC Berkeley, which keep a running tally.
In California, state Sen. Carl DeMaio and allies are working to qualify a November ballot measure that would require a government-issued ID to vote, a solution in desperate search of a problem.
“We have the lowest level of public trust and confidence in our elections that we have ever seen,” the San Diego Republican said in launching the effort, sounding the way someone would by lamenting the damage a fire has done while ignoring the arsonist spreading paint thinner all around.
Amid all the manufactured hysteria, there is a place that is unique in America, with no voter registration requirement whatsoever.
If you’re a U.S. citizen, 18 years or older and have lived in North Dakota for 30 days prior to election day, you’re eligible to vote. It’s been that way for more than 70 years, ever since voter registration was abolished in the state in 1951.
How’s it working?
Pretty darn well, according to those who’ve observed the system up close.
“It works excellent,” said Sandy McMerty, North Dakota’s deputy secretary of state.
“In general, I think most people are happy with this,” political scientist Mark Jendrysik agreed, “because it lowers the record-keeping burdens and saves money.”
Jendrysik, who teaches at the University of North Dakota in Grand Forks, said voter registration was abandoned at a time when the state — now redder than the side of a barn — had vigorous two-party competition and, with it, a bipartisan spirit of prairie populism.
“There was an idea we should make it easier to vote,” Jendrysik said. “We should open up things.”
What a concept.
Walk-up voting hasn’t made North Dakota a standout when it comes to casting ballots. In the last three elections, voter turnout has run close to the national average, which puts it in the middle of the pack among states.
But there also hasn’t been a high incidence of fraud. In 2022, a study by the state auditor’s office found it “exceptionally” unlikely an election in North Dakota could be fraudulently influenced. (Again, like the country as a whole.)
In fact, Jendrysik said he can’t recall a single case of election fraud being prosecuted in the 26 years he’s lived in North Dakota and followed its politics.
It’s not as though just anyone can show up and cast a ballot.
Voting in North Dakota requires a valid form of identification, such as a state-issued driver’s license, a tribal ID or a long-term care certificate. It must be presented each and every election.
By contrast, a California voter is not required to show identification at a polling place before casting their ballot — though they may be asked to do so if they are voting for the first time after registering to vote by mail and their application failed to include certain information. That includes a driver’s license number or the last four digits of their Social Security number.
Could North Dakota’s non-registration system be replicated elsewhere?
North Dakota is a sparsely populated state with hundreds of small communities where, seemingly, everyone knows everyone else. There are about 600,000 eligible voters, which is a lot more manageable number than, say, California’s 30 million adult-age residents. (California has more than a dozen counties with north of half a million registered voters.)
“It’s unique to this state,” Jendrysik said, “and I think if they hadn’t done it decades ago, it would have never happened.”
(Fun fact: North Dakota also has no parking meters on its public streets, owing to a state law passed in 1948, according to Jendrysik, who has published two academic papers on the subject.)
McMerty, of the secretary of state’s office, believes others could emulate North Dakota’s example.
It would require, she suggested, rigorous data-sharing and close coordination among various state agencies. “We’re updating our voter rolls daily — who’s obtained a driver’s license, births, deaths. That kind of thing,” McMerty said.
Again, that’s a much easier task in a state with the population the size of North Dakota’s. (About 800,000 at last count.)
And there’s no particular impetus for others to end their systems of voter registration — unless it could be proved to significantly boost turnout.
We should be doing all we can to get people to vote and invest in our beleaguered political system. Rather than wasting time chasing shadows and phantoms or indulging the delusions of a sore-loser president.
NASHVILLE — A massive winter storm made for a brutal travel day Sunday, with widespread cancellations and delays at some of the nation’s busiest airports.
What You Need To Know
Widespread snow, sleet and freezing rain threatened nearly 180 million people — more than half the U.S. population — in a path stretching from the southern Rocky Mountains to New England, the National Weather Service said Saturday night
After sweeping through the South, the storm moved into the Northeast Sunday, and was expected to dump about 1 to 2 feet of snow from Washington through New York and Boston
Aviation analytics firm Cirium said that as of Sunday morning, the storm is the highest experienced cancellation event since the pandemic
New York’s John F. Kennedy International Airport had 466 flights canceled, about 80% of flights, according to FlightAware
Widespread snow, sleet and freezing rain threatened nearly 180 million people — more than half the U.S. population — in a path stretching from the southern Rocky Mountains to New England, the National Weather Service said Saturday night. After sweeping through the South, the storm moved into the Northeast Sunday, and was expected to dump about 1 to 2 feet of snow from Washington through New York and Boston.
More than 11,400 flights were canceled on Sunday, according to flight-tracking site FlightAware. Aviation analytics firm Cirium said that as of Sunday morning, the storm is the highest experienced cancellation event since the pandemic.
By Sunday afternoon, the majority of flights were canceled at busy airports in the Northeast and elsewhere. LaGuardia Airport in New York closed Sunday afternoon, according to the Federal Aviation Administration. The agency said on its website the busy Queens airport grounded flights until 8 p.m.
In Philadelphia, 94% of flights, 326 flights, were canceled. Ninety-one percent of flights, 436 flights, were canceled at LaGuardia Airport in New York. New York’s John F. Kennedy International Airport had 466 flights canceled, about 80% of flights, according to FlightAware.
Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport said on its website that all airlines had canceled departing flights for the day, about 421 flights.
Significant disruptions also hit major airport hubs in Dallas-Fort Worth, Charlotte, Philadelphia and Atlanta, home to the nation’s busiest airport.
Allan Lengel of Detroit planned to return Monday from Fort Lauderdale, Florida, where the temperature has been in the 80s. But he’s staying until Wednesday after Delta suggested he change his reservation because of the weather impact on flights.
“Can’t say I’m disappointed. Frankly, I had been thinking of returning later because of frigid weather,” Lengel, 71, said, referring to conditions in Michigan.
American Airlines had canceled over 1,790 flights for Sunday, about 55% of its scheduled flights for Sunday, according to FlightAware. Delta Air Lines reported over 1,470 cancellations and Southwest Airlines reported over 1,340 cancellations for the day, while United Airlines had about 1,016. JetBlue had more than 590 canceled flights, accounting for roughly 72% of its schedule for the day.
Vikrant Vaze, a Dartmouth professor specializing in commercial aviation logistics, said recovery from the storm cancellations and delays will take days if not longer. And even for travelers who aren’t in areas that were directly affected by weather, cascading delays could still affect their travel plans.
“Because there are so many different airlines involved, I think it’s going to come down heavily to the individual airline’s network structure, the extent of hit that each of them has had, and just the intrinsic capacity of the airlines to handle these massive disruptions,” he said.
My flight was canceled, now what?
If you’re already at the airport, get in line to speak to a customer service representative. If you’re still at home or at your hotel, call or go online to connect to your airline’s reservations staff. Either way, it helps to also research alternate flights while you wait to talk to an agent.
Most airlines will rebook you on a later flight for no additional charge, but it depends on the availability of open seats.
Can I get booked on another airline?
You can, but airlines aren’t required to put you on another carrier’s flight. Some airlines, including most of the biggest carriers, say they can put you on a partner airline, but even then, it can be a hit or miss.
Am I owed a refund?
If your flight was canceled and you no longer want to take the trip, or you’ve found another way to get to your destination, the airline is legally required to refund your money — even if you bought a non-refundable ticket. It doesn’t matter why the flight was canceled.
The airline might offer you a travel credit, but you are entitled to a full refund. You are also entitled to a refund of any bag fees, seat upgrades or other extras that you didn’t get to use.
But, in the end, the Eagles decided to carry on even without ailing guitarist-vocalist Joe Walsh and play their sold-out show at the Sphere in Las Vegas on Saturday night (Jan. 24).
The result was unlike any other show the massively popular Los Angeles band has performed during its lengthy Sphere residence, except, really, in one way:
It was still an absolute delight to behold.
Vince Gill, the country star who joined the band after original member Glenn Frey died in 2016, shouldered most of the load caused by Walsh’s absence. He sang the tunes that usually go to Walsh and played many of his regular guitar leads — with the other portion of those hot licks being handled, quite admirably, by ace touring member Chris Holt.
Walsh was out of the fold on this night, band leader Don Henley explained to the crowd, due to his coming down with the flu. Walsh had still managed to soldier through the previous night’s Sphere gig, but his doctor reportedly advised him not to take the stage on Saturday.
He was missed — especially vocally — since Gill’s angelic voice does not, in any way shape or form, resemble Walsh’s charmingly out-of-pitch squawk-talk style. And there were times during the guitar parts that it felt like Walsh might have pushed things a little further — or, at least, a little different — than his studio-session-ready counterparts.
Eagles perform at the Sphere in Las Vegas on Jan. 24, 2026 (Jim Harrington, Bay Area News Group).
But Walsh will hopefully be feeling better soon and be back in the mix during this blockbuster Eagles residency, which continues at the Sphere through March 28. (For exact dates and other ticket information, visit eagles.com.)
The continued success of this residency — which is the longest in Sphere history — is further proof of the undying love for the Eagles, which got their start as the backing band for Linda Ronstadt in 1971.
Want even more proof? Well, consider that the Eagles’ “Their Greatest Hits 1971–1975” recently garnered quadruple platinum certification in the U.S. Never heard of the term “quadruple platinum certification” before? Well, that’s because it had never ever happened before — the Eagles are the first act to hit that mark, which translates to 40x platinum (aka, 40 millions album units sold).
The group would underscore so many of the reasons for its vast popularity during Saturday’s approximately 2-hour show. The classic rock outfit performed all 10 of the songs featured on that quadruple diamond offering — which ranks as the best-selling album of all time in the U.S. — as well as others tunes from elsewhere in the band catalog as well as a few solo Henley and Walsh cuts.
Eagles perform at the Sphere in Las Vegas on Jan. 24, 2026 (Jim Harrington, Bay Area News Group).
It’s amazing how good the group — consisting of Henley, Gill, bassist Timothy B. Schmit and vocalist-guitarist Deacon Frey (son of Glenn Frey) as well as touring members Holt, Scott F. Crago on drums and Will Hollis and Michael Thompson on various keys — sounded without such an important piece of the musical puzzle.
Yet, Henley explained that the band had called an emergency two-hour practice earlier in the day, once it was clear that Walsh wasn’t going to make it to the show, and it definitely did the trick. The whole thing went really smoothly and, if you didn’t know any better, it would have been hard to even tell that the group was missing anyone at all.
Of course, the whole shebang was greatly enhanced by the venue itself, which delivered its mind-blowing mix of colorful, moving visuals across and around its unbelievable vivid and clear 16K resolution wraparound LED screen that dominates the interior of this 366-foot-fall building.
The video segments and special effects always played to the lyrics, strengthening storylines with images that moved between fantastical and rooted in reality. As far as the latter goes, the group continually took us to its hometown of L.A. — as well as the broader Southern California region — which makes sense given the pronounced role that the City of Angels has played in the group’s music.
Highlights included those famed band harmonies on “Seven Bridges Road,” delivered ever so sweetly as huge video images of the players floated well above the stage; Deacon Frey’s solid vocal work on “Peaceful Easy Feeling,” which came to a close with a big shot of papa Glenn Frey on the screen; Gill’s blistering lead work on the Walsh solo cut “In the City”; and Henley warmly dedicating “The Boys of Summer” to the dearly departed Bobby Weir.
It was a great show from start to finish. And the shows will likely get even better once Walsh returns to the stage. Fans who haven’t attended this residency yet — or those who simply want another helping of the fun — should definitely consider making a date with the Eagles at the Sphere soon.
Eagles perform at the Sphere in Las Vegas on Jan. 24, 2026 (Jim Harrington, Bay Area News Group).
NEW YORK — With a winter storm blanketing a large swath of the country, Hollywood had its quietest weekend of the year at the box office. The Amazon MGM sci-fi thriller “Mercy” dethroned “Avatar: Fire and Ash” from the No. 1 spot with $11.2 million in North America, according to studio estimates Sunday.
What You Need To Know
Some 250 theaters were forced to close, from Texas to Maine, according to data firm Comsore. More than 140 million Americans were under winter storm warnings, depressing moviegoing
“Mercy,” a $60 million thriller starring Chris Pratt as a man in a near-future standing trial before an AI judge, was the top new release
“Fire and Ash” has now cleared $1 billion internationally, but its domestic haul ($378.5 million) is well off the pace of the other two films
The lead movies in Thursday’s nominations — “Sinners” and “One Battle After Another” — long ago completed their theatrical runs, but a handful of nominees saw strong business
Some 250 theaters were forced to close, from Texas to Maine, according to data firm Comsore. More than 140 million Americans were under winter storm warnings, depressing moviegoing.
But the weekend was never going to be a blockbuster one, anyway. “Mercy,” a $60 million thriller starring Chris Pratt as a man in a near-future standing trial before an AI judge, was the top new release. It arrived with withering reviews (20% fresh on Rotten Tomatoes) and an equally poor reception (a “B-” CinemaScore) from audiences.
That was still enough to finally dislodge James Cameron’s third Pandora epic from its monthlong perch atop the box office. “Avatar: Fire and Ash” slid to second place with $7 million. While The Walt Disney Co. release is starting to peter out domestically, it remains a top draw overseas. It took in $28.1 million internationally in its sixth weekend.
“Avatar: Fire and Ash” isn’t going to come close to the box-office heights of the previous two “Avatar” movies. The 2009 original grossed $2.9 billion and the 2022 sequel, “The Way of Water,” tapped out at $2.3 billion. “Fire and Ash” has now cleared $1 billion internationally, but its domestic haul ($378.5 million) is well off the pace of the other two films.
The “Oscar bump” that films once saw following nomination is largely a thing of the past. The lead movies in Thursday’s nominations — “Sinners” and “One Battle After Another” — long ago completed their theatrical runs. But a handful of nominees saw strong business.
Chloé Zhao’s “Hamnet,” nominated for eight Oscars including best picture, collected $2 million in its first weekend of wide release. The Shakespeare drama, starring Jessie Buckley and Paul Mescal, has been in theaters for two months, steadily increasing its theatrical footprint. It’s up to $17.6 million domestically and $42.1 million worldwide.
Josh Safdie’s “Marty Supreme,” nominated for nine Oscars, earned $3.5 million in its sixth weekend of release. The A24 title, starring Timothée Chalamet, this week cross $100 million globally. It’s made $86.2 million domestically thus far.
But newer releases struggled. “Return to Silent Hill,” the third installment in a horror series kick-started with 2006’s “Silent Hill,” opened with $3.2 million. Though Sony released the 2006 film and Open Road distributed the 2012 follow up, the low-budget “Return to Silent Hill” was put out by Iconic Events.
In its second week of release, “28 Years Later: The Bone Temple” dropped swiftly. The Sony release, directed by Nia DaCosta, opened last week to a disappointing $13.3 million in sales despite good reviews. But its second weekend was even worse, dropping 71% with $3.6 million.
Other new releases flopped. Roadside Attractions’ “H Is For Hawk,” starring Claire Foy, took in just $150,000 from 472 theaters. Sony’s “Clika,” about a migrant worker with music aspirations, managed only $1.2 million in 522 locations.
Top 10 movies by domestic box office
With final domestic figures being released Monday, this list factors in the estimated ticket sales for Friday through Sunday at U.S. and Canadian theaters, according to Comscore:
1. “Mercy,” $11.2 million.
2. “Avatar: Fire and Ash,” $7 million.
3. “Zootopia 2,” $5.7 million.
4. “The Housemaid,” $4.2 million.
5. “28 Years Later: The Bone Temple,” $3.6 million.
A public memorial service to honor the late Congressman Doug LaMalfa is being held at the Silver Dollar Fairgrounds in Chico on Saturday.Watch the video leading this story for a livestream of the service beginning at noon.House Speaker Mike Johnson and a delegation of members of Congress are among the attendees honoring their Republican colleague. The gathering is also bipartisan with Gov. Gavin Newsom and U.S. Sen. Adam Schiff in attendance.LaMalfa died on Jan. 5 while in surgery at Enloe Hospital following a medical emergency at his home.Memorial Service Updates The memorial began with a color presentation by the Unified Northstate Honor Guard and the singing of the National Anthem by Alexandria Jones.Mark Lavy, a second cousin of LaMalfa, was the first speaker at the service. He recalled LaMalfa’s life story, including how he met his wife Jill, the moment he knew he would be a Republican and key moments in his political career.Other speakers at the memorial include: Speaker Johnson; Ray Sehorn, LaMalfa’s sixth grade teacher; former House Speaker Kevin McCarthy; LaMalfa’s congressional chief of staff Mark Spannagel; Paradise Mayor Mark Spannagel; David Reade, LaMalfa’s former chief of staff in the Assembly; and Assemblymember James Gallagher.LaMalfa’s wife and his children were also set to deliver a family tribute.LaMalfa represented California’s District 1 in Washington for more than a decade and was the chairman of the Congressional Western Caucus. The district includes a large portion of California’s northernmost area, including Oroville, Yuba City, Chico, Redding and the California-Oregon state boundary.As a fourth-generation rice farmer, LaMalfa heavily advocated for his agricultural constituents. The congressman also worked to provide wildfire victims and survivors in his district with relief and recovery efforts and to bolster the state’s water resources.Before being elected to the U.S. House in 2012, LaMalfa served in the California State Assembly and State Senate. Earlier this month, a bill previously championed by LaMalfa advanced in the California Assembly. AB 1091 would allow Californians to purchase eight-character license plates.LaMalfa is survived by Jill, his four children, one grandchild, two sisters and a host of cousins.See more coverage of top California stories here | Download our app | Subscribe to our morning newsletter | Find us on YouTube here and subscribe to our channel
CHICO, Calif. —
A public memorial service to honor the late Congressman Doug LaMalfa is being held at the Silver Dollar Fairgrounds in Chico on Saturday.
Watch the video leading this story for a livestream of the service beginning at noon.
House Speaker Mike Johnson and a delegation of members of Congress are among the attendees honoring their Republican colleague. The gathering is also bipartisan with Gov. Gavin Newsom and U.S. Sen. Adam Schiff in attendance.
This content is imported from Twitter.
You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site.
Rep. Doug LaMalfa’s memorial service is a rare, bipartisan moment in the state.
Gov. Gavin Newsom, U.S. Senator Adam Schiff are among the first lawmakers to walk in.
They’re followed by several Republican state lawmakers and members of Congress. pic.twitter.com/jCdSf8gGJV
LaMalfa died on Jan. 5 while in surgery at Enloe Hospital following a medical emergency at his home.
Memorial Service Updates
The memorial began with a color presentation by the Unified Northstate Honor Guard and the singing of the National Anthem by Alexandria Jones.
Mark Lavy, a second cousin of LaMalfa, was the first speaker at the service. He recalled LaMalfa’s life story, including how he met his wife Jill, the moment he knew he would be a Republican and key moments in his political career.
Other speakers at the memorial include: Speaker Johnson; Ray Sehorn, LaMalfa’s sixth grade teacher; former House Speaker Kevin McCarthy; LaMalfa’s congressional chief of staff Mark Spannagel; Paradise Mayor Mark Spannagel; David Reade, LaMalfa’s former chief of staff in the Assembly; and Assemblymember James Gallagher.
LaMalfa’s wife and his children were also set to deliver a family tribute.
LaMalfa represented California’s District 1 in Washington for more than a decade and was the chairman of the Congressional Western Caucus. The district includes a large portion of California’s northernmost area, including Oroville, Yuba City, Chico, Redding and the California-Oregon state boundary.
As a fourth-generation rice farmer, LaMalfa heavily advocated for his agricultural constituents. The congressman also worked to provide wildfire victims and survivors in his district with relief and recovery efforts and to bolster the state’s water resources.
Before being elected to the U.S. House in 2012, LaMalfa served in the California State Assembly and State Senate.
Earlier this month, a bill previously championed by LaMalfa advanced in the California Assembly. AB 1091 would allow Californians to purchase eight-character license plates.
LaMalfa is survived by Jill, his four children, one grandchild, two sisters and a host of cousins.
After making historic inroads with Hispanic voters in the last several election cycles, the Republican Party is going all in on winning the Latino vote this midterm election. The party, which currently holds a razor-thin majority in the House of Representatives, is confident that Hispanic voters will help it retain and shape the future of its majority both this November and in the years to come.
Longtime South Texas Democratic Judge Tano Tijerina told Fox News Digital during an interview that he and Hispanics are ready to buck the Democrats and embrace a “new generation” of political leadership.
Alongside former assistant U.S. attorney Eric Flores and former California mayor Kevin Lincoln, Tijerina is one of three Hispanic Republicans running to unseat Democrats in Congress who have been endorsed by President Donald Trump. There are eight other Hispanic Republicans running in competitive, heavily Latino districts in border states, Texas, New Mexico and California.
If elected, these candidates will join an already influential group of Hispanics in Congress, including Reps. Maria Salazar, R-Fla., Monica De La Cruz, R-Texas, Nicole Malliotakis, R-N.Y., Juan Ciscomani, R-Ariz., and Gabe Evans, R-Colo.
From left to right: Judge Tano Tijerina, Eric Flores and Kevin Lincoln.(Courtesy of National Republican Congressional Committee)
Tijerina is running to unseat longtime Democratic Rep. Henry Cuellar in a district along the Texas-Mexico border. He said that despite long being a Democratic stronghold, the Biden administration’s mismanagement of the border and prioritization of DEI “really opened up a lot of eyes of the Hispanics down here in South Texas.”
“Being a Democrat after so many years, I’m just sick and tired of seeing all the social issues that the Democrats are [promoting]. And I’m not the only one. That’s why Webb County, that’s why South Texas, voted for Trump plus 10 numbers.”
“We have always been conservative, everybody knows it,” he went on, adding, “Down here in South Texas, the only thing that we care about is good-paying jobs [and] making sure that we’re getting protected.”
Cuellar also counts himself as one of the last “blue dog” conservative Democrats in the House of Representatives. He was highly critical of the Biden administration’s handling of the border and immigration issues. Cuellar has said that it was this stance that led to him being indicted by the Biden Department of Justice on foreign bribery charges. He was later given an unconditional pardon by Trump, who also posited that the charges were politically motivated.
Though there was much speculation that Cuellar would switch parties after his pardon, he rebuffed those rumors, saying he would remain a blue dog Democrat. Tijerina said that it is just as well because the people of South Texas “deserve somebody that’s actually going to go fight for them and not fight for themselves.”
“[Cuellar] comes around and says, ‘I’m your money guy, I’m the one that brings the money.’ When in all reality, I, as a county judge, know that we’ve gone through commissioner’s court, we’re the ones with the ideas, we’re are the ones that ask for the federal funding, we’re the ones who do the cash match,” said Tijerina.
“Henry’s been for Henry all these years, and it’s very obvious,” he went on. “It’s time for a new generation.”
Rep. Henry Cuellar, D-Texas, was accused of taking more than half a million dollars in bribes from an Azerbaijan-owned energy company and a Mexican bank. He was pardoned by President Donald Trump on the grounds that he was being targeted for political reasons.(Tom Williams/CQ-Roll Call, Inc via Getty Images)
In response, Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee Spokesperson Madison Andrus told Fox News Digital that “during his time in office, Congressman Cuellar has brought billions of dollars back home to South Texas through his powerful position on the House Appropriations Committee.”
Andrus knocked Tijerina for “fighting for a controversial $10 million spending project in Webb County” to purchase property for a new tax office.
“Tano should focus on his own backyard and do his homework on how members bring money back to their districts,” she said.
A national Democratic strategist told Fox News Digital that Tijerina’s assertion that Cuellar has failed to bring money back to the district stems from a “misunderstanding” of how the House appropriations process works.
“Just based on how the House works, Tano will not be able to bring as much money to the district as Cuellar is,” said the strategist, adding, “It is exceedingly rare that a freshman member of Congress gets a seat on the Appropriations Committee. So, Tano would not be able to sit on it, that just wouldn’t happen. And so, that would necessarily lead to a significant decrease in the federal funding that Texas 28 would get.”
Webb County Judge Tano Tijerina poses for a portrait in his office on February 20, 2025, in Laredo, Texas.(Matt McClain/The Washington Post via Getty Images)
Tijerina, however, is not the only candidate forecasting that the Democrats’ hold on the Hispanic vote is nearing its end.
“For too long, Democrats took South Texas for granted, assuming our votes were virtually guaranteed, while they turned their backs on our values,” said Flores, an Army veteran running as a Republican in the Texas Rio Grande Valley.
Flores asserted that Democrats have “traded the needs of hardworking families for a radical agenda that has left our borders open and our economy in shambles.”
Lest one think this phenomenon is isolated to the Texas border, this sentiment was further echoed by Lincoln, a Marine veteran who is also running in California.
Lincoln told Fox News Digital that Hispanic families in the California Central Valley are “feeling the crushing pressures of the affordability crisis driven by Democrats from Sacramento to Washington who put political ideology ahead of kitchen table issues.”
“Generations of families like mine came to America in pursuit of the American Dream, and the Republican Party is earning their trust by working to restore the affordability and opportunity that allows working families to get ahead again,” said Lincoln.
A woman holds a sign expressing Latino support for Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump at his campaign rally at the Orange County Fair and Event Center, April 28, 2016, in Costa Mesa, California.(DAVID MCNEW/AFP via Getty Images)
Despite this, the Democratic Party is also leaning into the affordability message and remains confident that Hispanic voters will stand by them.
“While Republicans are pushing policies that make everyday life unaffordable, Democrats are focused on lowering costs, creating good-paying jobs, and protecting health care for every American,” DCCC spokesperson Bridget Gonzalez told Fox News Digital.
“Latino voters see through the GOP’s empty, hypocritical rhetoric because they’re living with the consequences of Republican extremism every day,” said Gonzalez, adding, “Republicans can trot out all the talking points they want, but Latino families know who’s actually fighting for them — it’s the Democrats.”
Meanwhile, National Republican Congressional Committee spokesman Christian Martinez told Fox News Digital that “outstanding” candidates like Flores, Lincoln and Tijerina “reflect their communities, understand the challenges working families face, and are stepping up to help grow a House majority focused on opportunity, security, and the American Dream.”
“Republicans aren’t just talking about earning Hispanic voters’ trust, we’re continuing to work and build it,” said Martinez.
Peter Pinedo is a politics writer for Fox News Digital.
A man fatally shot by a federal officer in Minnesota worked as an ICU nurse, his parents say
By The Associated Press undefined
A federal officer fatally shot a 37-year-old man in Minneapolis amid the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown, according to a hospital record obtained by The Associated Press. Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, a Democrat, said in a social media post that he had been in contact with the White House after the shooting. He called on President Donald Trump to end the crackdown in his state. The Minnesota National Guard, which had been activated earlier by Walz, was assisting local police amid growing protests.
A federal immigration officer fatally shot a man in Minneapolis on Saturday, drawing hundreds of protesters onto the frigidly cold streets in a city already shaken by another fatal shooting weeks earlier.
Minneapolis Police Chief Brian O’Hara said a 37-year-old man was killed but declined to identify him. He added that information about what led up to the shooting was limited. The man was identified by his parents as Alex Jeffrey Pretti, an intensive care unit nurse. The officer who shot Pretti is an eight-year Border Patrol veteran, federal officials said.
The Minnesota National Guard has been activated by Gov. Tim Walz and is assisting local police amid growing protests. Guard troops are going to both to the shooting site and to a federal building where officials have squared off with protesters daily.
There have been daily protests in the Twin Cities since the Jan. 7 shooting of 37-year-old Renee Good by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer who fired into her vehicle. Pretti was killed just over a mile away from where Good was shot.
The Latest:
Family: ‘heartbroken but also very angry’
Pretti’s family released a statement Saturday evening saying they are “heartbroken but also very angry” and calling him a kindhearted soul who wanted to make a difference in the world through his work as a nurse.
“The sickening lies told about our son by the administration are reprehensible and disgusting. Alex is clearly not holding a gun when attacked by Trump’s murdering and cowardly ICE thugs. He has his phone in his right hand and his empty left hand is raised above his head while trying to protect the woman ICE just pushed down all while being pepper sprayed,” the statement said.
“Please get the truth out about our son. He was a good man. Thank you.”
Gun rights group ‘deeply concerned’ about shooting
While noting that “many critical facts remain unknown,” the Minnesota Gun Owners Caucus said in a statement that “there has been no evidence produced indicating an intent to harm the officers” and called for an investigation by both state and federal authorities.
“Every peaceable Minnesotan has the right to keep and bear arms — including while attending protests, acting as observers, or exercising their First Amendment rights,” the group said. “These rights do not disappear when someone is lawfully armed.”
Federal officials have said Pretti was armed and officers fired defensively after he approached them during an operation and resisted attempts to disarm him. However bystander videos do not appear to show Pretti holding a weapon.
The Minneapolis police chief said Pretti had a permit to carry a gun.
Another evening rally at a park near the scene of Saturday’s shooting
People chanted “say his name” in memory of Alex Pretti, who was fatally shot earlier in the day by a federal agent.
One speaker called for sit-ins at congressional offices to urge a halt to funding for Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Another participant said he believes the tide of public opinion is turning in the protesters’ favor.
Some carried lit candles, and all were bundled up against the frigid nighttime cold.
After about an hour they went to the scene of the shooting. There were chants of “Resisting ICE is not a crime” and “Observing ICE is not a crime.”
There were also chants honoring Renee Good, another person who was fatally shot by a federal agent in Minneapolis this month.
Republican chair of House Homeland Security Committee requests ICE, CBP, USCIS appear before Congress
Rep. Andrew Garbarino, a New York Republican who chairs the committee that oversees the Department of Homeland Security, sent a letter to the department requesting three top officials appear for questioning before the committee.
“As chairman of the House Committee on Homeland Security, my top priority remains keeping Americans safe and ensuring the Department of Homeland Security can accomplish its core mission,” Garbarino said in a statement. “Congress has an important responsibility to ensure the safety of law enforcement and the people they serve and protect.”
Garbarino requested that Immigration and Customs Enforcement senior official Todd Lyons, Customs and Border Protection Commissioner Rodney Scott and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services Director Joseph Edlow appear.
The public hearing would take place sometime in the next two months. Garbarino previously requested that senior DHS officials appear before the committee in a Jan. 15 letter.
Schumer: Democrats will block spending bill if it includes Homeland Security funding
Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer said Senate Democrats will not vote for a spending package that includes money for the Department of Homeland Security.
Schumer’s statement increases the possibility that the government could partially shut down Jan. 30 when funding runs out. Several Democrats said Saturday that they will not vote for the bipartisan package of bills, which will need some Democratic votes to pass.
Democrats say the legislation, which includes money for a broad swath of government agencies, does not include enough restrictions on ICE.
Schumer said what is happening in Minnesota is “appalling.”
“Democrats sought common sense reforms in the Department of Homeland Security spending bill, but because of Republicans’ refusal to stand up to President Trump, the DHS bill is woefully inadequate to rein in the abuses of ICE,” Schumer said. “I will vote no.”
Justice Department official says Minnesota leaders ‘created this escalation’
Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche called the shooting an “avoidable tragedy” that is the “result of the total failure of Minnesota’s city and state officials who have resisted federal law enforcement and created this escalation.”
Blanche said in a statement that the Justice Department will “continue to hold those breaking federal law accountable, including those who harass and violently attack law enforcement in the name of protest.”
The Department of Homeland Security is leading the investigation into the shooting with assistance from the FBI. The DOJ has not yet indicated whether it would open a civil rights investigation but declined to do so after the earlier shooting, of Renee Good.
That was a sharp departure from past administrations, which have moved quickly to probe shootings of civilians by law enforcement officials for potential civil rights offenses.
Dozens of people pay their respects to protester killed by federal agent
They lit candles, placed flowers and stood in silence at the vigil Saturday evening. As dark fell, hundreds of people gathered somberly and quietly by the growing memorial at the shooting scene.
Caleb Spike came from a nearby suburb to show his support and his frustration. “It feels like every day something crazier happens,” he said. “What’s happening in our community is wrong, it’s sickening, it’s disgusting.”
A nearby doughnut shop and clothing store stayed open to offer a place for people to warm up, as well as water, coffee and snacks.
Democratic senators come out against funding DHS, raising risk of another shutdown
Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto said Saturday that she too would not vote for legislation in the Senate that would fund the Department of Homeland Security.
In doing so, Cortez Masto joined fellow Nevada Democratic Sen. Jacky Rosen. The two moderates broke with their party last year on a vote over the last government shutdown.
Others like Democratic Sen. Brian Schatz of Hawaii have said in the wake of the shooting that they would oppose a DHS funding bill that is part of a spending package in the Senate that aims to avoid a partial government shutdown at the end of the month.
Minnesota-born Defense Secretary Hegseth says ICE is greater than Minnesota
Pete Hegseth posted on the social platform X to thank God for the “patriots” who work for ICE and said, “we have your back 100%.”
The Pentagon chief added: “Shame on the leadership of Minnesota — and the lunatics in the street. ICE MN.”
Hegseth was born and raised in Minnesota.
Nevada Sen. Rosen says she will vote against any government funding package that funds ICE
Sen. Jacky Rosen, a moderate Democrat from a political swing state, made the announcement Saturday after the fatal shooting in Minneapolis. Rosen was one of eight Democratic senators last year to break ranks with her party and vote with Republicans to move to reopen the government.
“The abuses of power we are seeing from ICE in Minneapolis and across the country are un-American and cannot be normalized,” Rosen said via the social platform X.
“Enough is enough. We need to rein in ICE’s out of control conduct,” Rosen said.
A bill that funds the Department of Homeland Security is part of a package of spending bills that is moving through the Senate to avoid a partial government shutdown at the end of the month.
Top Democrat on House Homeland Security Committee calls for Noem impeachment
Congressman Bennie Thompson, the top Democrat on the U.S. House Homeland Security Committee, called for Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem to be impeached and denounced statements from the administration about the man DHS agents killed.
“Apparently, the Trump administration and its secret police only support the First and Second Amendments when it’s convenient to them,” Thompson said in a statement.
Thompson called on Democrats in the U.S. Senate to vote against a funding bill for DHS that passed the lower chamber last week. “This is un-American and has to stop,” Thompson said. “The House must immediately take steps to impeach Kristi Noem.”
Walz excoriates immigration operations in Minnesota
Walz issued a statement Saturday calling immigration enforcement “organized brutality.”
“The federal occupation of Minnesota long ago stopped being a matter of immigration enforcement. It is a campaign of organized brutality against the people of our state. And today, that campaign claimed yet another life,” Walz said.
He said the state, and not the federal government, will lead the investigation into the death of 37-year-old Alex Pretti.
Pretti was shot and killed by federal officers amid an immigration operation.
“Minnesotans and our local law enforcement have done everything we can to deescalate. The federal government must deescalate. I once again call on the President to remove the 3,000 agents from Minnesota who are sowing chaos and violence.”
Congressional Democrats responded with immediate outrage to the killing of another person by federal agents in Minneapolis.
Congressman Robert Garcia, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee, called for ICE to be “abolished” and for Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem to be impeached.
“Trump has created a militarized police force accountable only to him and ready to murder people in our streets. These agents need to leave our cities NOW,” the California Democrat wrote on social media.
Congressman Brad Schneider, chair of the moderate New Democratic Coalition in the U.S. House, called for an investigation into the shooting and for federal agents to leave Minnesota.
“Every agent involved in this shooting must be suspended pending a full and independent investigation and ultimately held to account for their actions today,” Schneider said in a statement. “And, Kristi Noem has got to go. She needs to resign or be fired. If not, Congress must act,” the Illinois Democrat continued.
Man identified who was shot and killed amid Minneapolis immigration operation
The man who was shot and killed by a federal officer during an immigration operation has been identified as 37-year-old Alex Pretti. His parents told The Associated Press that Pretti was an intensive care unit nurse.
Vance criticizes local authorities for refusing to cooperate with ICE agents
Vice President JD Vance responded to the shooting in a post on X and said that when he visited Minneapolis this week, “what the ICE agents wanted more than anything was to work with local law enforcement so that situations on the ground didn’t get out of hand.”
He accused local officials in Minnesota of ignoring requests from ICE agents to work with them.
Notably, federal officials refused to cooperate with local officials on an investigation into the shooting death of Renee Good on Jan. 7.
Store owner opens to help protesters amid freezing temperatures
Allison Bross opened her fashion store, b. Resale, next to the shooting scene for the protesters to grab food, water, use the restroom, receive medical attention and get a warm break from the frigid temperatures outside.
“We’re a community-based business, we don’t exist without the community,” she said. “So if we hear someone in our neighborhood is getting hurt, I’m going to be here immediately.”
Meanwhile, a makeshift memorial at a bus stop next to the site of the shooting was taking shape. People left flowers and lit candles.
Hennepin County Sheriff’s Office asks for National Guard help
Sheriff Dawanna Witt has requested assistance from the Minnesota National Guard to support deputies at the Whipple Federal Building so that deputies can be assigned to other areas.
The Minnesota National Guard’s role is to work in support of local law enforcement and emergency responders, providing additional resources, the sheriff’s office said.
Their presence is meant to help create a secure environment where all Minnesotans can exercise their rights safely, including the right to peacefully protest.
“We know this moment is challenging for our community. Remember that our local teams are also part of this community. We respect and protect everyone’s rights to voice concerns and stand up for what they believe in, but we urge all actions to remain peaceful and lawful. Our collective priority remains protecting our neighborhoods and keeping people safe,” a statement said.
Trump weighs in on the shooting in Minneapolis
Trump posted to his Truth Social account after a man was killed by federal officers during an immigration enforcement action in Minneapolis. Trump’s statement said:
“This is the gunman’s gun, loaded (with two additional full magazines!), and ready to go — What is that all about? Where are the local Police? Why weren’t they allowed to protect ICE Officers? The Mayor and the Governor called them off? It is stated that many of these Police were not allowed to do their job, that ICE had to protect themselves — Not an easy thing to do! Why does Ilhan Omar have $34 Million Dollars in her account? And where are the Tens of Billions of Dollars that have been stolen from the once Great State of Minnesota? We are there because of massive Monetary Fraud, with Billions of Dollars missing, and Illegal Criminals that were allowed to infiltrate the State through the Democrats’ Open Border Policy. We want the money back, and we want it back, NOW. Those Fraudsters who stole the money are going to jail, where they belong! This is no different than a really big Bank Robbery. Much of what you’re witnessing is a COVER UP for this Theft and Fraud.
“The Mayor and the Governor are inciting Insurrection, with their pompous, dangerous, and arrogant rhetoric! Instead, these sanctimonious political fools should be looking for the Billions of Dollars that has been stolen from the people of Minnesota, and the United States of America. LET OUR ICE PATRIOTS DO THEIR JOB! 12,000 Illegal Alien Criminals, many of them violent, have been arrested and taken out of Minnesota. If they were still there, you would see something far worse than you are witnessing today!”
DHS says officers fired ‘defensive shots’
Department of Homeland Security spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement that federal officers were conducting an operation as part of the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown.
She said officers fired “defensive shots” after a man with a handgun approached them and “violently resisted” when officers tried to disarm him. O’Hara said police believe the man was a “lawful gun owner with a permit to carry.”
Police chief says man shot and killed was a ‘lawful gun owner’
O’Hara said the man’s only previous interaction with law enforcement as far as he knew was for traffic tickets.
“And we believe he is a lawful gun owner with a permit to carry,” he said.
Police chief asks public, law enforcement to remain calm
Minneapolis Police Chief Brian O’Hara appealed for calm, both from the public and from federal law enforcement, following the shooting of a man.
“Our demand today is for those federal agencies that are operating in our city to do so with the same discipline, humanity and integrity that effective law enforcement in this country demands,” the chief said.
“We urge everyone to remain peaceful. We recognize that there is a lot of anger and a lot of questions around what has happened, but we need people to remain peaceful in the area.”
Police also clarified that the age of the man shot is 37.
Angry crowd gathers after shooting of man in Minneapolis
An angry crowd gathered after the shooting and screamed profanities at federal officers, calling them “cowards” and telling them to go home.
One officer responded mockingly as he walked away, telling them: “Boo hoo.” Agents elsewhere shoved a yelling protester into a car.
The intersection where the shooting has been blocked off, and Border Patrol agents are on the scene wielding batons.
The shooting happened a day after thousands of demonstrators protesting the crackdown on immigrants crowded the city’s streets in frigid weather, calling for federal law enforcement to leave.
Minnesota Sen. Amy Klobuchar expresses outrage at shooting
Minnesota Sen. Amy Klobuchar has expressed outrage at the shooting of a man during an immigration operation.
“Donald Trump and all your lieutenants who ordered this ICE surge: watch the horrific video of the killing today. The world is watching. Thousands of citizens stopped and harassed. Local police no longer able to do their work. Kids hiding. Schools closed. Get ICE out of Minnesota,” Klobuchar said in a message posted on X.
Minnesota Democrats react to the shooting
Minnesota Sen. Tina Smith issued a statement after the shooting of a man during an ICE operation. She said, “We are gathering more information, but ICE must leave now so MPD can secure the scene and do their jobs.”
Rep. Angie Craig said in a statement that she has seen “my own eyes the video of another horrific killing by ICE agents this morning in Minneapolis. This is sickening.
“The agency is beyond out of control. How much more evidence do my Republican colleagues in Minnesota need to speak out?”
Minneapolis police chief calls for calm
Police Chief Brian O’Hara called for protesters who amassed at the scene of a shooting to stay calm and leave the area. “Please do not destroy our own city,” he said at a news conference.
Rep. Omar releases statement after Minnesota shooting
Rep. Ilhan Omar issued a statement after the shooting of a man by federal officers in Minnesota.
“I am absolutely heartbroken, horrified, and appalled that federal agents murdered another member of our community. It is beyond shameful these federal agents are targeting our residents instead of protecting them,” she said in a statement.
“This isn’t isolated or accidental. The Trump administration is trying to beat us into submission rather than protect us. … This administration cannot continue violating constitutional rights under the guise of immigration enforcement.”
The Los Angeles Charter Reform Commission this week adopted new transparency rules requiring commissioners to publicly disclose private communications with elected officials and their staff—a move supporters say is aimed at shoring up public trust as the panel moves toward an early April deadline to reshape the city’s governing charter.
The policy, approved unanimously at the commission’s Wednesday meeting, requires commissioners to disclose ex parte communications, or off-record discussions with elected officials or their staff about matters pending before the commission. The disclosure requirement took effect immediately on Jan. 21.
Under the new rules, commissioners must disclose any such communications at the next commission meeting following the interaction, including the date and time, form, duration, participants and a summary of the charter reform topics discussed. Any off-the-record conversations that occur during a public meeting must be disclosed before adjournment. Commission staff are also directed to maintain a public log of disclosures on the commission’s website.
The vote marks the commission’s first formal step to address growing concerns that behind-the-scenes conversations could influence charter reform recommendations outside public view. But while commissioners agreed on the need to disclose their own communications, they stopped short of extending the same requirement to commission staff, postponing a separate proposal that would have broadened the rule’s reach.
Commissioner Carla Fuentes, who introduced the motions, said the disclosure framework was necessary to protect the integrity of the commission’s work and ensure transparency at a moment when public confidence is critical.
“If the public is going to trust the outcomes of our charter reform process, it has to be transparent and credible,” Fuentes said during the meeting. “To me, this is about creating guard rails that match the magnitude of what we’re doing here by strengthening accountability and ensuring that the public record reflects the conversations that may influence our deliberations.”
She noted that the commission’s action would take effect sooner than a similar ordinance approved by the City Council earlier in the week, which still requires additional procedural steps before implementation.
The City Council ordinance, introduced by Councilmembers Monica Rodriguez and Imelda Padilla and approved on Jan. 20, similarly requires Charter Reform Commission members to disclose ex parte communications with elected officials and their staff. However, it is not expected to take effect for at least several weeks, following a second reading and other required procedural steps. The ordinance also does not extend disclosure requirements to commission staff.
In a follow-up email to this publication Friday, Fuentes said the commission could not afford to wait for the City Council’s ordinance to take effect, citing the panel’s limited lifespan and the April 2 deadline to submit their recommendations to the City Council.
“With each meeting, we’re closer to that deadline and transparency needs to be in place now for the public to have any confidence in the remainder of our work,” she wrote.
While commissioners ultimately approved disclosure rules for themselves, divisions emerged over whether the requirement should also apply to commission staff.
Commission Chair Raymond Meza said he supported commissioner disclosure but raised concerns that extending the rule to staff could sweep in routine or procedural communications.
“It is not uncommon for an elected official’s staff person to call one of our staff and say, ‘Hey, I heard a discussion that’s been taking place in the commission — did this commissioner really mean that,’” Meza said, adding that such exchanges could trigger disclosure even when no policy advocacy was involved.
With only seven of the commission’s 12 members present Wednesday, any dissenting vote would have been enough to block the motion. Meza said he would vote against the staff disclosure provision under those circumstances, prompting Fuentes to agree to separate the two proposals and bring the staff issue back at a future meeting when more commissioners are present.
Transparency advocates welcomed the commission’s action but said gaps remain—particularly around the decision to delay staff disclosure.
Chris Carson, chair of the League of Women Voters of Greater Los Angeles’ Government Reform Committee, speaking in a personal capacity and not on behalf of the League, said Friday that the new rules still leave significant gray areas.
She pointed to the difficulty of distinguishing between “procedural” and substantive conversations, noting that routine check-ins or requests for clarification can easily slide into discussions that influence decision-making.
“It just raises a lot of questions about what you are defining as procedural,” she said. “And when does an inquiry about what is going to happen morph into something else.”
While the new rule requires commissioners to publicly disclose off-the-record communications, enforcement relies largely on self-reporting and internal commission oversight. The policy does not include an independent enforcement mechanism, and violations would not invalidate votes or recommendations already made by the commission. However, commissioners who fail to comply could face censure or a recommendation for removal by their appointing authority.
Still, Carson said disclosure requirements can meaningfully change behavior, even when they rely on voluntary reporting, by making secrecy riskier than transparency.
Drawing on her experience helping draft California’s independent redistricting reforms, she said the state’s citizens redistricting commission adopted a strict ex parte ban — prohibiting private communications altogether — and publicly disclosing any attempted contacts.
“The cleanest and most transparent way to go is to just have a ban on ex parte communication from everybody,” Carson said. “That way, the commissioners know maybe they’re not being gamed. The public knows that the commissioners are not being gamed. And it works.”
Created in 2024 following a series of City Hall scandals, the Charter Reform Commission is tasked with reviewing Los Angeles’ charter, often described as the city’s constitution, and recommending changes to the City Council. If approved by the Council, some proposals could go before voters as early as November.
California becomes first state to join GOARN, a World Health Organization network, Newsom’s office says
The news comes after the Trump administration withdrew the United States from the World Health Organization
Thank you all for for joining us um and I actually want to start you, uh. You or your, you tweeted last or posted last night that this was that this was the tweets, the, the conversation, and yes, thank you for joining us, Governor and thank you so much to the WF for hosting this. This is the conversation that Donald Trump tried to cancel. Don’t miss it 11:30 Pacific. Thank you to our Pacific Time viewers. Um, in fact, this is *** different conversation in the WeF’s defense. It was the privately run USA House which is endorsed by the State Department, funded by. Big American companies which did pull *** pull an event with you with Fortune yesterday and I guess I wondered to begin with, what does that tell you about the way the US private sector, which is really very heavily represented here, so you’re gonna get me in trouble right off the bat moment. uh, I, I looked at the, I admit looking at the list McKinsey and Microsoft and *** few California companies. Uh, so you have you, what the hell are they even talking about, uh, but it’s indicative, I think, of America, uh, for those of you are not American. It gives you *** sense of what we’re up against, um, and what’s happening across my country, uh, and what happened here, um, in, in Davos. I was gonna speak last night. It was well established event at the USA House, *** simple conversation discussion after Trump’s speech. They made sure that I didn’t, uh, they made sure it was canceled, um. And that’s what’s happening in the United States of America. Freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, freedom of speech. Um, it’s America in reverse. Uh, they’re censoring historical facts. They’re rewriting history. Uh, they’re censoring books, 4340 books, libraries, and in schools banned in the United States of America. Uh, you’re watching institutions. Any institution of independent thinking is under assault and attack by the Trump administration. You’re seeing what’s playing out in the streets of American cities, what played out in California, the second largest city in the United States of America. 4000 National Guard were federalized. 700 active duty Marines were not sent overseas. They were sent to my largest city in the state of California, masked men. Guy Greg Bovino dressed up it’s as if he literally went on eBay and purchased SS garb. Greg Bovino, secret police, private army, masked men, people disappearing, quite literally no due process, windows being smashed. Seat belts on being, you know, literally just sort of cut off people dragged in the streets, kids separated from family, knocking on doors, racially profiling American citizens. So is it surprising the Trump administration didn’t like my commentary. And wanted to make sure that I was not allowed to speak. No, it’s consistent with this administration and their authoritarian tendencies. Forgive me, these are objective facts, but I would say this was not just to be clear, this was *** private enterprise endorsed by the State Department, but. These are, these are *** lot of decisions are being made by private companies right now. This is, you know, this is *** capital, this is the probably the central global gathering of CEOs, and I guess I wonder if you can give me *** review of how you see these folks, and you, you know, you know your way around this world, how you see those people behaving. Society becomes how we behave. We are our behaviors, uh, we’re not bystanders in this world. The world we’re experiencing happened on our watch. So in the relationship to your question, yeah, they’re complicit in some respects to this moment, you know, forgive me, you brought up *** tweet, but part of my approach has been *** little more aggressive than perhaps *** lot of American politicians. Uh, I created *** Patriot site. Uh, in, on the site, uh, you can go, there are knee pads that are available to purchase, um. The the last round of knee pads sold out just as our law firms are selling out. Many American universities are selling out, and yes, many corporate leaders are selling out to this administration, selling out our values, selling out our future. Selling out what makes America great. And it breaks my heart and uh and people need to stand up. Uh, people need to uh you know, courage of their damn convictions. Uh we’re the 250th anniversary of the United States of America this year. It’s the 250th anniversary. The best of the Roman Republic, Greek democracy, co-equal branches of government, the rule of law, popular sovereignty. Tell me that that reflects the America you read about today. There’s no rule of law. It’s the rule of Don. I hope it’s. Hope for Europeans, it’s dawning on you. It’s not the rule of law. You don’t have co-equal branches of government. You have *** supine Congress. You don’t have *** Speaker of the House. It doesn’t exist. Popular sovereignty and being challenged every single day by voter suppression, trying to rig elections. I mean, heck, Donald Trump tried to steal the election, the last election, tried to light democracy on fire, and then pardoned everyone that participated in that. Is anyone paying attention to what the hell is going on in the United States of America? So my state of mind is *** little different perhaps than many others. I won’t be complicit at this moment. I won’t. I can’t. I can’t look my kids in the eyes. And so I’m I’m just blessed that I get to represent *** state that’s larger than the size of 21 US states combined. Uh, where 27% of us are foreign born, we practice pluralism. That’s *** word you haven’t heard in America in *** year, uh, where we dominate in every critical category in terms of energy and daring and entrepreneurialism and innovation, uh, and, and, and look, give me *** category. In California outperforms the 4th largest economy in the world, and so we can punch above our weight. We can come here with formal authority and *** little moral authority, and I tell you, we need *** little moral authority. Our body politic in the United States of America today. Governor, you, how do you balance morning everybody. Sorry, I, I figured we would. Yeah, um. You’re ***, you’re, you’re *** tough interview, Governor. The uh the uh. and, and when I think you have chosen *** sort of if you can’t beat them join them strategy to the way you’re talking about this stuff you talk, you know, you, you know, you’re, you’re running around distributing knee pads to CEOs and, and, and, and I think it does them out and it, it does I do have *** few if you’d like, and I don’t know, and honestly it sounds, and you, by the way, I’m not kidding, they’re the new Trump signature series knee pads, um, yeah, and they are available online. I told you the last one sold out, uh, and, uh. And I, I just wanna sort of it’s *** serious moment. It actually, but we laugh, uh, anyway, these are available, uh, and in bulk too, but I wanna, I wanna read you *** couple of things the US government has said about you in, in the last 24 hours or so. The Treasury, the US government, the Treasury Secretary, when you put it, the Treasury Secretary described you as Patrick Bateman meets Sparkle Beach Ken. The White House communications director, hold on, was this, that was the US Secretary of Treasury. I have *** couple more and then, and then you can respond. Um, the White House communications director called you Gavin Newscombe, and *** and an official White House account, uh, um, you know, *** federal government account described you with ***, that’s *** very online sexual slur that people here probably don’t want to hear at 8:30 in the morning. Um, and you’re in some sense responding in kind and waving the knee pads around fire with fire. Do you think, do you should you, I mean, is that, is that kind of discourse from you, from them good for America? Oh, it’s deeply unbecoming. Come on, of course it is. It’s not what we should be doing, but you’ve got to point out the absurdity. You gotta put *** mirror up to this. This is madness. President, you, you see what he’s saying about European leaders, you talking down to people, talking past people. I mean, look at the, the comments he made yesterday we’re not even discussing because you’re discussing all the other comments about windmills or whatever else that was happening. Well, he talked about Somalia’s community. This is not normal. It’s *** deviation of normalcy. We’ve gotta call it out. So I put *** mirror up to Trump and Trumpism in all caps, and it was ironic because Pravda, Fox News in America, uh, others, you know, they got offended by it. They said, Well, where’s his mother to wash his mouth out with soap. I said, Where the hell have you been? You’ve never said *** word about Trump dressing up as the Pope, uh, tweeting out and cosplaying on the world stage, and so look, the Treasury Secretary talked about *** Barbie doll. It was as if he was reading *** diary and had just broken up with someone. I mean that was the Secretary of the Treasury using valuable time yesterday on the world stage. Some sexual, thank you for not sharing that on the official White House account. We’re deeply in their head. I think the affordability agenda appears to be, I’m living rent-free in the Trump’s head, Trump administration’s head. Um, the, um, the, the most talked about speech here in Davos actually isn’t what wasn’t Donald Trump’s address yesterday, it was, it was the Canadian Prime Minister speech. Um, it was Canadian Prime Minister, uh, Mark Carney the day before who talked about, I don’t know, in, in large terms *** bit the middle powers, everybody except for, for, for China and the US, we had to adapt permanently to *** world without. leadership, I, I guess I wonder, I mean, that’s in some sense *** pretty anti-American point of view. That’s, that’s *** view that America is gone from the world stage, that whether the next president is JD Vance, Gavin Newsom, somebody else, this isn’t *** deviation, as you said, this is permanent. Do you buy that? Do you, do you buy Carney’s point of view? I was, you know, I, I felt there were moments, and forgive me, I should be cautious making this statement. I don’t want it to be over analyzed, but when I was listening to the, uh, EU president speak, I, I, I, there were moments where I said that used to be us. I used to, I, I remember that. So am I surprised by what Carney did? Quite the contrary, I thought it was, I, I had more leaders from the United States quietly, I mean, not publicly, I’m not standing up publicly. The transcript of that speech saying wow. They were, I mean, got in Trump said yesterday he had brought it, he brought it up. You know everything about Trump because it’s what’s not in the teleprompter that tells you everything you need to know about where Trump’s head is on things. Um, it was incredibly effective. The markets were more effective markets. It’s not Mother Nature. I thought the most powerful force on Earth with Mother Nature, but it’s the markets, particularly the Trump administration. Combine that with the comments of Macron, combine that with the EU commissioner, but the clarity that came from Prime Minister of Canada. But the fact that he went to China, came back with *** deal, started introducing low cost, high quality electric vehicles not made in Michigan, Detroit. But overseas into Canada, it says everything you know about the recklessness. Of America’s foreign policy. Everything you need to know, you know it intimately, but it’s *** remarkable thing to break down 80+ years of alliances. It takes decades and decades to build trust in organizations, the architecture that it takes weeks, tweets, hours, minutes sometimes to destroy it. Destruction is not strength. The Trump administration is weakness masquerading as strength, and people need to understand that that’s reflected in the tweets, that’s reflected in canceling people, that’s reflected in sending masked men into the American cities. It’s reflected at this moment, so I respect what Carney did because he had courage of convictions. He stood up. And I think we need to stand up in America and call this out with clarity. We can lose our republic as we know it. Our country become unrecognizable in *** matter of months, just not years. It is code red blinking red. In the United States of America, so forgive me, I, I feel this with passion, some indignity that someone frankly has taken it for granted all of these years, and it’s why I came here to Davos to call it out, and I wish there were more of us doing the same because there are more of us. And on that, I just forgive me, I want you to know Donald Trump is an historic president. That’s absolutely correct. He’s historically unpopular. In the United States of America in every category, he’s underwater. He will be remembered in years, not decades. He’s not going to run again. Time of life denies that, not *** state of mind, but time of my life. But we need to manifest that, and we need to do the hard work and that hard work includes the difficult work of coming to Davos and calling that out. This is not where I wanna be spending. I love you all my time. Uh, and, and so, um, anyway, it’s an extension of the conviction I feel about this moment talking about people who, among other things, aren’t American, maybe be concerned for America, but are making decisions about their own politics, their own countries, and what Carney Carney’s core point was this is *** rupture, this isn’t an anomaly, and, and there’s no going back. And do you think that, I mean, do you think there’s *** different an American leader can bring, I think, I, I think these relationships are in dormancy, they’re not dead. I don’t use those binary terms. Don’t, don’t, don’t fall prey to that. That’s *** bit hyperbolic, and I’m prone to *** little of that at times. Uh, dormancy. We can look, he’s an invasive species, Donald Trump. He’s not. He is. Uh, he took over the Republican Party. They’re, they’re just, uh, I mean, uh, he’s got, you know, *** few of them, uh, Lindsey Graham, I mean, my, uh, speaking of the knee pads, uh. I’m sorry, this is tough stuff. It’s tough stuff. I don’t recognize these people any longer. I used to respect Lindsay. I mean, Lindsay, you think what I’m saying about Trump’s tough. How about what Lindsey Graham said about Trump? How about the Secretary of State Marco Rubio? Do you, do you I mean this is, these are the same people. And this is why we, for things to change, we need to change, and that’s why I’m changing my approach. And again I’m grateful you all took that. I mean, I suppose. Do you think post-Trump there’s *** path back because you see this everywhere to kind of unsolve politics that you’re doing here, which you, I see you said you don’t really enjoy it. You kind of seem to. I’m just putting *** mirror up. Just, you gotta. I was doing my 10 point plans before, and I don’t think any of you would have been here this morning had I done that. Oh, they would have been here. No, I, because it just, it wasn’t working. Everyone’s trying to figure this guy out. How do Mark Carney crowd? Yeah, no, but it’s, how do you, how do you, how do you communicate? How do you respond? To This moment. And it’s for me it’s about iteration. It’s an entrepreneurial spirit. It’s *** very California mindset. You gotta keep increasing the number of tries, and I was trying everything, wasn’t working, wasn’t breaking through. Democratic Party writ large, wasn’t breaking through, and we decided the only way to address Trump is quite literally to fight fire with fire. I did an initiative, Prop 50 in California was to reflect the fact that Donald Trump called an American politician and said in the middle of the decade to the governor of the state of Texas, I am entitled. Greg Abbott to 5 seats, and I need you to redraw district lines, mid-year redistricting to rig the 2026 election before 1 vote is cast. What the Trump administration expected we were going to do, as no good Democrats do, we might write an op ed. And we may, you know, all go out and just say this is just so wrong, and all of us would be applauding and say, yes, yes. You know, as he’s consolidating power, instead we went out and we redraw our maps. And we also drew *** line in the sand, and I think that’s what’s required at this moment, and uh he he susses out weakness like no one else. That’s his great strength, that’s his gift. But you punch back. You fight fire with fire, you display conviction and strength, it’s *** different relationship. And so my relationship to this moment is reflected in that. I’m not naive, these guys are gonna try to take me down, not just my state. I’m not naive about what I’ve said this morning and how that will be reflected in the official White House account. I’m not naive about the fact that he threatened to prosecute. The Fed chief in the United States of America that has subpoena against another sitting governor, Tim Waltz. Who’s literally going after his enemies with the FBI and the DOJ and these power ministries. I’m not naive about any of this. I’m not naive about the corruption and the graft at *** scale we’ve never seen in American history. I’m not naive about folks writing billion dollar checks to Witkoff, to Jared Kushner for this new peace deal they’re announcing today. I’m not naive about the fact that the President of the United States made $1.5 billion in the last 12 months personally. How the hell are we putting up with this? We have to call this out unprecedented in American history, happening in real time on our watch. We have to be held to *** higher level, all of us, myself notably, to *** higher level of accountability at this moment. And um You know 11 of what I think one of the main reasons that you know that that he has been successful is, is because the Democratic Party is so discredited in the in the eyes of so many voters. Um, I have *** couple of questions about that. One is big picture about California people, you know, you’re in the midst of ***, you know, enormous economic boom right now, and yet the state is on one hand running deficits and on the other. Not always delivering services that it’s, you know, from education to health care that your citizens are delighted with and and I guess I wonder how can you know how are voters looking at California looking at New York looking at Chicago. You know, supposed to say, yeah, this is the model we want. Well, I’m proud of my state. We have more Fortune 500 companies than any other state in America, more scientists, engineers, more more Nobel laureates in my state than any state in America, the finest system of higher public education in the world. Uh, we have 18% of the world’s R&D, China, 22%, Germany 21%, California, 18% of the world’s R&D. We’re the center of the universe as it relates to AI. 32 of 50, but, but what about the governance? Well, the governance, we’re one of the lowestinsured rates in America. You mentioned healthcare. Uh, we just did our state of education report which showed in every category, every classroom, uh, making progress with our test scores. Our investments are paying off. Just did *** big state of the state. The idea that these blue states have trouble are are spending more for less results, I don’t know, higher life expectancy, lower infant mortality, lower gun death rates, more productivity, higher wages, higher quality of life. $83.1 billion that was the net contribution that we provided to the federal government versus red state like Texas that was *** taker state of $73.1 billion so we’re producing more and people are I think creating more. Opportunities. So look, are there problems? You, for instance, you’re supporting the mayor of LA for re-election after these, these, these terrible fires that *** lot of, you know, *** lot of your citizens do feel was part in part because of government mismanagement. Do you just reject that narrative that the government has anything to do with I absolutely accept that. We all should be held to *** higher level of accountability in terms of our governance, and I think there are many areas of reforms that are necessary, so many areas of reforms that are underway. We can get into the specifics of any one of these issues, but the general notion that in the middle of winter with 100 mile an hour winds or attached to *** fire, that somehow, by the way, There were 16 major fires in Southern California over *** two week period that somehow that had to do with fire hydrants is rather preposterous and it was shape shift because of the complete *** that came from Donald Trump and Elon Musk, saying somehow the sprinklers didn’t work and the fire hydrants didn’t work because we didn’t turn on *** valve in Northern California. These are literal. Words from the Trump administration, uh, so I do reject that. Uh, do I reject this notion of being self-critical about governance and management across the spectrum? No, that’s fair game. And the probably the, the biggest governance issue policy issue fueling right wing parties in the United States around the country is immigration and, and, you know, I think liberal parties again in, in the US and around the world. Had *** posture of welcoming immigrants that it just turned out *** lot of Americans, *** lot of Californians, but more Americans are unhappy with legal illegal immigration, the out of control border, but also. It’s, it’s the last issue on which Trump, though his numbers have been sliding, remained somewhat popular, and I guess I wonder, do you think, do you think that your party went too far or that you went too far? And I think, for instance, you know, in extending, um, medical to the, the California health care program to undocumented immigrants. Like, do you, two different, I guess on the big picture and the small picture, do you feel like you went too far? Two different questions. Uh, do I believe. In universal healthcare, yes, regardless of pre-existing conditions, ability to pay, and your status, I campaigned on that. We delivered on that, and I’m proud of that. We’re one of 16 states to provide care to people regardless of their immigration status. By the way, we have universal care in emergency rooms, and you pay the price on the back end, at least Americans, uh, for that regardless of your immigration status. But the issue of immigration, uh, Donald Trump is very unpopular on immigration. He’s successful on the board. Separate issue connected and yes, the Democratic Party failed in the last few years on the border and yes, I was critical of that and yes, I put our own National Guard on the border the day I got elected into office in 2019, sent 394 National Guard down to the border, and we were very, very pointed with the Biden administration that we were failing to deliver border security for *** number of years on the larger immigration issue. I happen to share the same old office of Ronald Reagan, governor of California, who decided in his last day in office at the White House and he gave *** love letter to immigrants from around the world. It was *** love letter to America, what distinguishes America from the rest of the globe. He talked about lady Torch, Lady Liberty’s torch, and he talked about uh the vibrancy of newcomers, people coming all over the globe for riches and new beginnings, becoming Americans, and what defines our great nation. And that’s the spirit that defines my mindset. Getting first round draft choices around the rest of the world is what makes California so vibrant. It’s because of that diversity and it’s because of people’s willingness to dare and to match up with ideas and perspectives and backgrounds to come in to make *** go of it that has made California the 4th largest GDP in the world, but we have failed on the border. And Donald Trump is failing on immigration. His economic policy is not complicated. It’s tariffs, which is *** regressive tax. It’s mass deportations. Which is having *** major impact on supply chains, and you’ve seen the American jobless rate. You’re seeing it growing, the unemployment rate in America. Besson didn’t talk about this. They had the worst jobs numbers in the first year of the Trump administration outside *** recession since 2003. 49,000 jobs *** month. The Biden administration last year was averaging 168,000 jobs *** month. Inflation is not lowering, it’s still at 2.7%. Ask folks what *** pound of beef costs in the United States of America or *** brand new car. Everything you heard yesterday was BS. And it’s impacted by these policies of tariffs that are impacting ranchers and farmers and small business folks, *** major tax that they celebrate, *** tax that they celebrate collecting, which is ironic from the Republican Party. And the third leg of the stool is *** massive tax cut away from the wealthy and the privileged. Taxing now the burden on small businesses and working folks, that’s the policy easily described of America’s economic strategy, and it’s *** failed strategy, and the impacts of that strategy are being felt all throughout the United States of America, including my state that has been disproportionately impacted, uh, by, uh, these policies. So I’m, I’m very critical of those. I’m critical of our assault on institutions of higher learning research. Institutions, uh, that have literally been, I mean they’re part of that formula for success. The rest of the world gets that, uh, and he’s putting sand in the gears across that spectrum, uh, and, uh, in California again, uh, is, is fighting and pushing back and well, some of those, uh, those first round draft picks got, you know, incredible contracts and are now in, um, made quite *** lot of money and are now. Very freaked out threatening to leave California over *** proposal that just to uh be clear, you oppose to tax to for *** sort of one-time tax on, on, on the wealth of the very, very, very wealthy Californians, and I guess I wanna ask you two questions. One is I was talking to somebody progressive here who said, you know, this guy’s basically *** fake populist. He talks *** good game about the billionaires. Here is an actual proposal that they’re unhappy about, and you’re on the other side. You’re standing with, you know, Elon Musk and David Sachs on this. Why is that, uh. Or one time wealth tax at *** state level that almost exclusively goes to solve one problem, healthcare. And not solving for larger issues like education, supporting. Police officers and firefighters and starves the rest of the general fund. That has had already the impact of people moving out of our state. And impacting then the annual income tax collection is not something I support, um, and by the way, vast majority of labor does not support as well, uh, and, and that’s reflected in my opposition. What’s not reflected in my opposition, quite the contrary, is my advocacy for progressive taxes. That does tax the wealthy disproportionately. Do you have *** theory? I’ve been *** strong advocate for that. Do you have *** theory on how to tax this particular group who often kind of live in this, and I’m sure you know there are people in this room who do this, but who live on debt, you know, who have no income and live on these sort of giant revolving loans. Yeah, I mean that when you, you could have that conversation, I think the wealth tax is sort of an attempt to get at that, yeah, but at *** national level we’re competing with 50 states. Capital flows and move, that’s real. It’s not imagined. It’s very, very real. So we have *** progressive tax structure, the most progressive in the country, by the way, states like Texas and Florida, the most regressive tax structures. They tax their lowest wage earners more than we tax our highest wage earners. They are the high tax states. We have the highest tax rate for the 1%. But for working folks and middle class it’s *** very different tax structure. That’s the approach we promote. That’s the approach that we advance in our state. But again, our state of mind as it relates to the issue of *** state by state wealth tax, the impact of that has to be considered in the context of how freely capital can move and how that’s already occurred. It’s not just an assertion, it’s in evidence already in the state of California as it relates to *** proposal that hasn’t gone on the ballot. *** proposal that has never gotten through the legislature and *** proposal that likely if it did get on the ballot will lose. Would you campaign against it? I’m opposed to it. It’s already had, I think, *** very negative impact on the state and it’s *** badly drafted. Initiative again that literally takes teachers and takes our educational system out of any consideration of support and impacts other parts of our general fund. It is *** flawed initiative and then I think conversely these, these folks who control it *** ton of capital and as you said, some are actually already leaving, have been leaving. How do you, you know, over this, but I think also over *** sense that California, the Democratic leadership broadly. You know, complains about billionaires *** lot. Doesn’t, is, is, is not, does not give them the, uh, you know, love and respect that they feel that they’re entitled to. You know, how do you, what you, I mean, you actually, you, you, you talk to these folks. Some, some of them support you, some don’t. But what, what, what are you saying as you call people up and say, hey, please don’t leave California. What’s your, well, California’s population 3 years in *** row continues to grow, uh, and so does our footprint as it relates to more Fortune 500 companies than we’ve had in over, uh, 2 decades, uh, and. Our innovation ecosystem and startup ecosystem is second to none. We have half of the country’s unicorns in our state, the largest market cap private sector company, uh, OpenAI, just headquartered in San Francisco. They could have chosen any other state in the country. Look, I don’t begrudge other people’s success. I’ve never been that kind of Democrat. But I also recognize in *** world, uh, businesses can’t thrive in *** world that’s failing. 10% of the wealth is concentrated, or rather 2/3 of the wealth in the United States is concentrated in the hands of just 10%, 10% of our consumer spending. Uh, this imbalance, I mean, it was Plutarch who said it to the Athenians 2000 years ago. The imbalance between the rich and the poor is the oldest and most fatal ailment of all republics. Fast forward today, so this concentration, it’s *** very real issue, and we’re gonna have to address that. And, but we have to address it, I think, very thoughtfully and systemically, and I think we have to have it through the lens of *** national, uh, reform. What we’ve done is the exact opposite with HR 1, which is gonna explode deficits. In the United States of America and debt and again it’s transferred the tax burden to small businesses, farmers, and ranchers. Uh, it is an abomination and it’s *** policy unfortunately the Trump administration is very proud of. Do you think *** national reform is enough? I mean, *** lot of this capital is really global. It’s, I mean, this is *** challenge for all of us across the globe and so the challenge is. Do you have *** redistribution mindset or *** predistribution mindset? Do you have *** progressive tax structure that can balance these things? And this is the iteration in the state of California, and this is our approximation, and I think California’s figured it out in many respects. I mean, our economic, our, our entire entrepreneurial system is thriving. In our state where I think found that balance, we had the highest contribution of venture capital last year in our history, $106 billion 68% of it went back into the state of California, despite our progressive tax structure. Well, you know, from the tweets to Plutarch, thank you, thank you so much, Governor. Thank you guys. Thank you everybody for being here. Thank you. Thank you for the tweets.
California becomes first state to join GOARN, a World Health Organization network, Newsom’s office says
The news comes after the Trump administration withdrew the United States from the World Health Organization
California has become the first — and so far only — state to join the World Health Organization’s Global Outbreak Alert and Response Network (GOARN), Gov. Newsom’s office announced on Friday. The news comes a day after the United States finalized its withdrawal from the WHO. (Video Above: Gov. Newsom’s full talk at the 2026 World Economic Forum)Newsom’s office said GOARN is a WHO-coordinated network that brings together hundreds of public health institutions, national governments, labs, academic centers and response organizations across the globe. “The Trump administration’s withdrawal from the WHO is a reckless decision that will hurt all Californians and Americans. California will not bear witness to the chaos this decision will bring,” Newsom said in a news release. “We will continue to foster partnerships across the globe and remain at the forefront of public health preparedness, including through our membership as the only state in WHO’s Global Outbreak Alert & Response Network.”Although the California Department of Public Health is the only state-led institution included in GOARN, there are several other U.S.-based entities, including academic institutions and crisis response organizations. The One Health Institute from UC Davis is also listed as a GOARN partner. Newsom’s office said the governor met with WHO Director-General Dr. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus during his recent trip to Switzerland to discuss the collaboration. See more coverage of top California stories here | Download our app | Subscribe to our morning newsletter | Find us on YouTube here and subscribe to our channel
SACRAMENTO, Calif. —
California has become the first — and so far only — state to join the World Health Organization’s Global Outbreak Alert and Response Network (GOARN), Gov. Newsom’s office announced on Friday.
(Video Above: Gov. Newsom’s full talk at the 2026 World Economic Forum)
Newsom’s office said GOARN is a WHO-coordinated network that brings together hundreds of public health institutions, national governments, labs, academic centers and response organizations across the globe.
“The Trump administration’s withdrawal from the WHO is a reckless decision that will hurt all Californians and Americans. California will not bear witness to the chaos this decision will bring,” Newsom said in a news release. “We will continue to foster partnerships across the globe and remain at the forefront of public health preparedness, including through our membership as the only state in WHO’s Global Outbreak Alert & Response Network.”
Although the California Department of Public Health is the only state-led institution included in GOARN, there are several other U.S.-based entities, including academic institutions and crisis response organizations. The One Health Institute from UC Davis is also listed as a GOARN partner.
Newsom’s office said the governor met with WHO Director-General Dr. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus during his recent trip to Switzerland to discuss the collaboration.
A federal judge ruled Friday that President Trump’s administration must keep federal funds flowing to child care subsidies and other social service programs in five Democratic states — at least for now.
The ruling Friday from U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick extends by two weeks a temporary one issued earlier this month that blocked the federal government from holding back the money from California, Colorado, Illinois, Minnesota and New York. That expires Friday.
The judge said he’d decide later whether the money is to remain in place while a challenge to cutting it off works its way through the courts.
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services said earlier this month that it was pausing the funding because it had “reason to believe” the states were granting benefits to people in the country illegally, though it did not provide evidence or explain why it was targeting those states and not others.
The states say the move was instead intended to damage Mr. Trump’s political adversaries.
A judge previously gave the states a reprieve to the administration’s plan to halt funding for the states unless they provide information on the beneficiaries of some programs, including names and Social Security numbers. The temporary restraining order was set to expire Friday.
Around the same time as the actions aimed at the five states, the administration put up hurdles to Minnesota for even more federal dollars. It also began requesting all states to explain how they’re using money in the child care program.
The programs are the Child Care and Development Fund, which subsidizes child care for 1.3 million children from low-income families nationwide; the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program, which provides cash assistance and job training; and the Social Services Block Grant, a smaller fund that provides money for a variety of programs. The states say that they receive a total of more more than $10 billion a year from those programs — and that the programs are essential for low-income and vulnerable families.
HHS sent letters to the states on Jan. 5 and 6 telling them they would be placed on “restricted drawdown” of program money until the states provided more information.
For TANF and the Social Service Block Grant, the request required the states to submit the data, including personal information of recipients beginning in 2022, with a deadline of Jan. 20.
In court papers last week, the states said what they describe as a funding freeze does not follow the law.
They said Congress created laws about how the administration can identify noncompliance or fraud by recipients of the money — and that the federal government hasn’t used that process.
They also said it’s improper to freeze funding broadly because of potential fraud and that producing the data the government called for is an “impossible demand on an impossible timeline.”
In a court filing this week, the administration objected to the states describing the action as a “funding freeze,” even though the headline on the HHS announcement was: “HHS Freezes Child Care and Family Assistance Grants in Five States for Fraud Concerns.”
Federal government lawyers said the states could get the money going forward if they provide the requested information and the federal government finds them to be in compliance with anti-fraud measures.
The administration also notes that it has continued to provide funding to the states, not pointing out that a court ordered it to do so.
California is once again breaking ranks with the Trump administration, this time over the World Health Organization.
Gov. Gavin Newsom’s office announced Friday that the Golden State is the first and, so far, only state to join the WHO’s Global Outbreak Alert and Response Network (GOARN). The move comes one day after the Trump administration announced the U.S. had officially withdrawn from the WHO.
California joined GOARN back in September. Only sovereign nations can be official dues-paying members of the WHO. There are no dues for being part of GOARN.
Newsom called the U.S. exiting the WHO “reckless” and warned it could be harmful to public health.
With GOARN, California doctors will have global access to early warning systems and data sharing to prepare for potential virus outbreaks.
NBC Bay Area’s Emma Goss has more in the video report above.