3 Options for the Detroit Lions Emergency Quarterback in 2025

The Detroit Lions enter the 2025 season with only two quarterbacks on the roster: Jared Goff and Kyle Allen. Normally, that’s all you need. But what if both went down in the same game? NFL rules allow teams to designate an emergency QB from another position, and in Detroit’s case, the Lions have a few intriguing options.

David Montgomery: The Safe Pick

If the Lions were ever forced into this situation, the most realistic choice would be David Montgomery.

• Montgomery already has experience in wildcat formations, taking direct snaps and powering forward.
• Detroit likely wouldn’t try to throw much without a true quarterback, instead relying on safe handoffs, simple option looks, and Montgomery’s tough running style to grind out possessions.
• His vision and ability to pick up tough yards make him the “steady hands” option in what would be a chaotic scenario.

In other words, if you’re protecting the football and trying to survive until the final whistle, Montgomery is the guy you trust.

Amon-Ra St. Brown: The Trick-Play Option

That said, Amon-Ra St. Brown could still get a look.

• He’s already been used in trick plays and has shown some ability to throw.
• With his football IQ and leadership, he’d be capable of managing a simplified passing game if Detroit wanted to take a shot or two downfield.

Still, given the stakes of an emergency situation, St. Brown’s role would probably be limited to one or two surprise throws rather than running the full offense.

Kalif Raymond: The Wildcard

If the Lions wanted to inject speed and creativity, Kalif Raymond is another candidate.

• Known for his gadget-play usage, Raymond has the quickness to make things interesting.
• He could run wildcat-style packages, relying on jet sweeps, misdirection, and quick-hitting plays to keep defenses on their toes.
• While not a passer, his athleticism could give Detroit a spark in short bursts.

The Bottom Line

In reality, the Lions would do everything possible to avoid reaching this point. But if both Jared Goff and Kyle Allen were sidelined, expect David Montgomery to be the most-likely emergency quarterback.

St. Brown and Raymond could sprinkle in gadget plays, but Montgomery’s ability to run the football, protect possessions, and manage the game makes him the safest bet.