Sarah Brady Shares More Alleged Jonah Hill Texts, Claims Actor Was “Sexting” Her After Their Breakup

Sarah Brady, the professional surfer and law student who previously dated Jonah Hill, has released more screenshots of alleged text messages between her and the actor in August 2022, showing a conversation about his then-new relationship with Olivia Millar.

In the screenshots, which Brady shared on Instagram Stories Monday, Hill allegedly wrote, “I know I don’t need to but in the spirit of pure respect to our friendship and appreciation for each other I did want to be transparent that I did start dating someone recently.”

He allegedly continues, “I’m sorry if that is painful. It just happened and I didn’t want to not be transparent with you ever as I care about you.”

In the screenshots, Brady responds in a text the next day by asking Hill to respect her “own personal chicks before dicks code” and “make that woman aware of how recently you’ve been flirting with me, sexting me, and leaning on me for partner level emotional support.”

In response, Hill allegedly asked Brady not to “ruin all the kindness. You’re better than that.”

Brady then responded with a screenshot of a July text from Hill telling her he’s “holding my hard [redacted].” Hill shot back by telling her that “screenshotting intimate texts between us is a huge triggering violation for me and breach of trust as a friend.” He goes on to tell her that “you have been treated in fact incredibly both emotionally and financially.”

This flood of screenshots of alleged exchanges is a continuation of Brady’s public claims that began last week, accusing Hill of controlling and gaslighting behavior during their relationship that started in 2021 and ended sometime in 2022. She showed screenshots of alleged texts from Hill claiming that “your therapist thinks I suck. I literally am the best boyfriend. On earth.” She also claims he told her to delete photos of herself in swimsuits, not surf with men, and cut off friendships with “unstable women,” among other demands.

Hill and Millar welcomed their first child recently, his team confirmed to the press, though details and the exact date of this event have not been shared. Hill has been vocal in his desire to stay out of the spotlight and was noticeably absent from sister Beanie Feldstein’s wedding this May. In August 2022, around the same time that Brady claims the latest text messages she shared were sent, Hill wrote an open letter explaining that he’d be opting out of promoting his films because of mental health struggles and anxiety attacks.

In previous Instagram stories, Brady claimed that Hill had been “running out of ways to manipulate me” and began “questioning my sanity and medications” in relation to her bipolar disorder diagnosis.

In one of the stories she posted Monday, Brady commented that “It may seem as if I am sharing a lot, but you all have no idea how much more there is which I am choosing not to share out of consideration for him and his family.”

In a post to her Instagram feed July 7, Brady shared a photo of herself in a crop top and skirt, captioning it “reviving a pic I took down by request of a narcissistic misogynist.” 

Vanity Fair has reached out to Hill’s reps for comment.