Getting ready for New York Fashion Week always sends me into a very specific spiral. On one hand, I want something new—something exciting, trend-forward, and worthy of being photographed between shows. On the other, I know from experience that the pieces I end up reaching for the most are the ones I already trust. The coat that always works. The shoes I can actually walk in. The bag that somehow goes with everything. So this season, as I was mentally mapping out outfits (and resisting the urge to buy everything), I started wondering what the rest of our editors were doing.
I asked a few of my fellow Who What Wear editors to share exactly what they’re buying for NYFW—and what they’re happily rewearing instead. The result is a very real snapshot of how we’re actually getting dressed right now. Yes, there are a few strategic new purchases in the mix, but there’s also a lot of outfit repeating, smart layering, and pieces that have already earned their place in our wardrobes.
Ahead, four of us break down the eight new items we’re most excited to debut this Fashion Week, alongside eight older favorites we’ll be wearing again. Because if NYFW has taught us anything, it’s that the best outfits are rarely built from scratch.
Bobby Schuessler, Shopping Director
Vince
High-Waist Pleated Trouser
Something old: “Vince cuts some of my favorite trousers—all about the fabric, fit, and quality. I wear this specific wide-leg pair all the time, and I’m going to be anchoring many of my fashion week looks with them (probably styled with a turtleneck sweater and a faux-fur coat).”
COS
Chunky Cashmere Mock-Neck Sweater
Something new: “The famous COS cashmere sweaters continue to speak to me. This red iteration will make my outfits pop.”
Audry Hiaoui, Associate Shopping Editor
Free People
Vagabond Blanca Tall Boots
Something old: “NYFW being in February as someone who hates to be cold requires a lot more thought than in September in my opinion. These black knee-high boots from Vagabond have been my go-to whenever I want to be warm enough, but still look put together. I wear them all the time with longer skirts, with thermal tights hidden underneath.”
Loulou De Saison
Cara Super 120s Wool Pencil Skirt
Something new: “Whenever I’m in need of last minute clothes, I pretty consistently end up looking through Nordstrom’s Space section for pieces that feel a bit more unique and curated, but still have fast shipping.”
Ana Escalante, Associate Features Editor
GU
Balmacaan A-Line Half Coat
Something new: “I picked up this GU coat during a preview of the brand’s newest spring collection and, unlike other trench coats I own, the subtle, flared A-Line shape feels so girlish and different. I can’t stop wearing it, and I know I’ll bust it out on a colder (or car-heavy!) day during fashion week.”
Gap
High Rise Barrel Jeans
Something old: “Okay, these are technically newer-ish to me, but I’ve had them for the last two months and I haven’t been able to stop wearing them at least once a week. The shape and tone of them is so perfect, so I just know I’ll base several of my fashion week ‘fits around them.”
Ganni
Printed Flock Denim Baggy
Something new: “I picked up this pair of printed denim in Ganni’s Copenhagen flagship store, and I can’t for them to make their New York Fashion Week debut with all of my outfits. They’re an instant street style photographer-stopper.”
Verafied
Silver Noir Éclair Bag
Something old: “Ask any NYC It girl and they’ll tell you, Verafied is the new up-and-coming accessories brand to watch. I love my east-west handbag from them, and every time I wear it out someone alway stops to ask me where it’s from. If you’re looking for the ultimate compliment magnet whether you’re going to New York Fashion Week or not, boy do I have the bag for you.”
Madewell
The Lexie Ankle Boot
Something new: “On my quest to find the best black ankle boots in New York City, I added these Madewell booties to cart. Their subtle, western-inspired shape and blockier heel means they’re perfect to wear with my jeans and fringe coats while zipping around from show to show.”
Heaven Mayhem
Baby Knot Earrings
Something old: “These Heaven Mayhem baby knot earrings—a classic from the brand, are constantly in my rotation in both the gold and silver. Instantly outfit upgrade in my book.”
Gigi Burris
Lauren Pillbox Hat
Something new: “Ever since coming back from Copenhagen Fashion Week, I’ve entered my hat arc. After wearing the white version of this hat for a week straight (and getting dozens of compliments), I added the black version to my rotation.”
Uniqlo
Soft Ribbed T-Shirt (long Sleeve)
Something old: “If you see me in the winter, chances are, I’m wearing a chunky sweater with this classic Uniqlo crewneck layering shirt underneath. It’s the perfect base for every outfit and I’ve come back to it, year after year, for all of my winter needs.”
Josephine Hadjiloucas, Assistant Shopping Editor
Reformation
Gale Satin Mid Rise Bias Pant
Something new: “I picked this up earlier this year with the intent of wearing it to NYFW. I’m planning on styling them with an oversized sweater, dainty two-tone earrings, an embroidered clutch, and a pair of kitten heels.”
Repetto
Beige Cendrillon Ballerina Flats
Something old: “Truth be told, I don’t know how old my Reppeto’s actually are. A friend gifted me a second-hand pair a few years ago, and they’ve become a staple in my wardrobe. I expect them to make an appearance at NYFW this season.”
Daniela Guevara, Assistant Social Media Editor
Cecilie Bahnsen
Cecilie Bahnsen X Tnf Sarit Verto Sa Gore-Tex®
Something old: “My something old is actually a pair of shoes that have sat in my closet for a while, up until recently, as NYC has gotten sporadic snow. These boots are the most secure and structured boots I have (hence them being hiking boots), but their waterproof outsole is perfect for climbing over the NYC snow piles. And the classic Cecilie Bahnsen flower motifs keep my outfits feeling feminine in this intense winter weather.”
Etsy
Premium Genuine Super Soft Classic Leather Gloves
Something new: “My something new is my most-worn item in my closet since arriving in the mail mid-January: these stunning teal leather gloves I acquired from Etsy. They are fully lined with fleece and have been the perfect pop of color to my outfits. I’ve loved wearing them recently with my brown corduroy jacket from Fabrique.”
Explore More: