‘I Cannot Remember All Of Them’: Inside The Brutal Crimes Of Suspected Serial Killer Larry Hall

In 1994, Larry Hall admitted to police that he’d killed dozens of women and girls across the Midwest — but he immediately recanted his confession.

Wikimedia CommonsLarry Hall’s 1994 mugshot.

The true crime miniseries Black Bird follows James “Jimmy” Keene as he goes undercover to extract a confession from suspected serial killer Larry Hall. The show is based on Keene’s 2010 memoir, In with the Devil, which recounts his very real experience with Hall, a man who may be responsible for more than 40 murders.

But just who is Larry Hall? Unlike other serial killers like Ted Bundy and Jeffrey Dahmer, the exact details of Hall’s life and crimes haven’t been widely publicized despite the fact that he may be one of the most prolific serial killers in American history.

Although Hall admitted to killing dozens of women and girls throughout the 1980s and ’90s, he immediately recanted his confession. He was sentenced to life in prison for kidnapping a 15-year-old in 1993, but he was never charged with her murder — or the murders of any of his other potential victims.

Still, the details about Larry Hall’s life that have been made public paint a picture of a highly disturbed man capable of committing some of the most heinous acts imaginable. This is his story.

The Troubled Childhood Of Larry Hall

Larry Dewayne Hall and his twin brother Gary were born on Dec. 11, 1962, in Wabash, Indiana. The two boys were monochorionic twins, meaning they shared a placenta. Unfortunately for Hall, his brother received the majority of the nutrients and oxygen in the womb, so newborn Larry was rushed to the neonatal intensive care unit soon after he was born.

Because of the medical issues surrounding his development and birth, Larry Hall suffered from cognitive delays. His peers made fun of him for his speech impediment and the fact that he wet his bed well into childhood.

Additionally, as Gary Hall recalled to CNN in 2011, Larry was awkward growing up and showed signs of destructive behavior.

“He was the backward twin. I was the more dominant, outgoing twin,” Gary said. He claimed that he tried to be a good influence on his brother, but to no avail. According to Gary, Larry was “evil” — and even tried to kill him on more than one occasion.

Once, Gary recalled, “I just woke up out of a sound sleep to see my brother standin’ over me with this humongous long limb, getting ready to smash my skull.”

Larry Hall’s first brush with the law came when he was 15, when he and Gary were caught breaking the windows of a store. One of the police officers who questioned them after the incident later recalled, “It took a long time before we could crack the Hall brothers. They were just kids, but they held up better than hardened criminals.”

It wouldn’t be the last time Larry Hall baffled investigators.

Inside Larry Hall’s Alleged Killing Spree

After high school, Hall began traveling across the Midwest to participate in Civil War reenactments. Oddly, it seemed that girls and young women would go missing in each town that Hall visited.

It’s not clear who Hall’s first victim was, but in June 1982, 19-year-old Naomi Kidder went missing in Wyoming. When police eventually arrested Hall for other crimes 12 years later, they found a document with Kidder’s name on it among his possessions.

But the case that finally put Larry Hall on investigators’ radar was the disappearance of a 15-year-old girl named Jessica Roach from Georgetown, Illinois, in September 1993. She was last seen riding her bicycle near her home. Two months later, her body was discovered in an Indiana cornfield.

Witnesses had seen a strange van driving through the cornfield around the time Roach’s body was found — and police traced the license plate number back to Hall.

What’s more, another teenager named Tricia Lynn Reitler had vanished in Indiana six months prior to Roach’s disappearance, and the girls’ cases were oddly similar.

Family of Tricia ReitlerTricia Reitler, circa 1993. To this day, her family is unsure of what happened to her.

On March 29, 1993, 19-year-old Reitler had been in the middle of writing a term paper when she decided to take a break. She left her dorm and went to a store just half a mile away to pick up a soda and a magazine.

She never returned to her room.

Instead, police believe Reitler was abducted during her walk back. Her parents believe she was killed that very night — but her body has never been found.

Larry Hall Confesses To The Murder Of Jessica Roach

Investigators had never heard of Larry Hall before linking his vehicle to Jessica Roach’s disappearance. But as soon as they brought him in, it was obvious that he knew something.

Gary Miller, the chief investigator for the Vermillion County Sheriff’s Office in Illinois, brought Hall into the Wabash police station for questioning and showed him a picture of Jessica.

“He immediately flinched. He turned to his right and put his hand up over his face like he didn’t want to see the picture. And he told me he didn’t think he’d ever seen that girl,” Miller said.

It didn’t take long for Hall to confess. He admitted to investigators that he had raped Jessica, then led her to the woods and strangled her from behind so that she wouldn’t have to see his face as she died.

“I laid her up against a tree and put a belt around her neck and she stopped breathing,” he said.

FacebookJessica Roach, the young girl who Larry Hall confessed to kidnapping and killing.

Jessica Roach, investigators believe, was abducted just down the street from her home while riding her bicycle. And she wasn’t the only one.

Hall admitted to having hurt other girls — including Tricia Reitler, who he identified by pointing to her picture.

“All of the girls looked alike. I cannot remember all of them. I picked up several girls in other areas, but I can’t remember which ones I hurt,” he said.

Then, the next day, he recanted everything, telling investigators, “I was just tellin’ you about my dreams. That didn’t really happen.”

And unfortunately, this is something Larry Hall would do frequently. Investigators had a difficult time nailing down a confession from Hall that he would not later recant, and so they needed someone on the inside who could get a real confession from him. They found their man in Jimmy Keene.

Jimmy Keene Went Undercover To Get A Confession From Larry Hall

According to Newsweek, when investigators initially searched Hall’s van, they found several pieces of incriminating evidence including a knife and a missing poster for Tricia Reitler.

In 1995, he was ultimately found guilty of kidnapping Jessica Roach and sentenced to life in prison, but there were still many questions left unanswered. How many girls had Larry Hall actually killed? Was he truly the man responsible for Tricia Reitler’s disappearance? If so, where was her body?

Meanwhile, Jimmy Keene had been arrested on drug-related charges and sentenced to 10 years in prison. Both Hall and Keene were prosecuted by former Assistant U.S. Attorney Lawrence Beaumont. Beaumont later met with Keene several months into his sentence to work out a deal with him: If he would go undercover and get a confession from Larry Hall, he would be freed and his record would be scrubbed clean.

Apple/XActor Taron Egerton, who portrays Jimmy Keene in Apple TV+’s Black Bird, on set with the real Jimmy Keene.

Naturally, Keene accepted and was sent undercover to the Medical Center for Federal Prisoners in Springfield, Missouri. There, he befriended Hall and got him to talk about how he had killed Jessica Roach. Keene also said that Hall had confessed to him about killing Reitler, and how she had tried to fight him off.

At one point, Keene observed Hall in the prison wood shop, carving falcons and looking over a map with several marked locations. Keene said that Hall told him the falcons “watch over the dead,” leading Keene to believe the marked locations were the spots where Hall had killed his alleged victims.

Now, Keene felt he had solved the case. He called the FBI and left them a message about the map. Believing that he would soon be pulled out of prison, Keene confronted Hall about the alleged killings — and got himself sent to solitary confinement.

Unfortunately for Keene, the FBI never got his message. He spent weeks in solitary confinement, and when he was released, Hall had discarded the map and the falcons.

Gary Hall eventually convinced his brother to confess to 15 murders, but once again, Hall recanted the confession. In 2011, he confessed to his role in the disappearance of Laurie Depies in 1992, and shared details about the case with investigators that had not been made public. Five years later, police linked him to the 1986 killing of Eulalia Mylia Chavez — another murder he had confessed to and later recanted.

Ultimately though, no one is entirely certain how many murders Larry Hall is actually responsible for, other than Hall himself. He is still serving his life sentence at a medium-security federal prison in Butner, North Carolina.

After learning about Larry Hall and his numerous suspected killings, learn about the gruesome crimes of Jason Alan Thornburg, the Texas serial killer suspected of making “biblical sacrifices.” Then, discover the story of Wayne Nance, the suspected serial killer who terrorized Montana.