[ad_1]
In 2008, Taylor Swift was not only coming up in the world of music with her sophomore album, Fearless, but, more importantly, Britney Spears was making an unexpected and unprecedented “return” after, just months prior, being written off by the media as “never going to come back from” her much publicized mental breakdown. The one most closely associated with the illustrious images of her shaving her own head at a Tarzana hair salon on February 16, 2007. Although her performance at the VMAs later that year was meant to be her much-too-rushed “comeback,” Spears famously “bombed” (by the previous standards she had set for herself) while freely lip-syncing “Gimme More,” the lead single from Blackout. The performance was panned, unjustly so, and Spears went on a continuing emotional spiral for the rest of the year that led to her infamously and tragically being strapped to a gurney on January 3, 2008. A horrendous start to the new year.
As was being placed in a conservatorship soon after on February 1, 2008. Meanwhile, Swift was building up toward releasing Fearless, which would come out in mid-November of that year. The same month that Spears released Circus, her sixth album. In celebration of its release, the title track and second single was put out on December 2nd, Spears’ twenty-seventh birthday (and, to be sure, there were many people who, earlier that year, probably thought Spears was at risk of joining the “27 Club”). The accompanying video, directed by Francis Lawrence (who had previously directed Spears’ perhaps more iconic “I’m a Slave 4 U”), not only centers on various product placements (chief among them, Bvlgari and Spears’ own fragrance), but also Spears as the ringleader of a circus. Yet, despite this theme, there is an undeniable element of “showgirl-ness” to the costumes she wears, in addition to appearing in a dressing room with a brightly-lit vanity mirror before taking her place at the center of the ring.
And with just the opening verse alone, Spears says more about what it means to be a “showgirl” (a.k.a. born performer) than the entirety of Taylor Swift’s The Life of a Showgirl album: “There’s only two types of people in the world: the ones that entertain and the ones that observe/Well, baby, I’m a put-on-a-show kind of girl/Don’t like the back seat/Gotta be first.”
By this time in the video, the viewer has already caught a glimpse of her wearing a see-through number while standing in front of a signature red curtain—the kind that only hangs in front of a stage, used in many an “old-timey” theater. Soon after, she’s walking through the fairgrounds, interacting with her fellow performers by dancing with them. After all, the song is also primarily about her love for this form of expression, and the ways in which dancing in certain environments can create the same kind of chaotic atmosphere as a circus ring. That atmosphere further compounded by the presence of all manner of performers, including a contortionist, ribbon twirler and stiltwalker.
Spears joins in with her fellow showpeople in the center of the ring for a high-octane dance number that proves her assertion, “I’m like a firecracker, I make it hot/When I put on a show/I feel the adrenaline movin’ through my veins/Spotlight on me and I’m ready to break/I’m like a performer, the dance floor is my stage/Better be ready, hope that you feel the same.”
For it is the essence of a showgirl (an inherent people-pleaser) to want the audience to respond to the enthusiastic energy they’re giving off. Spears, even despite being forced to be a “workhorse” for her family throughout every tour starting from 2009’s The Circus Starring Britney Spears, always wanted that positive reaction from those taking in her spectacle. Yet, even though Spears initially boasts of being the one to watch in “Circus,” unlike Swift, she proves herself a more legitimate showgirl in that she actually wants “the common folk” to be a part of her show, urging, “Don’t stand there watching me, follow me/Show me what you can do/Everybody let go, we can make a dance floor/Just like a circus.”
The showgirl element of the “Circus” video begins to really ramp up once she starts to do her “whip and chair choreography” (timed for the moment when she sings, “I run a tight ship, so beware”), soon followed by one of the most visually stunning moments, when Spears is shown in profile as sparks fly above her, raining down behind her, in fact. Something she’s unfazed by, as any seasoned showgirl would be. This is but a preamble to dancing inside a ring that’s now on fire (a.k.a. a ring of fire). And no one knew/knows that metaphor better than Spears, who endured far more flak and scrutiny during the span of 2006-2008 alone than Swift has gotten in her entire career.
Regardless, it’s apparent that Swift is but one of many millennial girls who very much wanted to be Spears (or at least be as adored as her). This being a key reason why “The Life of a Showgirl” featuring Sabrina Carpenter (a fellow Brit enthusiast and frequent homage-payer), the final track on said album, almost comes across as though it was inspired, in some sense, by Britney—the ultimate millennial showgirl. The one who, in Swift’s mind, would have warned/cautioned her against becoming a pop star (the modern equivalent of a showgirl). Thus, Swift painting the picture of visiting a star backstage after seeing her perform. This includes the verses, “I said, ‘You’re living my drеam’/Then she said to me/‘Hеy, thank you for the lovely bouquet/You’re sweeter than a peach/But you don’t know the life of a showgirl, babe/And you’re never, ever gonna/Wait, the more you play, the more that you pay/You’re softer than a kitten, so/You don’t know the life of a showgirl, babe/And you’re never gonna wanna.”
Although Spears posted side-by-side images of the two known photographs of her and Swift together with the caption that the first time they met was during the Oops!… I Did It Again Tour “in 2003,” that doesn’t really track considering that said tour ended in 2001. More plausibly, Swift would have met Spears while she was on 2004’s The Onyx Hotel Tour, at which time Swift would have been fourteen (turning fifteen after that tour ended in mid-2004). Whatever the specifics of the meeting, it happened, and it undeniably influenced Swift. A much as Spears’ music and various indelible performances, whether live or in the music video format. For Swift, that Spears influence was revealed in a very blatant manner just three years after Spears debuted her ringleader costume at The Circus Starring Britney Spears.
While performing “We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together” at the 2012 MTV Europe Music Awards, Swift essentially re-created not only the entire “Circus” video, but also donned a ringleader ensemble that was very similar to the kind that Spears wore for her The Circus tour. Undoubtedly, Spears’ showmanship for the Circus era played a part in this specific rendition. And, funnily enough, Swift would have met Spears for the second time after becoming famous in September of 2008 at the MTV VMAs, when Swift was nominated for the lone, measly award of “Best New Artist.” An image that reveals the stark contrast between before and after fame, as Swift looks far less, shall we say, “rough-hewn” in it.
Alas, for all that Britney might have “taught” Taylor about the life of a showgirl, it still never seemed to sink in that having “grit” (like Brit) is what really makes such a performer. And while Swift might insist she has that combination of chutzpah and tenacity with a song like “I Can Do It With a Broken Heart,” there’s no denying that Spears not only earned her stripes in a way that “softer than a kitten” Taylor never had to, but also the fact that she smiled through her pain in a way that Swift could never possibly fathom. In this regard alone, Spears has more to say about the life of a showgirl than Swift, with “Circus” itself (in spite of being produced and co-written by, unfortunately, Dr. Luke) having more bona fide showgirl dazzle in its three minutes and twelve seconds than the entire forty-one minutes and forty seconds of The Life of a Showgirl.
[ad_2]
Genna Rivieccio
Source link













