As an example, someone who considered themselves fortunate to secure a 5-year variable rate mortgage at 0.9% in early 2022 may have seen their interest rate soar to 5.4%, leading to a significantly higher required payment. For some, this situation is painful, and for others, it becomes unmanageable. In extreme cases, selling the home they purchased just a few years ago, because they can no longer afford it, may be their only recourse.
Furthermore, demand from foreign buyers has also been curtailed by the Canadian government’s recent ban on non-Canadians purchasing property. Resident investors, who have significantly contributed to home price inflation, are also likely to be affected by higher interest rates and diminishing cash flow.
When will the Toronto real estate bubble burst? While pinpointing the exact timing of Toronto’s potential real estate correction remains challenging, signs of deflation may already be underway. The TRREB has its benchmark prices, designed to estimate the value of a typical home in the area without distortion from outliers. In October, the real estate board reported the benchmark at $1,103,600, indicating a 2.1% dip from September’s $1,127,000.
The prospect of a prolonged period of increased interest rates, driven by the Bank of Canada’s cautious stance amid inflation concerns, alongside reduced affordability, restrictions on foreign buyers, and decreased local investor activity due to higher interest rates, suggests the potential for further market deflation.
When will housing prices hit bottom?
Prices are dropping in Toronto, and in Canada as a whole. However, it’s uncertain whether prices will continue to decline or not. The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) forecasted home prices to increase in 2024. And according to recent stats from real estate firm Wahl’s 2023 GTA Housing Snapshot Report, underbidding has been rising over the past five months (81% in October). To me, the growth underbidding indicates there are less buyers and lower prices.
Optimists may argue we’ve seen this environment before, with affordability as the ongoing issue. They may contend that the lack of housing supply and the resilience of the housing market will continue to drive up home values. However, certain conditions such as astronomical inflation and rapid interest rate increases have not been seen in decades. This present landscape contains a new set of headlines, setting the stage for potential falling home prices.
While it’s impossible to definitively predict if and when the Toronto real estate market will experience a downturn, it’s evident that skyrocketing prices have created an affordability problem for many.
Simultaneously, though, it disproportionately benefited others, such as property investors. Despite current conditions suggesting diminishing housing demand, including that of investors, policy makers in Canada, including Toronto, must address and moderate this type of demand in the future. Even after interest rates come down.
Michael Pe, CFA
Source link
