Cape May Peanut Butter Company spreads smiles

Cape May, NJ — Cape May Peanut Butter Company has been spreading smiles for 13 years, offering everything from peanut butter nonpareils to cookie fries with peanut butter dips, and all-natural dog biscuits that help support Animal Outreach.

With flavors like honey roasted, cappuccino, and butterscotch, every batch needs that “wow” factor before it hits the shelves.

Owners Carl and Susan Spatocco built the shop to be “The Happiest Place in Cape May,” and it’s a place where you can literally eat your way through the store.