Downsizing With $700,000 on the East Side of Manhattan, Where ‘Charm Is More Expensive’

Downsizing With 0,000 on the East Side of Manhattan, Where ‘Charm Is More Expensive’

Tracy and Thomas Forzaglia landed a great pandemic deal. Their charming prewar rental in the Lenox Hill neighborhood of Manhattan had two bedrooms, two bathrooms, five closets and a terrace, all for around $4,775 a month.

“It was such a beautiful apartment, just like Mrs. Maisel,” Mrs. Forzaglia said. “It was more space than we needed. Nobody needs a foyer, but we had one. I could have done yoga in the foyer.”

It wasn’t perfect: On the terrace, roaches would scatter when the couple turned on the twinkle lights. Worse, there was a pending construction project next door, with a 21-story condominium tower planned. And the kitchen offered “a front-row seat of them digging a very large hole,” she said.

The construction was especially problematic for Mr. Forzaglia, who works from home as a software engineer. Mrs. Forzaglia, a metadata librarian, does so one day a week. What’s more, their post-pandemic rent was set to rise to $5,400.

[Did you recently buy a home? We want to hear from you. Email: thehunt@nytimes.com]

Last summer, the Forzaglias got serious about finding a smaller place to buy — one that would require a smaller monthly outlay — in the area east of Central Park. “Rents were getting out of hand,” Mr. Forzaglia said. “We wanted less variability in our monthly costs.”

They contacted David Son, a licensed real estate agent at Douglas Elliman, whom they had met at an open house. “When you’re making a purchase, there are other things than just the apartment itself to consider,” Mr. Son said. “And going through a first-time co-op purchase, there are a lot of rules, regulations and policies that most people are not familiar with.”

The Forzaglias were willing to sacrifice prewar charm in favor of a cookie-cutter one-bedroom in a newish co-op building, which they felt would offer better infrastructure with a lower risk of breakdowns and assessments — something bland but serviceable. “Charm is more expensive,” Mrs. Forzaglia said.

They set a budget of up to $700,000. Because they would be downsizing, they sought a workable layout and plenty of storage. Mr. Forzaglia has video game equipment and five bass guitars. “Each bass has its own kind of sound,” he explained, “so each one fits a different song.”

Mrs. Forzaglia wanted space for shoes, bags and beauty products. “I am not a beauty editor,” she said, “but I have a closet that looks like I am.”

Among their options:

Find out what happened next by answering these two questions:

Joyce Cohen

Source link