By Deborah Nicholls-LeeFeatures correspondent
Hans Holbein the Younger acted as a matchmaker to Henry VIII, tasked with painting the portraits of potential wives across Europe in a bid to safeguard the future of the throne. As two new exhibitions open, Deborah Nicholls-Lee looks at how he was the pre-eminent image-maker of the 16th Century.
Whisperings in corridors, prisoners in towers, courtiers and clergy sent to the block – Hans Holbein the Younger (1497-1543), court artist during Henry VIII’s reign, must have seen it all.
The German-Swiss artist was the image-maker of his time, garnering acclaim for his lifelike portraits of Basel’s elite, including the Dutch philosopher and theologian Desiderius Erasmus – who he painted exactly 500 years ago − before travelling to England to work in Tudor society’s uppermost echelons, influencing the course of history by painting the profile pictures of eligible women the King might like to marry, such as Christina of Denmark, as part of a long-distance introduction service.
More like this:
– How a 1574 portrait was made ‘Insta-fabulous’
Preserved by Holbein in pastels, tempera and oil are the famous faces of the tumultuous Tudor court, many of whose lives would soon be cut short. Without these realistic renderings, these key players in 16th-Century history might just be names.
Holbein’s commissions included decorative work such as jewellery, weaponry, woodcuts and frescos, but it is the portraits of illustrious figures like Sir Thomas More, Thomas Cromwell, Jane Seymour and Henry VIII that have most shaped his legacy, ranking among the world’s earliest and finest examples of portraiture.
Getty ImagesThe public can learn more about Holbein’s important place in art history at two recently opened exhibitions. Holbein and the Renaissance in the North at Frankfurt’s Städel Museum explores Holbein’s work – and that of his father, Holbein The Elder – in the context of the Northern Renaissance; while in London’s Buckingham Palace, works from the Royal Collection are on show as part of Holbein at the Tudor Court. This exhibition of more than 100 artifacts, including paintings and miniatures, is centred around 40 portrait sketches – some paired with the completed painting – made during Holbein’s time in England and rarely exhibited due to their fragile nature.
The experience of being up close to these historic characters is “incredible”, says Dr Kate Heard, curator of the Royal Collection’s exhibition and author of the accompanying book, Holbein at the Tudor Court. “You see faces that are known only through Holbein’s portraits − these amazing figures who we read so much about.”
But we also learn about Holbein himself and his perfectionism, evident in the painstaking reworking of a jawline or the profile of a nose. “His character and his concerns come out through the drawings as much as his sitters… You really get the sense of looking over his shoulder and seeing him at work,” Heard tells BBC Culture. “You see him recording texture and colour by smudging chalk or sharp lines; or recording in words: ‘velvet’, ‘satin’, ‘damask’; or ‘it’s black’, ‘it’s purple’, ‘it’s red’.”
Royal Collection Trust / His Majesty King Charles III 2023The exceptional access required for these intimate sittings saw Holbein admitted to Anne Boleyn’s private rooms in the early 1530s, where he sketched her in a satin bedgown, thought to be a gift from the king. Like so many of Holbein’s sitters, she would be executed during Henry’s tempestuous sovereignty, but Holbein had no shortage of patrons and, with Anne gone, his career reached new heights when Henry put him on the royal pay roll and instructed him to paint a mural for his Privy Chamber in Whitehall Palace.
“The extraordinary thing about his position… was his proximity to the inner workings of the court,” Franny Moyle, author of The King’s Painter – The Life and Times of Hans Holbein (2021), tells BBC Culture, describing the closeness to the King as “a measure of your importance”.
But such access was not without risk. Holbein arrived in England as the first of many court dramas was unfolding. The King’s forbidden love for Anne Boleyn, and Rome’s opposition to a divorce from Katherine of Aragon, was about to trigger a radical shift in the power dynamic between monarch and Church, and catapult the country into the Reformation. Those whose opinions were at odds with the King’s risked being tried for treason. “Holbein would have, very early on, witnessed some of Henry’s brutal treatments of dissenters,” says Moyle.
Survival at this turbulent time meant keeping your eyes and ears open, and your mouth firmly closed. “One of the reasons why he was so successful, is he must have been the embodiment of discretion,” says Moyle. “I suspect he did overhear an awful lot, and perhaps people unburdened themselves to him, a bit like a hairdresser.”
Navigating a treacherous terrain
Holbein deftly navigated the court’s shifting sands, moving stealthily between Protestant reformers and Catholics as they fell in and out of favour. He painted Sir Thomas More and the Duke of Norfolk (Thomas Howard), explains Moyle, as well as their arch-rival Thomas Cromwell – all three eventually locked up in Henry’s gruesome Tower of London, while Holbein slipped quietly onto the next client, ever-conscious, no doubt, of the family he had to feed back in Basel, and later also in London.
Holbein’s work required a dancing act between verisimilitude and diplomacy. At times, he appears to flatter his sitters. A comparison of the preparatory drawing and the finished portrait of Sir Henry Guildford reveals that Holbein elongated Guildford’s face, making Guildford appear, says Heard, “a much more authoritative, much more magnificent and a much more powerful figure”.
Getty ImagesElsewhere, there are hints of his antipathy. He makes no attempt to disguise the deep tuberculosis scar on the neck of Sir Richard Southwell, for example, and places him in a rather haughty and unsympathetic pose. Southwell was “a very unpleasant man known for betraying a number of his friends… and Holbein does capture something of that ambition and arrogance,” says Heard. Yet, here − as with the imagery he frequently created for factions − he was inscrutable. “One of the reasons why I think Holbein survived is that he was a complete master of ambiguity in terms of messaging,” says Moyle.
Holbein’s diplomacy was not just in his depictions. The German-speaking artist also played a role in building strategic alliances abroad. The unparalleled verisimilitude of his work saw him acting as a matchmaker to the monarch. Employed as a sort of Tinder for Tudors, he was tasked with painting the portraits of potential wives across Europe in a bid to safeguard the future of the throne and form familial connections with potential enemies overseas. Thomas Cromwell commissioned him to paint a portrait of the 16-year-old widow Christina of Denmark after the death of Henry VIII’s third wife Jane Seymour, and the image piqued the King’s interest when he was looking for a new bride – although the marriage proposal didn’t materialise for political and practical reasons.
Getty ImagesBut his artworks would shed blood. Holbein was sent to paint Anne of Cleves and her younger sister, both of whom were candidates to be the fourth wife of Henry VIII, and instructed to portray them faithfully. Even so, the rather dull Anne did not live up to her portrait, though Holbein’s expressionless front-facing rendition perhaps hinted at a certain plainness. The King reluctantly took her as his wife, but soon found pretexts to dissolve the marriage and to execute Cromwell, who he blamed for the debacle.
Holbein’s survival of the episode speaks to his indispensability to the King. “Art was soft power,” says Moyle. In securing Leonardo da Vinci as court painter, she explains, Francis I of France earnt cultural kudos throughout Europe. England, meanwhile, was still considered a nation of boors, but Holbein changed that. “You have to see Holbein’s tenure at the court in terms of Henry realising he’s got his Leonardo,” says Moyle.
Paintings were also powerful tools of propaganda. Sadly lost but widely copied, Holbein’s bombastic, life-size portrait of Henry VIII (1537), an assertion of prerogative and potency with an oversized codpiece at its centre, was an unambivalent attempt to shore up the King’s monarchic authority and strike fear into the heart of his opponents at a time when he had just declared himself the head of the Church of England.
With illiteracy commonplace, artworks had a cultural currency that it is hard to imagine today, explains Moyle. “Paintings were events: they were held behind curtains and revealed.” They were also powerful diplomatic gifts, sometimes exchanged with a former enemy or given to clients and associates, says Moyle, as “an expression of love and allegiance”. Holbein’s portrait of baby Prince Edward (1538) gifted to the King is a case in point, representing both gratitude for his patronage and, in its echoes of Da Vinci’s Salvator Mundi, tacit support for Henry’s heir as a future leader of Christianity.
Getty ImagesHolbein was careful, clever, and most likely likeable, but it was his unmatched talent that best explains the longevity of his service in such a volatile court. “He didn’t need protection. His skill enabled him to rise to this very senior post of king’s painter,” says Heard. “He does what every other court artist does… but he is creating something absolutely incredible”.
In a period where mirrors were a luxury, and photography was 300 years away, these extraordinarily lifelike people must have seemed ready to step from the frame at any moment. The exhibition Holbein at the Tudor Court closes with a 1533 portrait of German merchant Derich Born. An inscription on the parapet beneath him reads: “If you added a voice, this would be Derich his very self. You would be in doubt whether the painter or his father made him.”
Holbein at the Tudor Court is at the Queen’s Gallery, Buckingham Palace, London until 14 April 2024.
Holbein and the Renaissance in the North is at the Städel Museum in Frankfurt until 18 February 2024.
If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can’t-miss news delivered to your inbox every Friday.
If you would like to comment on this story or anything else you have seen on BBC Culture, head over to our Facebook page or message us on Twitter.