Why ‘Change Management’ Almost Always Fails (and How to Do It Right)

“If ever there is a misnomer, it’s change management. It rarely causes change—and it’s almost always mismanaged.”

That’s how Phil Gilbert, former head of design at IBM, opens his new book Irresistible Change: A Blueprint for Earning Buy-In and Breakout Success.

Gilbert argues that most change efforts fail because they rely on the wrong mental model: a mix of top-down mandates and one-size-fits-all training. Real transformation comes from willing adoption, he says.

“Our CEO never required even one of our 400,000 people to change,” Gilbert recalls. “Instead, we designed a program introducing change that people chose to adopt, in the same way they would adopt any great product or service. In a word, we made change irresistible.”

Here are three strategies from Irresistible Change that leaders can use to make culture change stick.

1. Brand it like a Louis Vuitton

Most change efforts are framed around the mechanics, like an “AI First” initiative. Gilbert says that’s a mistake.

“When you call a transformation a specific method or technology, you not only tend to focus too much on that one thing, but you also inherit all the baggage people already associate with it,” he explains. “When you brand it properly, you get to define what it means for your culture—and you gain permission to influence parts of the organization far beyond the technology itself.”

At IBM, the transformation program was given the intentionally neutral name “Hallmark,” and into that vessel the values underpinning the transformation were poured. Hallmark became a cultural movement about how IBMers worked together to serve clients better—a premium brand, the gold standard for how teams worked.

Leaders can borrow this play: brand your transformation. Make it stand for something deeper than a technology or process. Clarify what values it expresses, not just what techniques it uses. This is as relevant for today’s AI efforts as it was for IBM’s design transformation.

2. True stories, not evangelism

Most leaders evangelize change: big vision decks, mass emails, and quarterly town halls—all promising a beautiful but abstract future. Gilbert says this misses the point.

“Communication isn’t about selling a vision—it’s about building belief,” he explains. “Your teams don’t need promises. They need proof.”

This is no different from how the world is changing. Madison Avenue visions of the future aren’t nearly as powerful these days as personal endorsements from social media influencers. The result was what Gilbert calls “pull”: people wanted in because they heard directly from their trusted peers.

From the earliest days, Gilbert’s team interviewed people who’d opted into the program, then packaged their stories into short videos and posts shared across internal channels. The people doing the work described—in their own voices—how their work and lives were changing, and why it mattered to their clients.

For leaders elsewhere, the lesson is clear. Instead of evangelizing possibilities, build demand through first-hand accounts of success.

3. People + practices + places = outcomes

More than any single tool, culture affects outcomes. Gilbert reveals how he came to understand what culture is made of, and how he developed his formula for scaling culture change.

“Culture is a three-legged stool of people, their practices and the places they live and work,” he says. “If you want new outcomes, you’re going to have to adjust all three.”

New skills are often required during change, but they’re often introduced to people incorrectly. “This isn’t about counting how many people have been trained, it’s about measuring true behavior change,” Gilbert says. This can only happen by driving sustained adoption of new tools inside real-world teams, not the “quick win” approach of temporary “tiger teams” or innovation centers sitting outside the core business.

Practices include not only the tools and methods of teams, but also the systems they operate within. Many, like HR, budgeting, or performance dashboards, are built to reinforce the status quo. If you introduce new skills and tools but don’t update upline metrics or promotion criteria to reward their use, adoption will likely stall.

Places include both physical and remote environments, and their design can either reinforce old norms or signal new ones. For example, Gilbert’s team created a new language for IBM’s physical workspaces that challenged traditional silos and forced human interaction.

For leaders elsewhere, the lesson is simple: if you want new outcomes, there must be changes well beyond inserting a new tool. Organizations, like any system, are built to reinforce the status quo. To achieve real change, you have to loosen that grip. Align people, practices, and places so they all pull in the same direction.

The bottom line

Gilbert’s message is clear: lasting transformation doesn’t come from mandating compliance. It comes from making change irresistible. That means treating change like a premium product: one that people choose to adopt. Irresistible Change offers leaders a practical playbook for doing just that.

The early-rate deadline for the 2026 Inc. Regionals Awards is Friday, November 14, at 11:59 p.m. PT. Apply now.